Study Notes on Equality and Equity
Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Article One: Asserts that all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. This article serves as the foundational principle for all subsequent human rights, underlining the inherent worth of every individual. It signifies a universal entitlement to freedom and respect, regardless of background, origin, or any other characteristic.
Equality vs. Equity
There is an important distinction between equality and equity, although they are often confused because the terms sound similar. Understanding this difference is crucial for developing policies and practices that truly promote fairness and justice in society.
Definition of Equality
Equality:
Recognizes that all human beings possess the same value, an intrinsic worth that demands recognition.
Implies that everyone has the same rights, meaning no individual should be privileged or disadvantaged by law or societal norms.
Ensures that all individuals receive the same level of respect, fostering a sense of shared humanity.
Guarantees the same access to opportunities for everyone, aiming to remove overt barriers to participation and advancement. This could involve, for instance, equal access to education, healthcare, and employment without discrimination.
Supported by national and international laws that uphold these principles, establishing its significance in societal frameworks and demanding universal application.
Definition of Equity
Equity:
Focuses on everyone achieving equal outcomes, acknowledging the different starting points of individuals. This means that simply providing the same resources to everyone may not be enough if some individuals face pre-existing disadvantages due to systemic issues or different life circumstances.
Recognizes that while all individuals have the same inherent value, they experience the world in unique ways, often shaped by their socio-economic status, historical context, physical abilities, or cultural background.
Suggests that treating everyone the same does not always promote fairness due to varying needs. Instead, it advocates for providing differentiated support, resources, or accommodations to level the playing field, ensuring that everyone has a genuine chance to succeed. This might involve affirmative action, special education services, or accessible infrastructure.
The Importance of Differentiation
Acknowledging the differences among individuals and communities is crucial for achieving equity. Without this recognition, policies intended to create "equality" can inadvertently perpetuate or exacerbate existing disparities.
Situations may arise where treating everyone equally could lead to disadvantages, e.g.:
Example: Expecting everyone to read a book written in French may confuse individuals who do not understand the language. In this case, an equitable approach would provide translations or alternative learning materials.
Another example: Providing a standard ramp for wheelchair users is important, but if the ramp's incline is too steep, it may still not be truly accessible for all users, requiring modifications or additional support.
A further example: A standardized test might assess knowledge, but if some students lack access to quality education or have learning disabilities, providing the same test without accommodations creates an unequal playing field.
Illustrating the Concepts
Metaphor:
Equality: Giving everyone the same ladder to pick mangoes represents equality in access to opportunities. Everyone gets a ladder of the same height, assuming everyone starts from the same position and has the same ability to climb.
Equity: Recognizing that not everyone can use the same ladder implies that accommodations must be made for different abilities and circumstances. Some individuals might need a shorter ladder, a longer ladder, a stool, or even assistance to reach the mangoes, depending on their height, strength, or physical location relative to the tree. The goal is for everyone to successfully pick mangoes, not just to have a ladder.
Community Responsibility
Advocating for the protection of the community is a vital part of achieving equity, as individual well-being is interconnected with collective health and safety. Actions such as:
Washing hands meticulously.
Wearing masks when visiting sick individuals can help mitigate health risks for everyone, especially vulnerable populations.
Participating in community initiatives that address root causes of inequality, like food insecurity or lack of affordable housing, further demonstrates this responsibility.
Inclusivity in Values:
Every individual, regardless of their background, socio-economic status, gender, race, religion, or ability, has equal value and should have access to the same opportunities (symbolized by "mangoes"). This principle requires actively working to dismantle systemic barriers and biases that prevent certain groups from reaching their full potential.
Call to Action
Creating a truly fair and just world requires collective effort from all individuals and institutions. It's not just about individual acts of kindness but systemic change.
Important behaviors include:
Looking out for one another, fostering empathy and mutual support within communities.
Showing respect towards others, acknowledging and valuing diverse perspectives and identities.
Understanding that different individuals experience life differently and may require different kinds of support to achieve equitable outcomes
– this means being open to providing resources, creating accessible environments, and advocating for policies that cater to varied needs, rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. This involves listening to marginalized voices and centering their experiences in problem-solving.