Exploring Self-Esteem and Child Development

Exploring Self-Esteem as a Path to Success

The Concept of Self-Esteem

Self-esteem is a focused area of study regarding early preparation for success in school and life. It is intrinsically linked to achievement, behavior, positive growth patterns, and mindset. Understanding self-esteem requires moving beyond cultural ideals to look at individual realities and the influence of professionals and families on a child's path.

The Cultural Ideal vs. Individual Reality

Mainstream cultural backgrounds often produce a stereotypical portrait of a person with high self-esteem:

  • Characterized by self-confidence in dress, grooming, gait, and speech.
  • Perceived as secure, happy, outgoing, energetic, brave, strong, and proud.
  • Regarded as motivated, successful, independent, and assertive.

However, in diverse settings, this list is identified not as a universal indicator but as a cultural ideal. Real-world observations reveal different truths:

  • Uniqueness: A person with high self-esteem is more likely to be themselves rather than a walking example of specific traits. Individuals with high self-esteem can be very different from one another.
  • Happiness vs. Self-Esteem: High self-esteem does not equate to constant happiness. Emotional range is part of being authentic. External circumstances (e.g., living in a refugee camp) can cause unhappiness despite high self-esteem.
  • Attributes and Success: Self-esteem is not necessarily linked to talent, physical appearance, strength, or financial wealth. Some individuals deemed "best-looking" feel inferior, fearing their worth is tied only to fading looks.
  • Hidden Realities: Assertiveness can sometimes mask a shy or scared internal state, and a "paragon of virtue" may have hidden vices. Judging self-esteem in others is prone to error because people are not always as they seem.
Definitions and Components
  • Self-Esteem: Defined as a valuing process resulting from an ongoing self-appraisal where traits and abilities are acknowledged and evaluated. It occurs when a person, after a realistic appraisal of pluses and minuses, decides they have more positive attributes than negative ones.
  • Self-Image: The internal pictures we carry of ourselves.
  • Self-Concept: The ideas we have about ourselves.
  • High Self-Esteem: Holding oneself in esteem and liking oneself despite flaws.
  • Low Self-Esteem: Lacking a global sense of self-worth.
  • Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation: Individuals with high self-esteem are motivated more from within (intrinsic) than by external rewards (extrinsic).

The Cultural Context of Self-Esteem

Self-worth is entirely tied to culture and the family's role in socialization.

  • Independence/Individuality Culture: Families help infants discover separateness and draw boundaries. Success is felt through becoming an independent individual.
  • Interdependence Culture: Families may de-emphasize independence to encourage mutual bonding. Jerome Kagan, in The Nature of the Child (19841984), notes that in Japanese culture, adults "tempt the infant into a dependent role" to prepare for adult life (p. 2929).
  • Conflicting Values: In some cultures, holding oneself in high esteem is viewed as abhorrent, and pride is forbidden. Instead, humility and humbleness are valued (Greenfield, Quiroz, Rothstein-Fisch, & Trumbull, 20012001; Rogoff, 20032003). Conflicting cultural messages can erode self-esteem.

Cognitive Development and Reality Match

Cognitive Stages and Misconceptions

A child’s self-perception is influenced by leur stage of cognitive development rather than self-esteem alone.

  • Example: A 33-year-old may feel they caused a sibling's illness through "ugly wishes." This is a lack of logic relative to their age, not low self-esteem.
The Importance of Reality

True self-esteem requires self-perception to align with reality. Exaggerated misperceptions not related to developmental stages are considered delusions.

  • Reference: A NewsweekNewsweek cover from February 1717, 19921992, showed a weak man seeing a strong, self-assured reflection. This illustrates a "false picture" that does not constitute healthy self-esteem.
  • Building Real Self-Esteem: It is impossible to "fool" a child into self-esteem with false pictures. A child aware of their lack of ability or unacceptable behavior will not believe empty praise. Change only happens when the individual decides to change their own perceptions through a collaboration with culture, community, and family.

Ecological Systems and Dimensions of Self-Esteem

Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory

Self-esteem is acted upon by multiple forces: temperament, family parenting styles, peers, schools, neighborhoods, and the broader society.

Coopersmith’s Four Dimensions (19671967)

Researcher Stanley Coopersmith identified four dimensions that contribute to self-esteem, influenced by what the family and culture value:

  1. Significance: The feeling of being loved, cared about, and mattering to someone. This is a choice the individual makes based on messages received.
  2. Competence: Feeling capable and skillful. This often depends on who the child compares themselves to.
  3. Power (Personal Power): The sense of effectiveness; "to be able." Having control over being who you are and having an effect on people and events.
  4. Virtue: Feeling "good" according to one's own standards.
The Role of Values

Self-esteem is defined by the gap between where a person perceives themselves to be and where they want to be on the dimensions they value most.

  • Example: A housewife may excel in virtue and significance but feel low self-esteem because she values only power and competence, which she perceives she lacks.
  • Example: A monk may derive high self-esteem purely from virtue (obedience to faith), regardless of power or significance.

Developmental Perspectives

Erikson’s Psycho-social Stages (19631963)

Self-esteem emphases change as children develop:

  • Infancy (0−10-1): Basic Trust versus Basic Mistrust.
  • Toddlerhood (1−31-3): Autonomy versus Shame and Doubt (Focus on Power).
  • Preschool Years (3−63-6): Initiative versus Guilt.
  • School Age (6−106-10): Industry versus Inferiority (Focus on Competence/Industry).
Maslow’s Hierarchy

On Maslow's hierarchy of needs, "Esteem" sits directly below "Self-Actualization." These two processes are linked; a person further along self-actualization is likely to have higher self-esteem.

Self-Fulfilling Prophecies and Beliefs

What a child believes they can or cannot do influences their actual performance.

  • Learned Helplessness: Seligman (19751975) demonstrated this with dogs that were shocked in cages. Even after the shocks stopped and doors were opened, the dogs stayed, acting on past experience rather than current reality.
  • Labeling: Labels like "Lazy," "Bad," "Dumb," or "Stupid" become internalized and affect behavior.
  • Reflections: Children define themselves by images reflected in their environment. Positive attachments lead to a sense of being "lovable." Early efficacy (crying and having needs met) builds a sense of "self-efficacy."

Bias and Environmental Influence

Negative reflections from the outside world regarding color, gender, ethnicity, or ability can damage self-esteem.

  • Environmental Factors: Insensitive or assaultive environments (racism, sexism, ableism) can be devastating.
  • Protective Shields: Families can provide lessons on surviving discrimination, which helps children maintain self-esteem against negative societal messages.

Strategies for Promoting Self-Esteem

1. Eliminating Critical Attitudes

Guidance should be provided without labeling or name-calling. Honest feedback is necessary, but the form of delivery matters.

2. Honest Feedback vs. Praise
  • Praise: Often overblown and creates a dependency on extrinsic judgments. "Great job!" for everything becomes an empty phrase.
  • Encouragement: More effective than praise. It involves:   - Calling attention to legitimate success.   - Comparing past performance with present performance (e.g., "You picked up more blocks this time than last time").   - Explaining why a behavior is valuable.   - Acting as a "coach" rather than a "cheerleader."
3. Creating Opportunities for Success

Success should be earned through manageable but challenging environments.

  • Assisted Performance/Scaffolding: Lev Vygotsky (19781978) suggested that adults or peers provide a "helping hand." Scaffolding is a temporary support that allows a child to problem-solve at new levels.
  • Optimum Challenge: Risk-taking is the secret to development. Adults should provide the smallest amount of help necessary to facilitate problem-solving rather than "rescuing" the child.
4. Case Studies in Scaffolding
  • Travis (44 years old): Travis exhibited bullying behaviors (loud, unruly, big for his age). His teachers realized his bullying was a sign of low self-esteem and a way to hide perceived inadequacies. They planned to help him by having him lead a paper airplane project and encouraging a friendship with another child, Paul.
  • Dashinique: An adult helped her choose a scene for a school play and organized a small audience for her to practice in front of, allowing her to gain the self-confidence needed for the actual tryout.
  • Brandon and Shelby: An adult refused to simply take a glue gun away to resolve a dispute. Instead, he narrated what he saw, encouraging the children to find their own resolution through negotiation.
5. Learning from Failure

Failure provides clear feedback. Adults must remain supportive rather than critical during mistakes to ensure the child emerges with an intact sense of self-worth.

Mindsets: Fixed vs. Growth

Carol Dweck, in Mindset (20072007), identified two types of mindsets based on how children view challenges:

  • Fixed Mindset: Children worry about mistakes and failures. They pick easy tasks to validate their capability and see failure as a personal deficiency.
  • Growth Mindset: Children see mistakes as paths to learning. They value the process over the outcome and thrive on challenges. They believe effort leads to improvement.

Application:

  • Do not praise intelligence or ability (leads to fixed mindset).
  • Focus on effort: "You tried really hard. I notice you just kept at it."
  • Describe what you see without value judgments: "I notice you put these large brush strokes next to the very small ones."

The Anti-Bias Approach

Adults' reactions to differences affect children's reactions. Louise Derman-Sparks (19891989) and the anti-bias curriculum emphasize that adults must work on their own biases.

The "Color-Blind" Myth
  • Pretending to be "blind" to differences (color-blind, gender-blind) often comes from a place of privilege.
  • It can be insulting because it ignores a person's true identity.
  • Equality vs. Identity: Recognizing skin color is not immoral; presenting one color as superior is.
Celebrating vs. Stereotyping
  • Japanese Tea Party Example: A teacher created a "strange conglomeration of stereotypes" that was insulting to a Japanese parent guest.
  • Native American Stereotypes: Michael Dorris (20112011) criticized insulting practices like singing "Ten Little Indians" or telling children to sit "Indian-style." Modern educators use "Criss-cross, applesauce" as a neutral alternative.
Anti-Bias Action
  • Model Behaviors: Acknowledge the privilege typically held by the white, able-bodied male group.
  • Create Environments: Use pictures, books, and experiences that reflect both the children's own lives and lives unlike theirs.
  • Address Media: Point out stereotypes (e.g., weak women in TV programs).
  • Identify Unfairness: Children understand fairness. Bias is defined as unfair exclusion or disrespect.
  • Inclusion: Including children with disabilities benefits everyone, teaching typical peers to respect big differences in ability.

Working with Families and Affirmations

Individualism vs. Interdependence
  • Individualist Goal: Parents see the baby as arriving connected; the goal is to teach separateness and autonomy ("I can do it myself").
  • Interdependent Goal: Parents see an independent streak in the baby; the goal is to ensure the baby is forever connected and values dependence/connections.
  • Conflict Case Study: The author attempted to explain self-esteem to Teresa, a Mexican immigrant. Teresa responded: "You can't esteem yourself; you can only esteem others."
  • Linguistic Difference: A Spanish-English dictionary showed 196196 entries for "self" in English compared to only 1313 in Spanish.
The Power of Expectations
  • Rosenthal Study (19871987): Teachers were told certain students were expected to have a "growth spurt." Although these students were randomly selected, they showed remarkable improvement because the teachers' beliefs influenced their nonverbal and verbal messages.
Life Scripts and Reprogramming

Adults carry "life scripts"—voices from childhood that praise or criticize. To stop passing negative messages to children, adults can perform a reprogramming exercise:

  1. Write down all internal messages (voices) on slips of paper.
  2. Sort into positive, negative, and mixture piles.
  3. Rewrite mixture/negative messages into positive ones.
  4. Consciously choose to discard (tear up) the negative slips.
  5. Review positive messages regularly to "take charge" of one's life.
Strategies for Professional Engagement
  • Seek to understand each family’s specific view of self-esteem.
  • Provide affirmations to parents to support their strengths.
  • Practice self-nurturing and reciprocation. (The author cited friends providing meals during a crisis with her premature son as a vital affirmation of being cared for).
  • Encourage the cycle: give affirmations to get them, and get them to give them.