The Who and Why of QAnon’s Rapid Rise (Hughey 2021)

Million MAGA March Gathering

  • Location: Freedom Plaza at 14th and E Street, NW, Washington, D.C.

  • Date: Saturday morning, November 14, 2020.

  • Image credit: Elvert Barnes, Flickr

QAnon Overview

  • Definition: QAnon is a conspiracy theory that gained prominence after the U.S. Capitol insurrection on January 6, 2021.   - Example of QAnon symbolism includes flags with a large "Q" and the slogan "WWG1WGA" ( where we go one, we go all).   - Known figures include Jake Angeli ("Q Shaman"), who was photographed on the dais of the House of Representatives.

  • Origins:   - Started on October 28, 2017, with an anonymous user on 4chan named "Q" predicting Hillary Clinton's arrest.   - Built on previous conspiracy theories such as the "Pizzagate Conspiracy".   - Followers, called "QAnons", viewed Donald Trump as the key figure to combat corruption and predicted a leadership overhaul known as "The Storm".

  • Public Perception & Growth:   - The FBI labeled QAnon a "dangerous extremist group" by August 2019 due to its violent actions.   - Key events leading up to the Capitol insurrection include discussions around election fraud and the hashtag #StopTheSteal.   - Post-election, the theories persisted despite Trump's loss, leading to the movement's evolution.

QAnon Demographics

  • Popularity Indicators:   - In April 2018, a QDrop tracking app was among the top ten iTunes apps.   - Membership in large public QAnon Facebook groups grew over 600% from March to July 2018 (6,000 to 40,000 members).   - Approximately 4% of U.S. registered voters (around 8.5 million) identify as QAnon supporters.   - A December 2020 NPR/Ipsos poll found that 17% of adults believed in the foundational myth of QAnon regarding a child sex ring run by elites.

  • User Composition:   - Contrary to stereotypes of QAnons as uneducated, those with college degrees show slightly higher awareness and support for QAnon ideas.   - 40% of individuals charged in the January 6 insurrection had white-collar jobs.   - An affiliation exists with white evangelical Christians, with surveys indicating significant overlap in beliefs.   - The QAnon movement connects to broader global conspiracy theories with followers in various countries.

Mechanisms of Influence

  • Manipulation of Vulnerabilities: QAnon leverages social-psychological aspects to attract and maintain followers.   - Inspiring Ideologies:     - Initially aligns with normative values such as child protection.     - Exploits moral panic topics like child trafficking, evolving from moral conversations to conspiracy ideation.     - An example includes the hijacking of anti-trafficking movements with QAnon rhetoric leading to a significant membership increase in relevant groups.   - Allure of Social Conformity:     - Individuals are drawn to echo beliefs of trusted individuals or popular figures, influenced by the spread of conspiracy theories through political elites such as Donald Trump.     - The community fosters support for each other’s conclusions through a process of validation, emphasizing group identity over independent thinking.     - Social media plays a critical role in reinforcing beliefs, as the community of discussion creates an engaging echo chamber.   - Con Artistry:     - The facilitators of QAnon (i.e., Q) exploit emotional investment and sociopolitical tension to cultivate a following.     - Individuals engaged often misinterpret mixed messages and engage in self-deception regarding their understanding of the conspiracy.

Harms Associated with QAnon

  • Consequences of Belief:   - QAnon has led to physical violence, criminal actions, and psychological harm among its followers.   - A significant number of adherents reported damaged personal relationships (over 40%), increased anxiety, stress-related issues, and social disengagement.

  • Self-Deception Mechanisms:   - Followers regularly dismiss contradictory information and memories, reinforcing a false reality through selective recall of events or false memories created around the content they consume.   - Collective misinformation exacerbated belief in the QAnon narrative, leading to affirmed disaster scenarios leading to the January insurrection.

Future of QAnon

  • QAnon continues to evolve post-2021, shifting narratives towards pandemic denialism and conspiracy theories tied to global crises, establishing a potentially lasting presence in extremist rhetoric.

  • Addressing QAnon effectively demands comprehensive approaches combining media scrutiny, societal shifts, empathetic discourse, and community reengagement.