ISS notes
Focus:normative and positive/benefits of min. wage
Positive
a factual statement
used to understand casual relationships
Normative
includes a value statement
Should people work while going to school?
Whether a policy is good or bad will require normative judgement
Haider talk notes
Sep 10,2026
Fixing social security
Old age insurance-for the risk of living too long
Social security is incredibly popular with everyone(why?)
Regardless of political party, the program is still popular
Pay-as-you-go system / not a funded retirement plan-all used by federal government
Dependent on the ratio of workers to retirees being greater
1940: 159-1 worker to retiree, now estimated to be a 2.6 ratio and decreasing
Trust fund peaked in 2010, projected to be exhausted in 2032(what does that mean for future generations?)
Not a election topic while being in major trouble
If trust fund goes to zero, its still a pay as you go
If retirees bare the brunt of the trust fund running out, benefits are reduced
If we do nothing social security doesn’t disappear, benefits are reduced by 22%
In order to save SS, keep it internally solvent
reduce benefits(reduce monthly payments)
raise taxes (payroll,raise taxable minimum)
“Its just raising taxes”
“Its not rocket science”
It wasnt formulated in a way for people to live another 20 years
The system wasnt made for people to live as long as they do now
Raising the retirement makes sense because
industrial change
health improvements
disability programs
pensions
Widespread support for changes(why havent they been made?)
The system has high approval and changes to keep the system afloat are popular
Really fixing social security
Enriching older americans but not say a pregnant women who can work
Choose tax cuts and benefit reductions to ensure it stays afloat
Raise retirement age
Let people borrow 36 months of SS, up to the individual to use
Lifelong security allows for mistakes to be made
People can draw on social security when they need it, up to 36 months
Cost neutral is possible
Lifelong security lessens the need for other programs
Biggest challenge against LS, is our beliefs:the idea of extended leave being seen as lazy
Bolder talk notes
Sep 17,2026
Should we tax soda?
The Costs
The direct costs of obesity has more than doubled since 2001 and continues to rise
53.5% paid by private health insurance and 22.2% by public programs
Diabetes costs continue to increase(85%)
SSB increase risk of obesity, type 2 and heart disease (do people know the risk?)
Why are people consuming so much soda?
Habit formation-it just becomes normal
The problem doesn’t matter to me today
Soda Tax
local governments put a volume tax(ex.1 cent/oz)
In favor arguments
Fairness, I don’t buy soda so why should I pay for people who are affected
Help people make healthier choices(shouldn’t people be able to make their own decisions and not be punished?)
Raise revenue
Who actually pays the tax?
The party with better outside option bears less of the burden
Consequences of taxing
Full pass through puts all the pressure on consumers
For individual servings the pass through is higher(would this cause people to buy more?)
People will just go somewhere else to buy something
Critiques
We shouldn’t be telling people what they should do
Large burden on local governments to manage this
Why don’t we focus on the actual problem of sugar? Less inefficient(why not other unhealthy things?)
Individual behaviors are under a microscope when we should really look at societal, legal and geographical problems (Are you going to punish people who may only have access to certain drinks?)
Anderson talk notes
Social cost of carbon
Co2 concentrations are rising in the atmosphere
Rising global temp has been seen to coincide with Co2 concentrations rising (so we know there is a relationship?)
Damages have been linked to rising temps
Damages
Heat waves-stress electrical grid, crops failing, coastal erosion and floods
We benefit from cheap travel, heating and electricity | Climate costs fall on other people and even other generations | We are not paying the cost now |
Social cost of carbon
How much damage does that cause to people around the world, living today and out into the future, expressed in today’s dollars?
To answer questions must be answered for economists
How much damage does climate change cause? Costly harms:Heat exposure-injury/death,Drought:crop loss, Storm surge:property damage
How much are future damages worth today?
How we attempt to combat costs as a result of climate change
Air conditioning-less heat related deaths
Irrigation-less crop loss from drought
Sea walls-less property loss from storms
Why do we focus on being reactive instead of being proactive?
How expensive is it to adapt?
Total cost=cost of adaptation+harms that remain
Model of the impact of greenhouse gases:GIVE(Greenhouse gas impact value estimator)
Requires a lot of assumptions
Plenty of uncertainty in climate outputs
Put a price on carbon/tax on carbon
Government sets price | Cap and Trade | Permit to create emissions/gov sets quantities of permits |
Market determines emissions | market determines price | |
Price creates incentive to reduce | permit price is incentive to reduce |
27 noble recipients signed a proposal for a tax on carbon
In conclusion
Climate change is an international externality
Damage depends on impact and adaptation
Future damages must be discounted todau
Social Cost of Carbon- combines the prices but is highly uncertain
Carbon pricing creates incentives to reduce
Cooperation on a massive scale is key for reducing emissions
Imberman talk notes
Impacts of going to college
On average people with college degrees earns 2.3 million over their working life vs highschool grads making around 1.3 million
Who is able and more likely to go to college
wealthier
did better in school
worked harder
career goals
The causal benefit of college
Must find two almost identical people using a admission threshold: went to college vs did not
Early career earnings are 22% higher just from going to college
Going to a college vs going to msu
Impact attending a flag ship-again a earnings increase of 20% vs going to a separate institution or not attending
Not all institutions guarantee the earnings increase (is it still worth it to attend college? should people who can’t afford the costs of a flagship college even try to go to a non flagship college?)
Is the trade off of paying to go college worth the possibility of earning more?
You pay now and then get the return later
The money today is worth more than the money tomorrow
The money is not the end all
college may make you a millionaire in a sense of the term but theres more to life than money
Eguia talk notes
Gerrymandering
how does it influence elections?
how should it be drawn?
“This pretty mid-michigan polygon”(why is it drawn like that?)
Towns and counties used to be represented by themselves not districts
There was no need to draw
Larger towns obviously had more sway
1960 USSC
districts must have equal pop.
expands smaller districts to match
The votes are the same the representation we get is very different
How can a map be fair?
“a map is fair if it does not inflate the seats a party gets”
Do it as the colonials
The result of this would be on avg: 7.3 dem and 5.7 repub vs. drawn maps 7.2 and 5.8
Prof. Eguia’s role
Reviewed and stated how the map is wrong and does not represent the voters in detroit well
Led to detroit being split in 2ish districts vs the illegal map drawn in 2018 by the GOP
Philosophy-Whats fair,the “should”
“The strong do what they can…” (are we really properly represented?)
Creates the view of others as “bad” or “traitors” (people want to win, regardless of fairness)(is gerrymandering to a degree cheating?)
Fairness would be argued by both sides
Its hard to make such a change on normative statements
Doblas-Madrid notes
Bubbles,crashes and greater fools
Tulipmania-first crash 1637
An investor Irving was convinced in 1920’s that stocks had reached a permanent plateau later he lost massively when a bubble burst
Newton-I can calculate the motion of the heavens but not the mindlessness of people
Stock market investing and bubbles
Stocks are shares/fractions of ownership of companies
Bubbles result in stock prices rising without a match in dividends received
New technology drives prices up often leading to FOMO and greed lures in investors (ai?)
When prices inflate pass the fundamental value it signals a bubble about to pop
Are bubbles bad?
Efficient Market Hypothesis
Not all booms lead to crash, half typically do
Simply because a price exceeds fundamental value does not mean that something is bound to happen
Values may be changed by collateral,money,gold,art and things like bitcoin
FV is not solely swayed by dividends
It is incredibly hard to guess when bubbles are bound to happen and buy and holds often succeed far better than mutual funds based on that way of thinking
After every crash markets have rebounded past their peak (are bubbles natural?)(why do we think of them so negatively if half the time they don’t cause a crash?)
Bubbles steer people in the wrong directions ex. housing crash people moved from going to school to go into construction which was not good in the long term
Levy notes
AI and the Job Market
AI is known to be a massive technological disruption
Has occurred before and the economy rebounded, its always asked “is this time different?”
A group of skilled workers called The Luddites were very scared that they were going to lose there jobs due to advancing technology(the comparison to today)
The market forces how and if the technology is used
Technological innovation typically benefits many and harmful to few
How is AI different?
Affects such a broad range of occupations, unlike previous innovations that typically phased out on job group
AI can spread unusually quick
Could eliminate entry level jobs that are needed to acquire more senior level jobs
AI typically is seen to affect the jobs that 22-25 are usually involved in by 19%
Expertise is even more valued but the roles that are meant to give you the experience are being affected
Is this time different?
Because we are living through it we don’t know
Set yourself apart