CHAPTER 3

Chapter Three: Values, Ethics, and Legal Obligations

Personal Values

  • Definition: Personal values are preferred conceptions, outcomes, and ways of dealing with people.

  • Influence of Personal Values:

    • Affect one’s perception of the world.

    • Shape personal and professional philosophies and choices.

    • Determine how individuals view human behavior and change.

  • Behavioral Determinants: Behavior is primarily shaped by one's values and beliefs.

Professional Values

  • Core Principles: Professional values typically encompass:

    • Respect

    • Self-determination

    • Social justice

    • Professional integrity

  • Conflict Areas: Personal values may conflict with professional values in areas such as:

    • Religion

    • Health

    • Marriage and family matters

    • Education

    • Role of government

    • Topics surrounding birth and death

    • Honesty and integrity issues.

Ethical Standards

  • Importance of Ethical Codes: Ethical codes concisely describe expected behaviors in interactions between:

    • Professionals and clients

    • Professionals within the field

  • Content of Ethical Codes:

    • Must include detailed instructions on what professionals should and should not do.

Professional Competency and Integrity

  • Definition of Professional Competence: Professional competence involves:

    • Practicing within one's educational and experiential scope.

  • Cultural Competence:

    • Application of cultural knowledge about various individuals and groups into practices, policies, and attitudes to improve outcomes in the helping process.

    • Requires professional self-awareness and situational sensitivity.

Technology and Ethics

  • Response to Technological Ethics:

    • Increasing ethical dilemmas prompted professional associations to update technology-related ethical standards.

  • Use of Technology:

    • Technology can enhance client benefits when guided by ethical practices in application and implementation.

Confidentiality

  • Definition of Confidentiality: Information shared by clients must remain private and not disclosed to others.

  • Reasons to Maintain Confidentiality:

    • To prevent client stigma.

    • Moral obligation to adhere to official ethical standards.

    • To model discretion and trustworthiness.

  • Challenges in Technology: Technology introduces unique difficulties regarding maintaining confidentiality.

Prohibition of Boundary Violations

Part 1: Definition and Importance of Boundaries
  • Boundary Definition: Boundaries delineate distinct entities including:

    • Parents vs. children

    • Clients vs. service providers

    • Health care workers vs. clients

  • Significance:

    • Essential for fostering trust in helping relationships.

  • Considerations for Professionals:

    • Evaluate potential harm and benefits when navigating dual relationships or boundary crossings.

Part 2: Ethical Considerations
  • Avoiding Personal Relationships: Professionals should not enter into client relationships with:

    • Friends

    • Family

  • Self-Disclosure:

    • Self-disclosure is common in U.S. culture but must be approached cautiously in professional contexts.

  • Sexual Relationships:

    • Prohibited by all professional codes and often lead to common ethical complaints.

Part 3: Post-Relationship Considerations
  • Factors to Evaluate in Post-Professional Relationships:

    • Persistent power differentials

    • Potential damage to prior professional relationships

    • Future client return for professional help needs

  • Additional Boundary Violations:

    • Touching clients

    • Accepting gifts

    • Self-disclosure can also violate boundaries depending on context.

Assessment

  • Key Ethical Issues in Assessment: Most ethical codes address:

    • Utilizing assessments within personal scope of practice and training.

    • Full client disclosures and collaborative processes in the assessment procedure.

    • Selection of appropriate instruments based on assessment questions.

  • Standards for Assessment Instruments:

    • Should include standardized procedures and normative data suitable for culturally diverse or disabled clients.

    • Proper administration, scoring, and interpretation are essential.

    • Clients must receive clear explanations of assessment results.

    • All data must remain secure and only shared with qualified individuals.

Informed Consent

  • Definition: Informed consent involves fully disclosing the purposes, goals, techniques, and procedural rules related to assessment and counseling using language that clients can easily understand.

Legal Obligations

  • Differences Between Legal and Ethical Violations:

    • Ethical challenges are typically routed through state licensing boards or relevant professional organizations.

  • Legal Duties to Clients Include:

    • Duty to care

    • Duty to respect privacy

    • Duty to maintain confidentiality

    • Duty to inform

    • Duty to report

    • Duty to warn

Legal Limits to Confidentiality
  • Not Absolute: Confidentiality has legal limitations varying by state.

Civil Legal Challenges

  • Definition of Malpractice:

    • Negligence by a professional when failing to adhere to professional standards.

    • Leads to client injury and is addressed in civil court.

  • Consequences of Malpractice:

    • Can result in fines, loss of professional licensure, damage to reputation, and difficulties in obtaining malpractice insurance.

Minimizing the Risk of Ethical or Legal Challenges

  • Best Practices:

    • Stay updated on practice methods.

    • Maintain thorough documentation.

    • Keep appropriate boundaries (avoid multiple relationships).

Ethical Decision Making

Part 1: Ethical Dilemmas
  • Definition: Ethical dilemmas arise when choosing between two or more conflicting ethical directives, all resulting in potentially undesirable outcomes.

  • Guiding Principles:

    • Beneficence: Promote good.

    • Non-maleficence: Avoid harm.

Part 2: Decision-Making Framework
  • Congress ETHIC Model Components:

    1. Examine all relevant values (client, personal, agency, professional, societal).

    2. Review ethical standards and applicable laws.

    3. Predict potential consequences of various decisions.

Part 3: Collaborative Decision-Making
  • Considerations:

    • Assess all potential beneficiaries and those who might be harmed.

    • Consult with supervisors and colleagues to conceptualize choices.

    • Take into account the insights of supervisors or consultants in final decision-making.

    • Reference: (Congress, 2000, p.10)