1.3.2 Evolutionary Explanations for Behavior
↳
Key Definitions
Adaptation: process of changing to better suit demands of the environment
Disgust: one of the basic human emotions; feeling of revulsion caused by something unpleasant
Evolution: process by which organisms change from generation to generation due to the transmission of heritable characteristics
Massive modularity: assumption that the mind has evolved to serve different survival-related functions
↳hence, it must consist of “modules” each responsible for one of these functions
Natural selection: key mechanism of evolution; differential survival of individuals based on the extent to which they are adapted to the environment
Post-hoc reasoning: explaining something after it has already happened
Essential Understanding
→ evolutionary psychology attempts to apply modern theory of evolution to explain the observed variations in human behavior
↳ has been applied to many behaviors like the emotion of disgust
→ Curtis, Aunger, and Rabie (2004): an example of how evolutionary explanations in psychology are put to the test
↳ usually a phenomenon universal for all humans is selected (i.e. emotion of disgust)
↳ the explanation for this phenomenon serves as a model upon which several predictions are made (if A is true, then B, C, D, etc. are also true)
→ Although evolutionary psychology has a very high explanatory power with clear explanations for a wide range of phenomena, there’s still limitations:
↳ex: assumption of mass modularity, lack of knowledge about ancestral environments, lack of testability and the existence of cross-cultural differences
Theory of Evolution
→based on ideas of differential fitness, survival of the fittest, and natural selection
→ applies to many behaviors
→ first made by Charles Darwin in 1929 with more expansions from modern discoveries in genetics
→ Its main principles include:
↳ organisms are driven by the need to survive and reproduce
↳ organisms having different traits to adapt to their environment to varying degrees
↳ better-adapted organisms have higher chances of surviving and producing offspring
↳ less-adapted=less offspring, so their genes will gradually disappear from the population
↳ genes from better-adapted organisms will be passed on to further generations
Research
Curtis, Aunger, and Rabie (2004)→ evolutionary explanation for disgust
↳key: findings suggest that the emotion of disgust evolved as protection from risk of disease
Aim: hypothetically, if disgust is a production of evolution, the following must be true:
↳ disgust should be stronger in response to stimuli that are associated with disease
↳ disgust response should be similar cross-culturally
↳ disgust should be more pronounced in females since they have to protect their immune system of their babies and themselves
↳ disgust should become weaker as one becomes older (because reproductive potential declines)
→ the aim is to test these predictions
Participants: volunteers who completed a survey online; total of over 77,000 people from 165 countries
Method: correlational study
Procedure:
↳data was gathered in a survey from BBC website
→ survey asked them a series of questions like age and country of origin
→ were asked to rate picture for disgust on a scale from 1 to 5; pictures were similar pairs digitally manipulated stimuli→ one picture in the pair was disease-salient and the other less-salient
Results:
→ all 4 predictions found support
↳rankings of disgust in response to disease-salient stimuli were higher than ratings of disgust towards similar stimuli that were digitally manipulated to be less disease-salient
ex: a plate of organic-looking fluid was ranked higher in disgust than a blue chemical fluid
↳ rankings were consistent among cultures
↳ rankings were more pronounced in the sub-sample of females
↳ rankings of disgust in response to disease-salient stimuli declined with age
Conclusion:
→results supported the evolutionary explanation: disgust is a biologically based response to disease-salient stimuli that reduces risk of disease
→ evolutionary explanation is a model that fits into observational data→ if it fits well, it increases our confidence on the model
→ one say that evolutionary explanation of disgust stood the test
Criticism of Evolution Explanations in Psychology
→ Although evolutionary psychology has a very high explanatory power with clear explanations for a wide range of phenomena, there’s still limitations:
↳ex: assumption of mass modularity, lack of knowledge about ancestral environments, lack of testability and the existence of cross-cultural differences
Limitation: Massive Modularity vs. Neuroplasticity
→Massive modularity is the idea that mind consists of modules that each serve a function like emotion of disgust
↳ if we accept that the mind as a whole is a product of evolution, then we accept the idea of massive modularity
↳ however, since the brain demonstrates neuroplasticity, then this contradicts massive modularity
Limitation: Speculations about the environment
→ Adaptation is always adaptation to some environment, so if wants to explain the behavior change using the evolution theory, one must have knowledge about the environment in which a change occurred
↳ however, our knowledge of ancestors’ environment is limited and most knowledge we know is speculative
Limitation: Testability
→ evolutionary explanations are difficult and often impossible to test
→ many criticize that evolutionary psychology uses post-hoc reasoning
Limitation: Cultural variation
→ observed cultural variations weaken evolutionary explanation of behavior
→ one can claim that different environments so such variation is perfectly plausible, but if cross-cultural differences are observed for basic phenomena that were thought to be universal, then evolutionary explanation become questionable