Required Court Cases
Brown v. Board of Education
Facts: Black students were forced to attend separate schools from white students.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Segregation in public schools is unconstitutional.
Why it matters:
Overturned Plessy v. Ferguson
Said “separate is NOT equal”
Started desegregation
Expanded civil rights protections
Tinker v. Des Moines
Facts: Students wore black armbands to protest Vietnam War and were suspended.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Speech
Decision: Students have free speech in school unless it disrupts learning.
Why it matters:
Students do not lose rights at school
Schools can limit speech only if disruptive
Schenck v. United States
Facts: Schenck gave anti-draft pamphlets during WWI.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Speech
Decision: Speech can be limited if it creates clear and present danger.
Why it matters:
Created clear and present danger test
Shows speech is not absolute
Engel v. Vitale
Facts: Public school required a daily prayer.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Establishment Clause
Decision: School prayer led by government is unconstitutional.
Why it matters:
Government cannot promote religion
Separation of church and state
Wisconsin v. Yoder
Facts: Amish parents refused to send kids to school past 8th grade.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Free Exercise Clause
Decision: Amish could stop school for religious reasons.
Why it matters:
Protects religious freedom
Free exercise > state law in this case
Gideon v. Wainwright
Facts: Gideon could not afford a lawyer and was denied one.
Amendment: 6th Amendment (via 14th Amendment incorporation)
Decision: States must provide lawyers to poor defendants.
Why it matters:
Right to counsel required in state courts
Example of selective incorporation
McDonald v. Chicago
Facts: Chicago banned handguns.
Amendment: 2nd Amendment + 14th Amendment
Decision: 2nd Amendment applies to states.
Why it matters:
Incorporated right to bear arms
Limited state gun bans
Citizens United v. FEC
Facts: Law limited how much corporations could spend on elections.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Speech
Decision: Political spending = protected speech.
Why it matters:
Money = speech
Allowed Super PACs
Increased role of interest groups in elections
Gonzales v. Raich
Facts: California allowed medical marijuana, but federal law banned it
Amendment: Commerce Clause
Decision: Federal government can ban marijuana even in states where it’s legal
Why it matters:
Federal law overrides state drug laws
Expanded federal commerce power
United States v. Nixon
Facts: Nixon refused to release Watergate tapes
Amendment: Separation of Powers (Article II vs Judiciary)
Decision: President is not above the law; must release evidence
Why it matters:
Limited executive privilege
Strengthened judicial power over president
Bush v. Gore
Facts: Disputed 2000 presidential election recount in Florida
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Florida recount stopped; Bush becomes president
Why it matters:
Decided presidential election
Limited inconsistent ballot recount standards
Korematsu v. United States (already listed in your set? if not, keep it)
(keeping here only in case your teacher expects it in Unit 2/5)
Facts: Japanese internment during WWII
Amendment: 5th Amendment
Decision: Internment upheld (later widely condemned)
Why it matters:
Shows wartime limits on civil liberties
Later effectively discredited
Texas v. Johnson
Facts: Flag burning protest
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Free Speech
Decision: Flag burning is protected speech
Why it matters:
Symbolic speech is protected
Government cannot ban offensive expression
District of Columbia v. Heller
Facts: DC handgun ban
Amendment: 2nd Amendment
Decision: Individuals have right to own firearms unrelated to militia
Why it matters:
Strengthened individual gun rights
Set up McDonald incorporation later
Shapiro v. Thompson
Facts: States required residency before welfare benefits
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection
Decision: Residency requirements unconstitutional
Why it matters:
Protected right to travel between states
Limited state control over welfare access
Furman v. Georgia
Facts: Death penalty applied inconsistently
Amendment: 8th Amendment — Cruel and unusual punishment
Decision: Current death penalty laws unconstitutional (at the time)
Why it matters:
Temporarily halted death penalty
Forced states to rewrite laws
Gregg v. Georgia
Facts: Revised death penalty laws after Furman
Amendment: 8th Amendment
Decision: Death penalty is constitutional if applied fairly
Why it matters:
Reinstated death penalty
Created modern capital punishment system
Clinton v. City of New York
Facts: Line-item veto used by president
Amendment: Separation of Powers
Decision: Line-item veto is unconstitutional
Why it matters:
Limited presidential legislative power
INS v. Chadha
Facts: Congress tried to overturn deportation decision with one-house veto
Amendment: Separation of Powers
Decision: Legislative veto unconstitutional
Why it matters:
Strengthened checks and balances
Congress must pass laws properly
Marbury v. Madison
Facts: Marbury sued Madison for not delivering his judicial appointment.
Amendment: Article III (Judicial Review implied)
Decision: Established judicial review (courts can strike down unconstitutional laws).
Why it matters:
Courts gained power to review laws
Made judiciary equal to other branches
Foundation of constitutional law
McCulloch v. Maryland
Facts: Maryland taxed the national bank.
Amendment: Necessary and Proper Clause + Supremacy Clause
Decision: States cannot tax federal institutions; federal laws override state laws.
Why it matters:
Strengthened federal power over states
Established implied powers
Expanded national government authority
Gibbons v. Ogden
Facts: New York granted a steamboat monopoly on interstate waters.
Amendment: Commerce Clause
Decision: Only Congress can regulate interstate commerce.
Why it matters:
Expanded federal control over trade
Limited state economic power
Defined interstate commerce authority
Plessy v. Ferguson
Facts: Black and white passengers were required to use separate train cars.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Segregation is constitutional if facilities are “separate but equal.”
Why it matters:
Legalized segregation for decades
Later overturned by Brown v. Board
Justified Jim Crow laws
Mapp v. Ohio
Facts: Police illegally searched Mapp’s home without a warrant.
Amendment: 4th Amendment (search and seizure)
Decision: Illegally obtained evidence cannot be used in court (exclusionary rule applies to states).
Why it matters:
Strengthened Fourth Amendment protections
Limited police power
Applied exclusionary rule to states
Miranda v. Arizona
Facts: Suspect confessed without being informed of rights.
Amendment: 5th Amendment — Self-incrimination
Decision: Police must inform suspects of rights before questioning.
Why it matters:
Created “Miranda rights”
Protects accused during interrogation
Ensures fair legal process
New York Times v. United States
Facts: Government tried to stop publication of Pentagon Papers.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Press
Decision: Government cannot prevent publication unless direct national security threat is proven.
Why it matters:
Strengthened press freedom
Limited government censorship
Protected investigative journalism
Baker v. Carr
Facts: Tennessee had unequal legislative districts and refused to redraw them.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Redistricting issues are constitutional and can be decided by courts.
Why it matters:
“One person, one vote” principle begins
Courts can handle redistricting cases
Increased voting equality
Reynolds v. Sims
Facts: State legislative districts had unequal populations.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: State legislative districts must have roughly equal populations.
Why it matters:
Strengthened “one person, one vote”
Equalized representation in states
Reduced rural overrepresentation
NFIB v. Sebelius
Facts: Affordable Care Act required individuals to buy health insurance.
Amendment: Commerce Clause / Taxing Power
Decision: Individual mandate upheld as a tax, not under commerce power.
Why it matters:
Limited Commerce Clause expansion
Upheld Obamacare
Strengthened federal taxing authority
United States v. Lopez
Facts: Student brought gun to school under federal Gun-Free School Zones Act.
Amendment: Commerce Clause
Decision: Congress exceeded its commerce power.
Why it matters:
First major limit on federal power in decades
Defined limits of Commerce Clause
Strengthened states’ rights
Obergefell v. Hodges
Facts: Same-sex couples were denied marriage licenses in some states.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection & Due Process
Decision: Same-sex marriage is a constitutional right.
Why it matters:
Legalized same-sex marriage nationwide
Expanded civil rights
Strengthened equal protection doctrine
Shaw v. Reno
Facts: North Carolina created oddly shaped districts based on race.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Racial gerrymandering can violate the Constitution.
Why it matters:
Limited race-based redistricting
Protected voting fairness
Set standards for district drawing
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke
Facts: Medical school used racial quotas in admissions.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Quotas are unconstitutional, but race can be considered in admissions.
Why it matters:
Allowed limited affirmative action
Banned strict racial quotas
Shaped college admissions policy