Untitled Flashcards Set

History of Stress Research

1.AHistory of Stress Research

This section will acquaint you with prominent stress researchers and their important contributions to this field. These contributions form the foundation of our understanding of stress, stress management, and stress research.

Walter Cannon: Fight or Flight and Homeostasis

Born on October 19, 1871, Walter Cannon was an American physiologist and was the chair of the Department of Physiology at Harvard Medical School. One of his major accomplishments was that he was the first to describe the effects of acute stress. He described this reaction to stress as the fight-or-flight response.

He also developed the concept of homeostasis based on the earlier work of Claude Bernard.

Walter Cannon described homeostasis as “the property of either an open system or a closed system that regulates its internal environment so as to maintain a stable constant condition.”1 An open system is a system that is influenced by the environment, whereas a closed system is not influenced by the environment. In this theory, there is a set point and any deviation from the set point results in physiological changes that work to bring the value back to the set point. The theory comes from observations of physiological values like blood sugar, blood pH, and blood pressure. For example, when blood sugar is elevated, insulin is promptly released to bring it back to baseline levels. Similarly, if blood sugar is low, glucagon is released to increase blood sugar. Thus, the amount of blood sugar in the blood is defended, and any deviation from this value will result in a coordinated effort to restore the baseline value.

The following are the four features of homeostasis described by Walter Cannon:

1.    "Constancy in an open system [one that interacts with its environment], such as our bodies represent, requires mechanisms that act to maintain this constancy . . .

2.    Steady-state conditions require that any tendency toward change automatically meets with factors that resist change . . .

3.    The regulating system that determines the homeostatic state consists of a number of cooperating mechanisms acting simultaneously or successively . . .

4.    Homeostasis does not occur by chance but is the result of organized self-government.”2

In addition to homeostasis, Walter Cannon described the primary process of restoring homeostasis and termed it the fight-or-flight response. A fight-or-flight response is a primitive instinct that quickly increases heart rate, respiration, blood pressure, and serum cholesterol. It is the body’s primary means of restoring homeostasis under pressure. We will talk extensively about this process in the next topic.

Hans Selye: Stress and General Adaptation Syndrome

Hans Selye was born on January 26, 1907. He was an Austrian-Canadian endocrinologist who built on the work done by Walter Cannon and studied the long-term physiological effects of (chronic) stress.

He coined the word stress and defined it as “the nonspecific response of the body to any demand made upon it.”3 He also noted that stress was different than other physiological responses in that stress can come from both good and bad situations. Thus, whether you have a happy or fun event (like marriage or graduation) or a sad or frustrating event (like a death in the family, a bad grade, or a fight with a roommate), the physiological response is similar.4 He defined good stress as eustress and bad stress as distress.

Hans Selye summarized his findings by proposing a three-phase process called the general adaptation syndrome. The general adaptation syndrome describes how the body responds to prolonged stress. In this video clip, I will describe the general adaptation syndrome.

General Adaptation Syndrome

Stage 1: Alarm Reaction

·       Phase 1: Shock: The body may exhibit signs of shock, and the ability to resist and cope with the stressor decreases.

·       Phase 2: Antishock: The body recognizes the stressor and starts to respond. The sympathetic nervous system is activated and triggers the fight-or-flight response. This changes muscle tone, blood pressure, heart rate, vascular tone, and blood sugar, and activates the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis.

Stage 2: Resistance

·       The body elevates the secretion of hormones, specifically cortisol, epinephrine, and norepinephrine.

·       The body is actively trying to resist the stressor and meet demands. The body is in a heightened state of arousal, and demands on resources are high. Because of this heightened demand for resources, the body cannot sustain this stage indefinitely. Resources are gradually depleted.

Stage 3: Recovery or Exhaustion 

·       If the stressor remains, the body moves towards exhaustion; however, if the stressor is taken away, the body moves toward recovery.

·       During exhaustion, the body’s resources are depleted, and the body is unable to maintain normal function. If this continues, the body can be damaged, and the body’s ability to resist the stressor is diminished. This can lead to obvious physical disease such as diabetes, hypertension, GI distress, and heart problems, as well as psychological disorders like depression, post-traumatic stress disorder, and anxiety disorders.

Check Your Learning 

Drag and drop the phase tiles into the correct positions on the chart. Check your answers. 

We’ll talk more about how disease is related to prolonged stress in the next couple of sections. In extreme cases with exceptionally high levels of sustained stress, the body cannot cope, which can lead to death.

Robert M. Sapolsky: Evolution and Modern-Day Stress

Dr. Sapolsky (neuroendocrinologist and primatologist) has extensively researched stress and its effects on health, in both humans and primates. In his writings he discusses how the stress response, which evolved to deal with acute physical threats, is often triggered by modern psychological stressors that are chronic and less immediately threatening.

Dr. Sapolsky suggests that while our stress response systems (fight or flight) evolved to cope with acute physical dangers such as predators, our bodies react in a similar way to modern stressors like social media posts, work deadlines, traffic, and finances. He has argued that the chronic activation of the stress response (fight or flight) can have detrimental effects on physical and mental health given enough time. In other words, our physiological response to stress has not significantly evolved to match the changing nature of stressors in modern society, contributing to the widespread prevalence of stress-related illnesses.5

Peter Sterling and Joseph Eyer are contemporary scientists who have challenged the theory of homeostasis and proposed the more stress-appropriate theory of allostasis. The theory of homeostasis claims that the purpose of biological systems is to maintain stability, whereas allostasis claims that the purpose of biological systems is to meet demand in a changing environment. We will discuss more about allostasis, read Dr. Singer’s article, and evaluate how allostasis differs from Cannon’s homeostasis in Module 3.