Finite Potential Well and Sketching Wave Functions

Finite Potential Well - Solutions and Review

  • The general solutions to the finite potential well problem include terms with c<em>2cos(kx)c<em>2 \cos(kx), c</em>3eαxc</em>3 e^{-\alpha x}, and c4eαxc_4 e^{\alpha x}.
  • The first solution resembles a sinusoidal function within the well (up to l/2-l/2) and decaying exponential functions outside the well.
  • This is similar to the infinite box problem but with non-zero probability outside the box.
  • Classically forbidden regions: areas where classical mechanics predicts a particle cannot exist because its energy would be less than the potential.
  • For the n=1n=1 solution:
    • Inside the box: the wave function looks like c2cos(kx)c_2 \cos(kx).
    • Outside the box (right): c3eαxc_3 e^{-\alpha x}.
    • Outside the box (left): eαxe^{\alpha x}.
  • Energy levels in the finite well are discrete, similar to the infinite well, but only up to a certain point. Above the potential, the energy levels become a continuum, resembling a free particle.

Boundary Conditions and Continuity

  • To solve the finite well, boundary conditions must be matched:
    • The wave function must be continuous at x=±l/2x = \pm l/2.
    • The derivative of the wave function must also be continuous at x=±l/2x = \pm l/2.
  • Continuity of the wave function:
    • c<em>2cos(kl/2)=c</em>3eαl/2c<em>2 \cos(kl/2) = c</em>3 e^{-\alpha l/2}
  • α\alpha describes how far the wave function extends into the classically forbidden region.
    • Imagine ex/(1/α)e^{-x/(1/\alpha)} where 1α\frac{1}{\alpha} represents a characteristic length. The wave function declines by 68% over this length, similar to a capacitor losing charge over one time constant.

Differentiability and Solving for Energy Eigenstate

  • Differentiability of the wave function:
    • dψdx\frac{d\psi}{dx} evaluated at x=+l/2x = +l/2 (inside the box) must equal dψdx\frac{d\psi}{dx} evaluated at x=+l/2x = +l/2 (outside the box).
  • Taking the derivative of the wave function inside the box:
    • c2ksin(kl/2)-c_2 k \sin(kl/2)
  • Taking the derivative of the wave function outside the box (on the right):
    • αc3eαl/2- \alpha c_3 e^{-\alpha l/2}
  • By dividing the differentiability equation by the continuity equation, we eliminate c<em>2c<em>2 and c</em>3c</em>3.
    • ksin(kl/2)cos(kl/2)=αc<em>3eαl/2c</em>3eαl/2\frac{-k \sin(kl/2)}{\cos(kl/2)} = \frac{-\alpha c<em>3 e^{-\alpha l/2}}{c</em>3 e^{-\alpha l/2}}
    • α=ktan(kl/2)\alpha = k \tan(kl/2)

Relationship Between α\alpha and kk

  • kk is a function of EE, while α\alpha depends on both the potential V0V_0 and the energy level EE.
  • Graphing α\alpha as a function of kk:
    • The tangent function approaches infinity when its argument approaches π/2\pi/2 radians.

The Circle Equation

  • k2+α2=2mV02k^2 + \alpha^2 = \frac{2mV_0}{\hbar^2}
  • This equation represents a circle.
  • Let k<em>0=2mV</em>02k<em>0 = \sqrt{\frac{2mV</em>0}{\hbar^2}}, where k0k_0 is the wave number associated with the potential.
  • The equation becomes: k2+α2=k02k^2 + \alpha^2 = k_0^2

Graphical Solutions for Energy Levels

  • The solutions for kk (and thus, EE) are found where the circle intersects with the tangent function.
  • Increasing the potential increases the radius of the circle, leading to more intersections and thus more discrete energy levels.
  • Solutions for E < V_0 cannot be found analytically, but they can be found graphically.

Bound States and Potential

  • For a given potential, there will be a finite number of bound state solutions.
  • As the potential approaches infinity, the finite well problem approaches the infinite well problem.
  • In the limit as V0V_0 \rightarrow \infty, the solutions correspond to sin(nπx/L)\sin(n \pi x / L).
  • There will always be at least one bound state, even for a very small potential.
  • Bound states imply that the probability of finding the particle at ±\pm \infty is zero.

Additional Considerations and Subtleties

  • α\alpha is considered positive because E < V_0 for bound state solutions.
  • The first solution has a cosine function, the second has a sine function, the third has a cosine function, and so on.
  • Only solutions with cosine in the middle region were initially found (k1, k3, k5, etc.).

Even Solutions

  • For even solutions (E2, E4, E6), use c1sin(kx)c_1 \sin(kx).
  • The same mathematical process is followed, but the boundary condition equations change slightly due to switching from cosine to sine.
  • α=kcot(kl/2)\alpha = -k \cot(kl/2)
  • The equation k2+α2=k02k^2 + \alpha^2 = k_0^2 still holds (the circle function remains the same).

Graphical Analysis with Cotangent

  • To find even solutions, graph cot(kl/2)-\cot(kl/2).
  • Intersections between the circle and the cotangent curves give the allowed energy levels.
  • The number of bound states depends on the potential energy. A larger potential leads to more bound states.
  • As potential goes to infinity, the number of bound states approaches infinity, and the finite well merges with the infinite well problem.

General Properties of Bound States

  • For any potential with bound states:
    • The first solution has no nodes (zeros) between the boundaries.
    • The next bound state has one node.
    • The one after that has two nodes, and so on.

Sketching Wave Functions for Arbitrary Potentials

  • For the eigenvalue problem: 22md2ψdx2=(EV)ψ-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m} \frac{d^2 \psi}{dx^2} = (E - V) \psi
  • Rearranging, we get: d2ψdx2=2m2(VE)ψ\frac{d^2 \psi}{dx^2} = \frac{2m}{\hbar^2} (V - E) \psi
  • The second derivative is related to the curvature of the wave function.
    • If the second derivative is positive, the function is concave up.
    • If the second derivative is negative, the function is concave down.
  • When E > V, the solution exhibits sinusoidal behavior.
  • When E < V, the behavior is exponential.
  • The magnitude of the second derivative (and thus the tightness of the curvature) is proportional to EV|E - V|.

Sketching Example and Considerations

  • Regions where E is much bigger than V gives large negative number, The function has a larger curvature or tighter curvature
  • In classically allowed regions (E > V), the wave function oscillates.
  • In classically forbidden regions (E < V), the wave function decays exponentially and is concave up.

Estimating Energy Levels

  • Estimate the first energy level by pretending that the function goes to zero at a characteristic length beyond the well.
  • E1=2π22mL2E_1 = \frac{\hbar^2 \pi^2}{2m L^2}
  • Replace L with an effective length: L+2(1/α)L + 2(1/\alpha)
  • E12π22m(L+2/α)2E_1 \approx \frac{\hbar^2 \pi^2}{2m (L + 2/\alpha)^2}
  • This approximation treats the finite well like an infinite box problem with extended boundaries. The smaller the potential, the longer the extended box.