The Civil War & Reconstruction Treaties - OKHIST

The Civil War & Reconstruction Treaties in Indian Territory

The 5 Tribes and the Civil War (1861-1865)

  • During the Civil War, the 5 Tribes sided with the Confederacy.

  • The Confederacy promised the 5 Tribes:

    • Adoption of all financial obligations from the old treaties with the U.S.

    • Protection from invasion.

    • Guarantee of self-government.

  • The Confederacy also agreed to:

    • Protect slavery.

    • Grant representation in Confederate courts.

Battle of Honey Springs

  • The most important battle of the Civil War in Indian Territory.

    • Southern forces were not in good condition to fight against another Union invasion.

    • Union soldiers out-gunned and out-manned the Confederates.

    • Confederates were sent fleeing south to the Red River.

Results of Honey Springs

  • Confederates found safety in camps along the Red River.

    • Joined by over 15,000 friends and family.

    • Abandoned their homes in the northern part of Indian Territory to avoid the wrath of Union supporters.

    • Food and medical supplies were in short supply.

Results of the Civil War

  • The Confederacy lost the Civil War.

  • North sympathizers spent the war in refugee camps.

    • The majority of the estimated 10,000 deaths occurred in refugee camps.

  • End of the “Golden Years” for the 5 Tribes.

    • Homes were abandoned.

    • Grain was seized.

    • Livestock driven off.

    • Schools and churches closed.

  • The 5 Tribes were now a “conquered enemy” of the Union.

Reconstruction Treaties

  • Reconstruction Treaties with the Five Tribes reduced the land of those tribes to about half its previous size.

    • Divided what had once been Indian Territory into two distinct parts.

Reconstruction Treaties: Impact on Indian Territory

  • September 1865, the 5 Tribes met in Washington, D.C.

  • The 5 Tribes had “rightfully forfeited” all their annuities and lands.

  • The President was willing to forgive them and make new treaties.

Reconstruction Treaties: Positive Impacts on Indian Territory

  • Abolished slavery.

  • Gave each slave citizenship and property.

  • Allowed railroads to build on their land.

    • Railroads would run North-South and East-West.

  • Avoided a territorial government.

  • Agreed to an intertribal council.

  • Restored their annuities.

Reconstruction Treaties: Negative Impacts on Indian Territory

  • Loss of land.

  • Ceded the western half of Oklahoma as a home for other Plains Indians.

  • Cherokees ceded land in Kansas and control of the Cherokee Outlet.

  • Seminoles had to sell old land for 15 cents per acre.

    • Also pay the government 50 cents per acre for land they bought from the Creek for 30 cents per acre.

Goods and Services

  • Indian Agents provided:

    • Medical care and education to replace the schools which were left behind or to train Indians for a necessarily new way of life

    • New medicine to replace the traditional medicine which was by nature a regional art

  • Each tribe or confederacy of tribes governed itself.

    • The tribes made their own laws and set the penalties for breaking those laws.

    • They provided their own police forces and patrolled their own boundaries.

  • The greater a tribe's need, the more control the United States had.

  • The Civil War not only reduced tribal lands but also reduced Indian power.

  • The reservation era was a whole new proposition for all Native Americans.

The Leased District

  • After the Civil War, the entire western half of Indian Territory was available for settlement by western tribes (Plains Indians).

    • Tribes the government intended to remove from areas of the Western Plains and resettle in the Territory.

Medicine Lodge Peace Council

  • In October 1867, a peace council met at Medicine Lodge Creek in Kansas.

  • Among the well-known Indian representatives were Satanta, Wolf’s Sleeve, Ten Bears, and Black Kettle.

  • The commission warned that the buffalo were disappearing and that for survival the chiefs should take their people to reservations to learn to farm.

  • The Commissioners left Washington with instructions to accomplish three things:

    • Prevent Indian attacks on white emigrants and settlers.

    • Stop Indian wars by removing their cause.

    • Convince Indians to become farmers and stockmen, stopping their restless wandering about in search of a precarious living by hunting buffaloes and other game.

Broken Promises

  • The Medicine Lodge treaties further reduced the tribal lands specified in the 1865 treaties.

  • Despite their peaceful promises, the government did not deliver the goods and services exchanged for depleted tribal lands.

  • Young Warriors believed that the United States had broken the treaty and therefore the Indians were no longer bound by it.

    • Many of them left the reservations and made their way north, looting and raiding en route.

Treaty Violations

  • White settlers coveting Indian lands pressed into areas stipulated in current treaties as tribal lands.

  • The government wanted more tribal land reductions to satisfy the ever-moving frontier.

  • Angry Indians, who could not depend on government agents to protect their territories, retaliated against poachers.

    • This brought the military to control marauding Indians.

  • The summer of 1867 saw constant warring between the United States Army in the west and the Plains Tribes: Kiowa's, Comanche's, Cheyenne's, Arapahoe's, and Apaches.

Battle of the Washita

  • In retaliation, Colonel George Armstrong Custer and the Seventh Cavalry attacked Black Kettle’s peaceful band camped on the Washita River.

  • On November 27, 1868, in another early morning attack, Custer virtually annihilated the unsuspecting Indians.

    • He killed 102 warriors, many women and children, and slaughtered a herd of 800 horses.

  • Black Kettle was shot and killed as he fled on horseback across the Washita River.

Conquering the Indians

  • Battles and skirmishes between the army and the Indians continued.

    • The army patrolled the reservations in Western Indian Territory.

    • Young Indian Warriors slipped away to raid Texas and Kansas farms and ranches.

  • In 1871, the government declared that no Indian tribes were sovereign and that they no longer would be treated as free and independent states.

Americanization and Reservations

  • During the conquest of the western and Plains Tribes as well as the constant removal of the tribes of the Old Northwest, some tribes suffered great wrongs.

  • One policy seemed to remain constant throughout the dealings of the United States with the Indians, and that was that the Indians should be “Americanized.”

  • The reservation Indians were given their rations and taught to farm and raise livestock.

    • If they resisted Americanization, agents were instructed to withhold supplies.

  • Indian children who spoke tribal languages were punished in school.

  • Ministers and teachers berated the customary tribal dress and hairstyles.

    • All signs of Indian culture were to be obliterated, if possible.

Discussion Questions

  • How did the Civil War end the Golden Years for the 5 Tribes? How were they punished?

  • Explain what caused wars between Plains tribes and the U.S. Army.