SCH3145 Biomedical Ethics - Animals in Research
Topic = Guest Lecture 2 (Animal Ethics)
Lecturer and Contact Information
Lecturer: Andrew J. Woo, PhD.
Human Health Burden and the Need for Biomedical Research
Core Objective of Biomedical Research: The primary motivation is the valuation of human life, seeking to reduce the global health burden and save lives.
Global Cancer Burden (2020 Statistics):
Cancer is identified as a leading cause of death worldwide.
Total cancer-related deaths in 2020: Approximately (10 million).
Most common causes of cancer deaths:
Lung cancer: deaths.
Colorectal cancer: deaths.
Liver cancer: deaths.
Stomach cancer: deaths.
Breast cancer: deaths.
Top 15 Causes of Death in Australia:
1. Ischaemic heart diseases.
2. Dementia, including Alzheimer's disease.
3. Cerebrovascular diseases.
4. Malignant neoplasm of trachea, bronchus, and lung.
5. Chronic lower respiratory diseases.
6. Diabetes.
7. Malignant neoplasm of colon, sigmoid, rectum, and anus.
8. Malignant neoplasms of lymphoid, haematopoietic, and related tissue.
9. COVID-19.
10. Diseases of the urinary system.
11. Accidental falls.
12. Heart failure and complications (including ill-defined heart disease).
13. Malignant neoplasm of prostate.
14. Malignant neoplasm of pancreas.
15. Malignant neoplasms of breast.
Species-Specific Applications in Research and Teaching
Rats and Mice:
Used as disease models for cancer and genetic research.
Used for testing pharmaceutical drug activity.
Essential for genome research.
Pigs:
Applied in teaching surgery and medical procedures.
Used for transplantation research.
Common in veterinary research.
Dogs:
Critical for heart surgery developments.
Utilized in bone marrow transplantation research.
Used in veterinary research and teaching.
Fish:
Extensively used for drug screening.
Used in genome research and veterinary studies.
Cows and Horses:
Vital for vaccine development and isolation.
Standard in veterinary research and teaching.
Rabbits:
Used for vaccine development.
Applied in tests for drug activity.
Statistics of Animal Use in Australia
State-by-State Breakdown of Animal Usage:
New South Wales (2017): .
Queensland (2017): .
Victoria (2017): .
Western Australia (2017): .
South Australia: (yearly average).
Tasmania (2017): .
ACT: (yearly average).
Northern Territory: (yearly average).
2016 Statistics by Species (Specific Totals):
Mouse: .
Rat: .
Guinea Pig: .
Rabbit: .
Primates: .
Domestic Fowl: .
Other Birds: .
Reptiles: .
Fish: .
Arguments in Favor of Animal Research (The Pros)
Legal Mandates:
Current laws dictate that any new medicinal drug intended for human use must undergo substantial testing.
Required testing includes at least two different species of live mammals, one of which must be a large non-rodent.
Pharmaceutical companies are legally obligated to perform these tests regardless of ethical stance.
Inherent Biological Complexity:
Life is complex; in vitro (cell culture) studies cannot address complex physiological questions.
Diseases often involve whole-organ systems that require evaluation in a whole animal model.
Basic biological understanding is a prerequisite for developing diagnostics and treatments.
Scientific Arguments:
Pathway to drug development: In vitro —> In vivo (animal studies) —> Human trials.
Historical breakthroughs include:
Penicillin (1940): Saved mice from lethal Streptococcus infections.
Blood Transfusion (1915): Citrate first demonstrated to permit transfusions in dogs.
Tuberculosis (1943): Streptomycin treatment suppressed disease in guinea pigs.
Macular Degeneration (1998): Surgical techniques developed over 40 years using multiple species.
Additional breakthroughs in Asthma, Meningitis, Kidney Transplants, Breast Cancer, Parkinson’s disease, and Diabetes.
Non-Medical Applications:
Environmental science and animal conservation.
Veterinary science focused on improving animal health.
Philosophical/Societal Arguments:
Human life is argued to have greater intrinsic value than animal life.
Lab animals are protected by legislation from cruelty/mistreatment.
Relative comparison: Millions of animals are killed for food; research is framed as a more "worthy" cause of death.
Claims often suggest few animals feel pain and are euthanized before suffering occurs.
Arguments Against Animal Research (The Cons)
Scientific Limitations:
Interspecies Variation: A mouse is not a human. Responses in an animal do not always resemble human responses.
Model Invalidation: For an animal to be a valid model, it must share the same biological mechanisms, symptoms, and treatment responses as humans. Failure to meet these criteria "invalidates" the model.
Expert Critiques:
Dr. Richard Klausner (Former Director of the National Cancer Institute): "The history of cancer research has been a history of curing cancer in the mouse. We have cured mice of cancer for decades and it simply didn't work in humans."
Dr. Clif Barry (Chief, Tuberculosis Research Section, NIAID): "Mice are mice, and people are people. If we look to the mouse to model every aspect of the disease for man, and to model cures, we're just wasting our time."
Non-Scientific/Ethical Arguments:
Animals possess an equal right to live as humans.
Strict controls fail to prevent rare instances of abuse.
Deaths in research are viewed by some as unnecessary.
Animals suffer during confinement, and measuring the exact onset of pain is difficult.
Regulations and the 3 Rs
The Australian Code: All Australian universities and research institutions are bound by the "Australian code for the care and use of animals for scientific purposes" (governed by the NHMRC).
Scope of the Code:
Covers research, teaching, field trials, product testing, diagnosis, and production of biological products.
Applies to all live non-human vertebrates and cephalopods.
Covers the entire lifecycle: acquisition, transport, breeding, housing, husbandry, usage, and post-project provisions.
Enforcement:
Managed by Animal Ethics Committees (AECs).
Supported by Animal Ethics Offices, Welfare Officers, and Veterinary Advisers.
Committees include both scientific experts and lay members.
The 3 Rs (Origin: Russell and Burch, 1959, "The principle of humane experimental technique"):
1. Replace:
Complete replacement: Using dummies, mechanical, or computer models (no animal-derived components).
Incomplete replacement: Using in vitro cell lines or substituting higher organisms with lower ones (microorganisms, plants, invertebrates).
Utilizing epidemiological studies or human volunteers.
2. Reduce:
Minimizing animal numbers to reach statistical significance.
Improved experimental techniques and data analysis.
Information sharing to avoid duplicate studies.
Reducing variables like stress, diet, and overcrowding.
3. Refine:
Alleviating pain and distress while enhancing wellbeing.
Implementing training for proper handling.
Using less invasive methods (e.g., anesthesia and analgesia).
Practicing high-standard animal husbandry to allow natural behaviors.
Historical, Present, and Future Perspectives
The Past:
Historically illustrated by Joseph Wright of Derby's 1768 painting "An Experiment on a Bird in an air pump" (demonstrating Boyle’s law: volume of gas decreases with increasing pressure).
1884 Harper's Weekly supported dog research as "humane and justified."
1885: Louis Pasteur conducted first successful human trials for the rabies vaccine.
The Present:
COVID-19 Research (2020): Moderna's vaccine showed immune response in people and protected mice from lung infection. Oxford vaccine protected monkeys from pneumonia.
Genetic Engineering: Deleting or introducing genes to better mimic human functions.
Patient-Derived Xenograft (PDX) Models: Transplanting human cancer cells into immune-compromised mice for personalized drug testing.
The Future:
Human Organ Generation: Injecting human stem cells into pig embryos (genetically modified to lack certain organs) to grow "human-like" organs for transplant.
Organoids: 3D tissue cultures from stem cells (Brain, Lung, Liver) that mimic organ functions.
iPSC Technology (Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells): Creating complex models for inhalation, oral, dermal, and intravenous testing on human-derived tissues.