CHAPTER 3
Chapter Three: Values, Ethics, and Legal Obligations
Personal Values
Definition: Personal values are preferred conceptions, outcomes, and ways of dealing with people.
Influence of Personal Values:
Affect one’s perception of the world.
Shape personal and professional philosophies and choices.
Determine how individuals view human behavior and change.
Behavioral Determinants: Behavior is primarily shaped by one's values and beliefs.
Professional Values
Core Principles: Professional values typically encompass:
Respect
Self-determination
Social justice
Professional integrity
Conflict Areas: Personal values may conflict with professional values in areas such as:
Religion
Health
Marriage and family matters
Education
Role of government
Topics surrounding birth and death
Honesty and integrity issues.
Ethical Standards
Importance of Ethical Codes: Ethical codes concisely describe expected behaviors in interactions between:
Professionals and clients
Professionals within the field
Content of Ethical Codes:
Must include detailed instructions on what professionals should and should not do.
Professional Competency and Integrity
Definition of Professional Competence: Professional competence involves:
Practicing within one's educational and experiential scope.
Cultural Competence:
Application of cultural knowledge about various individuals and groups into practices, policies, and attitudes to improve outcomes in the helping process.
Requires professional self-awareness and situational sensitivity.
Technology and Ethics
Response to Technological Ethics:
Increasing ethical dilemmas prompted professional associations to update technology-related ethical standards.
Use of Technology:
Technology can enhance client benefits when guided by ethical practices in application and implementation.
Confidentiality
Definition of Confidentiality: Information shared by clients must remain private and not disclosed to others.
Reasons to Maintain Confidentiality:
To prevent client stigma.
Moral obligation to adhere to official ethical standards.
To model discretion and trustworthiness.
Challenges in Technology: Technology introduces unique difficulties regarding maintaining confidentiality.
Prohibition of Boundary Violations
Part 1: Definition and Importance of Boundaries
Boundary Definition: Boundaries delineate distinct entities including:
Parents vs. children
Clients vs. service providers
Health care workers vs. clients
Significance:
Essential for fostering trust in helping relationships.
Considerations for Professionals:
Evaluate potential harm and benefits when navigating dual relationships or boundary crossings.
Part 2: Ethical Considerations
Avoiding Personal Relationships: Professionals should not enter into client relationships with:
Friends
Family
Self-Disclosure:
Self-disclosure is common in U.S. culture but must be approached cautiously in professional contexts.
Sexual Relationships:
Prohibited by all professional codes and often lead to common ethical complaints.
Part 3: Post-Relationship Considerations
Factors to Evaluate in Post-Professional Relationships:
Persistent power differentials
Potential damage to prior professional relationships
Future client return for professional help needs
Additional Boundary Violations:
Touching clients
Accepting gifts
Self-disclosure can also violate boundaries depending on context.
Assessment
Key Ethical Issues in Assessment: Most ethical codes address:
Utilizing assessments within personal scope of practice and training.
Full client disclosures and collaborative processes in the assessment procedure.
Selection of appropriate instruments based on assessment questions.
Standards for Assessment Instruments:
Should include standardized procedures and normative data suitable for culturally diverse or disabled clients.
Proper administration, scoring, and interpretation are essential.
Clients must receive clear explanations of assessment results.
All data must remain secure and only shared with qualified individuals.
Informed Consent
Definition: Informed consent involves fully disclosing the purposes, goals, techniques, and procedural rules related to assessment and counseling using language that clients can easily understand.
Legal Obligations
Differences Between Legal and Ethical Violations:
Ethical challenges are typically routed through state licensing boards or relevant professional organizations.
Legal Duties to Clients Include:
Duty to care
Duty to respect privacy
Duty to maintain confidentiality
Duty to inform
Duty to report
Duty to warn
Legal Limits to Confidentiality
Not Absolute: Confidentiality has legal limitations varying by state.
Civil Legal Challenges
Definition of Malpractice:
Negligence by a professional when failing to adhere to professional standards.
Leads to client injury and is addressed in civil court.
Consequences of Malpractice:
Can result in fines, loss of professional licensure, damage to reputation, and difficulties in obtaining malpractice insurance.
Minimizing the Risk of Ethical or Legal Challenges
Best Practices:
Stay updated on practice methods.
Maintain thorough documentation.
Keep appropriate boundaries (avoid multiple relationships).
Ethical Decision Making
Part 1: Ethical Dilemmas
Definition: Ethical dilemmas arise when choosing between two or more conflicting ethical directives, all resulting in potentially undesirable outcomes.
Guiding Principles:
Beneficence: Promote good.
Non-maleficence: Avoid harm.
Part 2: Decision-Making Framework
Congress ETHIC Model Components:
Examine all relevant values (client, personal, agency, professional, societal).
Review ethical standards and applicable laws.
Predict potential consequences of various decisions.
Part 3: Collaborative Decision-Making
Considerations:
Assess all potential beneficiaries and those who might be harmed.
Consult with supervisors and colleagues to conceptualize choices.
Take into account the insights of supervisors or consultants in final decision-making.
Reference: (Congress, 2000, p.10)