Microeconomics: Demand Under Risk, Uncertainty, and Imperfect Information

Weaknesses of the One-Commodity Marginal Utility Theory

  • The marginal utility theory based on a single commodity contains several significant weaknesses:   - Interactions Between Goods: A change in the consumption of a single good does not occur in a vacuum; it will directly affect the marginal utility of substitute goods and complementary goods.   - Impact on Demand: Because the marginal utility of related goods is affected, a change in one good's consumption necessarily impacts the demand for those other products.   - Expectation vs. Totality: Consumer behavior is driven by perceptions of the marginal utility they expect to gain from a product, rather than by the total utility itself.

Demand Under Conditions of Risk and Uncertainty

  • Section Reference: 6.26.2

  • Economic models often operate under the assumption that individuals possess perfect information when buying goods and services.

  • This assumption implies consumers know two variables exactly:   - The exact price they will pay.   - The exact amount of utility they will gain from the consumption.

  • While this assumption holds true for low-cost, immediate-consumption items (e.g., a bar of chocolate), it does not accurately reflect the market for more complex items.

The Problem of Imperfect Information

  • Metadata References: KIB; p42.

  • For many purchases, especially long-term ones, perfect information is a "reasonable assumption" only in the short term.

  • Uncertainty increases as the consumer looks further into the future regarding the costs and benefits of a product.

  • This uncertainty is particularly prevalent in the market for consumer durables.

  • Definition of Consumer Durable: A consumer good that lasts a period of time, during which the consumer can continue gaining utility from it.

  • Examples of consumer durables cited include:   - Mobile phones.   - Tablets.   - Cars.   - Washing machines.

Case Study: Uncertainty of Costs and Benefits in a Washing Machine

  • Uncertainty of Costs:   - Initial Purchase: Buying a washing machine may require an immediate cash outlay of £400£400. This is a certain cost.   - Hidden Future Costs: Washing machines are prone to breaking down. A consumer might face an unpredicted repair bill of £100£100 after 2years2\,\text{years}.   - Realized Price: Even though it cannot be predicted at the moment of purchase, that £100£100 is a price the consumer must pay, just like the original £400£400. Thus, the consumer is uncertain of the full "price" the item will entail over its lifetime.

  • Uncertainty of Benefits:   - External Influences: Consumers are often attracted to buy products based on manufacturer brochures, aesthetic appeal, or advertisements on TV and in magazines.   - Reality of Use: After using the product for a period, consumers may discover unanticipated negative attributes, such as:     - A spin dryer that does not get clothes as dry as hoped.     - Excessive noise levels during operation.     - Water leaks.     - Mechanical failures, such as a sticking door.

Uncertainty in Assets

  • Buying consumer durables is inherently a gamble, but so is the purchase of assets.

  • Assets can be categorized as:   - Physical assets (e.g., a house).   - Financial assets (e.g., shares in a company).

  • The primary source of uncertainty for assets is their future price, which cannot be known with certainty at the time of the transaction.

Attitudes Towards Risk and Uncertainty

  • The effect of uncertainty on human behavior depends on individual attitudes toward "taking a gamble."

  • Distinction between Risk and Uncertainty:   - Risk: A condition where the person knows their chances, meaning they understand the probabilities involved (e.g., 25%25\% chance of an outcome).   - Uncertainty: A condition where probabilities are unknown.

  • Economics often analyzes behavior under risk to provide a mathematical framework for decision-making.

Practical Example: The Student Lottery Ticket

  • Scenario parameters:   - A student has an remaining student loan balance of £105£105.   - The student considers buying an instant lottery ticket or scratch card.   - The cost of the ticket is £5£5.   - The probability of winning is 11 in 44 (or 25%25\%).   - The prize for a winning ticket is £20£20.

  • The decision whether or not to purchase the ticket is a function of the student's personal attitude toward risk.

The Concept of Expected Value

  • Definition of Expected Value: The average value of a variable after many repetitions: in other words, the sum of the value of a variable on each occasion divided by the number of occasions.

  • In economic terms, the expected value of a gamble is the amount a person would earn on average if that gamble were repeated many times.

  • Calculation of Expected Value:   1. Multiply each possible outcome by the probability that it will occur.   2. Sum these values together.

  • In the lottery ticket example, there are two distinct outcomes:   1. Purchasing a winning ticket.   2. Purchasing a losing ticket.