Valuing Equity, Modern Portfolio Theory, and CAPM Study of Risk and Return, and CAPM
Characteristics of Equity Versus Debt
Debt Characteristics:
- Payments: Fixed payments consisting of interest (coupons) and repayment of the face value.
- Upside: No upside potential beyond the fixed contractual payments.
- Risk: Subject to default risk.
- Claimant Status: Senior to equity; debt holders are paid before equity holders.
- Maturity: Has a stated maturity date.
- Voting Rights: No voting rights in the company.
- Cost of Capital: Lower required return ().
Equity Characteristics:
- Payments: Variable or irregular payments (dividends); represents a share in the profits.
- Upside: Significant upside potential if the firm performs well.
- Risk: Riskier for the investor because equity is the residual claimant (paid only after all other obligations are met).
- Maturity: Infinite maturity (the stock exists as long as the firm does).
- Voting Rights: Typically carries voting rights for corporate governance.
- Cost of Capital: High required return ().
The Four Basic Models for Equity Valuation
- The Dividend Discount Model (9.1/9.2): Based on the present value of future dividends.
- Total Payout Valuation (9.3): Based on the present value of dividends plus share repurchases.
- Free Cash Flow Valuation (9.3): Based on the Enterprise Value derived from the present value of Free Cash Flows (FCF).
- Valuation Based on Comparable Firms (9.4): Using multiples to estimate value relative to similar investments.
The Dividend Discount Model (DDM)
- Definition: The price of a share is the discounted present value of all future expected cash flows to the equity holder.
- Shareholder Cash Flows: These include dividends received while holding the stock and the proceeds (selling price) when the stock is sold.
- Theoretical Principle: If the selling price is just the present value of all subsequent dividends, then the current price is equal to the present value of all future expected dividends over an infinite lifetime, discounted at the opportunity cost of equity ().
Constant Dividend Growth Model Example (Tesla)
- Scenario: Tesla plans to pay a yearly dividend starting with per share at year-end. Dividends grow at per year forever. The equity cost of capital is .
- Solution:
Two-Stage Dividend Growth Model Example (Tesla)
- Scenario: Tesla pays at year-end. Growth is per year for the first two years. From year 3 onwards, growth drops to per year forever. The cost of capital remains .
- Calculations:
- Terminal Value:
- Present Value at t=0:
Dividend Growth Mechanics
- Usage of Earnings per Share (EPS):
- Dividends: The fraction of earnings paid out is the dividend payout ratio ().
- Retained Earnings: This is the "plowback ratio" or "retention rate." These funds are reinvested to generate a Return on Investment (ROI), which leads to growth in future EPS and dividends.
- Limitations of DDM:
- Uncertainty: It is difficult to forecast growth rates and future dividends accurately.
- Dividend Smoothing: Firms tend to smooth dividends, making initial dividends less informative.
- Sensitivity: Small changes in the growth rate () cause massive swings in the estimated stock price.
- Exclusions: It does not naturally account for share repurchases or the influence of borrowing.
Total Payout and Free Cash Flow Valuation
Total Payout Valuation
- Method: Instead of just dividends, take the present value of the total payout (Dividends plus Share Repurchases) at the opportunity cost of equity.
- Share Repurchase: When a firm uses excess cash to buy back its own stock rather than paying a dividend.
Free Cash Flow (FCF) Valuation
- Definition: FCF is the cash flow available for distribution to all investors (debt and equity) after current business activities have been maintained.
- The Enterprise Value (EV) Approach:
- The discount rate used is the Weighted Average Cost of Capital ().
- Calculation of Share Price:
- Advantages: This method is less dependent on the specific capital structure (debt vs. equity mix) and FCF is often more informative about firm value than dividends.
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
- Purpose: It is the correct opportunity cost of capital for projects with risk equivalent to the firm’s existing project portfolio.
- Components:
- : Cost of debt.
- : Cost of equity.
- : Market value of equity.
- : Market value of debt.
Example: Corina Corporation
- Data: FCF Year 1 = , Year 2 = , Year 3 = . Post-Year 3 growth = . . Debt = , Cash = , Shares = .
- Step 1: Calculate EV:
- Step 2: Calculate Equity Value:
- Step 3: Share Price:
Valuation Based on Comparable Firms (Multiples)
- Standard Logic: Estimate value based on the value of comparable firms or investments expected to generate similar future cash flows.
- Valuation Ratios:
- P/E Ratio: Share Price divided by EPS.
- V/EBITDA Ratio: Enterprise Value divided by EBITDA.
- MTB (Market-to-Book): Ratio of market value to book value of equity.
- Comparison Example (Firm ABC):
- Industry Average MTB = .
- ABC Book Value = .
- ABC Market Value = .
- ABC Shares = .
- Share Price = .
- Tesla Comparables (as of 22-04-2025):
- Tesla P/E:
- Tesla TEV/EBITDA:
- Compared to Industry Mean P/E: and Mean TEV/EBITDA: .
- Limitations of Multiples:
- Does not account for differences in growth rates, risk, or accounting policies.
- Provides only relative valuation (relative within the set); it cannot determine if an entire industry is over- or undervalued.
Capital Markets: Risk and Return (1926–2021)
- Historical Trends:
- Small Stocks: Highest long-term returns but largest price fluctuations (volatility).
- T-Bills (Treasury Bills): Lowest long-term returns and lowest risk.
- Fundamental Rule: Higher risk requires a higher expected return.
- Measures:
- Expected Return (): Weighted average of possible returns based on probabilities.
- Variance: The expected squared deviation from the mean.
- Standard Deviation (Volatility): The square root of the variance ().
- Expected Return (): Weighted average of possible returns based on probabilities.
Historical Volatility vs. Excess Return (Table 10.5)
- S&P 500 (Large Stocks): Lower volatility than small stocks.
- Corporate Bonds: Moderate risk and return.
- Treasury Bills: Low-risk benchmark.
Diversification and Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT)
- Key Concept: Investors choose portfolios to maximize expected returns and minimize risk.
- Diversification Effect: By holding many stocks, firm-specific risks are reduced through the diversification effect. Only systematic risk remains.
- Risk Types:
- Systematic Risk: Market-wide risks that affect all firms; cannot be diversified away.
- Firm-Specific Risk (Unsystematic/Idiosyncratic): Risks unique to a firm; can be eliminated via diversification.
- Portfolio Return Calculation:
- Portfolio Variance Calculation:
- Correlation ():
- Between (move together) and (move oppositely).
- Independent risks have a correlation of .
- As long as correlations are not perfectly , diversification benefits exist.
Two-Stock Volatility Example
- Addison Printing: Volatility = , Weight = .
- Wesley Publishing: Volatility = , Weight = .
- Correlation: .
- Solution:
The Efficient Frontier and CAPM
- Efficient Portfolios: Portfolios that provide the highest expected return for a given level of risk.
- Portfolios on the "red portion" of the curve are efficient; the "blue portion" is inefficient.
- Risk-Free Assets: Optimal portfolios combine a risk-free asset (lending/borrowing) with the Tangent Portfolio (the risky portfolio with the highest Sharpe ratio).
- Required Return and Beta:
- Adding an investment to a portfolio improves the Sharpe ratio if the expected return exceeds the required return ().
- Beta (): Measures the sensitivity of an asset's return to the market.
The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)
- Formula:
- Assumptions of CAPM:
- Investors can buy/sell all securities at competitive prices without taxes/transaction costs and can borrow/lend at the risk-free rate.
- Investors hold only efficient portfolios.
- Investors have homogeneous expectations (same estimates for future returns/volatility).
- Equilibrium: If these hold, the Market Portfolio is the efficient portfolio.
- Security Market Line (SML): Graphs the required return for each security as a function of its beta. All stocks should lie on the SML.
- Capital Market Line (CML): Graphs the risk-return of combinations of the risk-free asset and the efficient (market) portfolio.
Sustainable Finance: The ABP Case
- News: Dutch pension giant ABP decided to dump in fossil fuel holdings (e.g., Shell) due to insufficient progress in energy transitions.
- Modern Portfolio Theory Implications:
- Divestment may result in an "optimally less-diversified" portfolio.
- It could lead to lower performance or exposure to different risks (stranded assets).
- Hart and Zingales (HZ) Framework:
- Discusses maximizing shareholder welfare vs. just profit.
- Role of fiduciary duty: Should investors use voting and engagement or divestment?
Questions & Discussion
- Q: How does a correlation of instead of affect Wesley/Addison volatility?
- A: Increasing correlation reduces diversification benefits, thus increasing the volatility of the portfolio.
- Q: What determines the best valuation technique?
- A: No single technique is final. DCF is potentially more accurate but requires many assumptions. Practitioners use a combination and look for consistency across models.
- Q: How do investors choose portfolios?
- A: Based on E(r) and SD, targeting the efficient frontier and adjusting for individual risk aversion.