psych 3

Structuralism and Introspection

  • Early psychology context: Wilhelm Wundt and structuralism sought to analyze the mind by breaking experiences into basic building blocks.
  • Core idea: psychology could be reduced to the sum of its parts (the basic elements of consciousness).
  • Method: introspection — thinking about thinking and reporting inner experiences.
  • Problems:
    • Introspection was unreliable and not valid as a scientific method for measuring mental processes.
    • This critique contributed to the decline of structuralism.

Functionalism and Evolutionary Perspectives (William James)

  • Response to structuralism: shift from asking what mental experiences are to what their functions are.
  • William James emphasized function and purpose of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.
  • Influence of Darwin: apply evolution and adaptation to human behavior.
  • Questions highlighted by James:
    • Why do we have memory and different memory types?
    • Why do aspects like depression and anxiety persist?
    • If a trait isn’t beneficial, why hasn’t it disappeared through evolution?
  • Legacy: foundational for later evolutionary psychology and nature–nurture discussions.
  • Key point: behavior and mental processes may be better understood in terms of adaptive value and function rather than solely structure.

Evolutionary Psychology, Development, and Attachment

  • Evolutionary framework: genes and behaviors persist if they offered an evolutionary advantage.
  • Attachment theory: secure vs insecure attachment patterns.
    • Although secure attachment is often viewed as optimal, there may be evolutionary advantages to insecure attachment in certain contexts.
  • Implication: developmental trajectories and attachment styles can be understood through evolution and adaptation rather than purely through conscious choice.

Gestalt Psychology and Perception

  • Reaction to Wundt/Structuralism: the Gestalt approach argued that the whole is not always the sum of its parts.
  • Focus area: sensation and perception.
  • Core claim: perceptual experience is influenced by context; identical sensory input can yield different percepts.
  • Illusions as evidence: the perception of the dress (black-blue vs white-gold) demonstrates context shaping perception.
    • Despite receiving the same information, people report different colors due to contextual cues and prior experiences.
  • Gestalt principles emphasize that the brain combines information holistically and uses context to interpret sensory data.

The Dress Illusion: Context and Perception

  • Example: dress illusion shows that perception can diverge when given the same stimulus.
  • Explanation: lighting context leads the brain to interpret color as either blue-black or white-gold.
  • Takeaway: context, prior knowledge, language, and experience shape perceptual outcomes.

Nature, Nurture, and Epigenetics

  • Nature–nurture debate: how much of a behavior is due to genetics versus environment?
  • PKU example (phenylketonuria): a 100% genetic condition that can be managed via environment.
    • Gene causes an inability to break down phenylalanine; if untreated, brain development is severely affected.
    • Diet can prevent adverse outcomes, illustrating a strong environmental influence on a genetic condition: a 100% genetic predisposition but 100% environmental control of outcome.
  • Cross-fostering experiments (mice/rats): environment can override genetics.
    • Smart vs dumb genetically modified animals showed that nurturing environment (e.g., a smart mother with higher caregiving) could normalize behavior.
    • Case: dumb offspring raised by a smart mother displayed enhanced problem-solving similar to smart peers.
    • Second generation: offspring of the previously nurtured dumb mice still benefited in problem solving, suggesting some persistence of the nurture effect across generations.
  • Epigenetics: environment can influence gene expression and susceptibility to certain traits.
    • Traumatic experiences can activate specific genes in some individuals differently than others.
    • Epigenetic effects can persist across generations, affecting behavior and development without changes in the DNA sequence.
  • Hormonal mechanisms: differences in nurturing behavior linked to hormones such as oxytocin and vasopressin.
    • Vole studies: prairie voles (high oxytocin/vasopressin) are monogamous; montane voles (lower levels) are polygamous.
    • This demonstrates that gene expression and hormonal profiles influence social bonding and mating behavior.
  • Practical implications: enrichment and nurturing environments can significantly alter outcomes, illustrating that nurture can modulate or even override certain genetic predispositions.

Free Will, Determinism, and Priming

  • Free will: the belief that individuals make independent decisions to shape their behavior.
  • Determinism: behavior is caused by determinants outside of conscious choice, possibly below awareness.
  • View on the debate: not a strict either/or—some behaviors reflect free will in some contexts, while others are driven by deterministic forces.
  • Priming: environmental stimuli outside conscious awareness influencing behavior.
    • Classic priming study: participants counted either pieces of paper or money; later, when choosing among sweets, those who counted money ate more (
      50 ext{%} more) than those who counted paper.
    • Money-related word task and observation of helping behavior demonstrated priming effects on social behavior without conscious awareness.
    • Conclusion: environmental cues can systematically shape behavior, illustrating determinism in certain contexts.

The Scientific Status of Psychology

  • Question that persisted: is psychology a science?
  • Current consensus: psychology uses empirical methods, the scientific method, and data-driven conclusions.
  • Emphasis on empirical evidence over anecdote; claims must be tested and supported by data.
  • The role of skepticism: avoid relying on stories or hearsay (anecdotal evidence) for claims.
  • Historical example: Clever Hans the horse.
    • Hans was believed to perform arithmetic based on cues