Required Court Cases

Brown v. Board of Education

Facts: Black students were forced to attend separate schools from white students.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Segregation in public schools is unconstitutional.
Why it matters:

  • Overturned Plessy v. Ferguson

  • Said “separate is NOT equal”

  • Started desegregation

  • Expanded civil rights protections


Tinker v. Des Moines

Facts: Students wore black armbands to protest Vietnam War and were suspended.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Speech
Decision: Students have free speech in school unless it disrupts learning.
Why it matters:

  • Students do not lose rights at school

  • Schools can limit speech only if disruptive


Schenck v. United States

Facts: Schenck gave anti-draft pamphlets during WWI.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Speech
Decision: Speech can be limited if it creates clear and present danger.
Why it matters:

  • Created clear and present danger test

  • Shows speech is not absolute


Engel v. Vitale

Facts: Public school required a daily prayer.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Establishment Clause
Decision: School prayer led by government is unconstitutional.
Why it matters:

  • Government cannot promote religion

  • Separation of church and state


Wisconsin v. Yoder

Facts: Amish parents refused to send kids to school past 8th grade.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Free Exercise Clause
Decision: Amish could stop school for religious reasons.
Why it matters:

  • Protects religious freedom

  • Free exercise > state law in this case


Gideon v. Wainwright

Facts: Gideon could not afford a lawyer and was denied one.
Amendment: 6th Amendment (via 14th Amendment incorporation)
Decision: States must provide lawyers to poor defendants.
Why it matters:

  • Right to counsel required in state courts

  • Example of selective incorporation


McDonald v. Chicago

Facts: Chicago banned handguns.
Amendment: 2nd Amendment + 14th Amendment
Decision: 2nd Amendment applies to states.
Why it matters:

  • Incorporated right to bear arms

  • Limited state gun bans


Citizens United v. FEC

Facts: Law limited how much corporations could spend on elections.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Speech
Decision: Political spending = protected speech.
Why it matters:

  • Money = speech

  • Allowed Super PACs

  • Increased role of interest groups in elections


Gonzales v. Raich

Facts: California allowed medical marijuana, but federal law banned it
Amendment: Commerce Clause
Decision: Federal government can ban marijuana even in states where it’s legal
Why it matters:

  • Federal law overrides state drug laws

  • Expanded federal commerce power


United States v. Nixon

Facts: Nixon refused to release Watergate tapes
Amendment: Separation of Powers (Article II vs Judiciary)
Decision: President is not above the law; must release evidence
Why it matters:

  • Limited executive privilege

  • Strengthened judicial power over president


Bush v. Gore

Facts: Disputed 2000 presidential election recount in Florida
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Florida recount stopped; Bush becomes president
Why it matters:

  • Decided presidential election

  • Limited inconsistent ballot recount standards


Korematsu v. United States (already listed in your set? if not, keep it)

(keeping here only in case your teacher expects it in Unit 2/5)

Facts: Japanese internment during WWII
Amendment: 5th Amendment
Decision: Internment upheld (later widely condemned)
Why it matters:

  • Shows wartime limits on civil liberties

  • Later effectively discredited


Texas v. Johnson

Facts: Flag burning protest
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Free Speech
Decision: Flag burning is protected speech
Why it matters:

  • Symbolic speech is protected

  • Government cannot ban offensive expression


District of Columbia v. Heller

Facts: DC handgun ban
Amendment: 2nd Amendment
Decision: Individuals have right to own firearms unrelated to militia
Why it matters:

  • Strengthened individual gun rights

  • Set up McDonald incorporation later


Shapiro v. Thompson

Facts: States required residency before welfare benefits
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection
Decision: Residency requirements unconstitutional
Why it matters:

  • Protected right to travel between states

  • Limited state control over welfare access


Furman v. Georgia

Facts: Death penalty applied inconsistently
Amendment: 8th Amendment — Cruel and unusual punishment
Decision: Current death penalty laws unconstitutional (at the time)
Why it matters:

  • Temporarily halted death penalty

  • Forced states to rewrite laws


Gregg v. Georgia

Facts: Revised death penalty laws after Furman
Amendment: 8th Amendment
Decision: Death penalty is constitutional if applied fairly
Why it matters:

  • Reinstated death penalty

  • Created modern capital punishment system


Clinton v. City of New York

Facts: Line-item veto used by president
Amendment: Separation of Powers
Decision: Line-item veto is unconstitutional
Why it matters:

  • Limited presidential legislative power


INS v. Chadha

Facts: Congress tried to overturn deportation decision with one-house veto
Amendment: Separation of Powers
Decision: Legislative veto unconstitutional
Why it matters:

  • Strengthened checks and balances

  • Congress must pass laws properly

Marbury v. Madison

Facts: Marbury sued Madison for not delivering his judicial appointment.
Amendment: Article III (Judicial Review implied)
Decision: Established judicial review (courts can strike down unconstitutional laws).
Why it matters:

  • Courts gained power to review laws

  • Made judiciary equal to other branches

  • Foundation of constitutional law


McCulloch v. Maryland

Facts: Maryland taxed the national bank.
Amendment: Necessary and Proper Clause + Supremacy Clause
Decision: States cannot tax federal institutions; federal laws override state laws.
Why it matters:

  • Strengthened federal power over states

  • Established implied powers

  • Expanded national government authority


Gibbons v. Ogden

Facts: New York granted a steamboat monopoly on interstate waters.
Amendment: Commerce Clause
Decision: Only Congress can regulate interstate commerce.
Why it matters:

  • Expanded federal control over trade

  • Limited state economic power

  • Defined interstate commerce authority


Plessy v. Ferguson

Facts: Black and white passengers were required to use separate train cars.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Segregation is constitutional if facilities are “separate but equal.”
Why it matters:

  • Legalized segregation for decades

  • Later overturned by Brown v. Board

  • Justified Jim Crow laws


Mapp v. Ohio

Facts: Police illegally searched Mapp’s home without a warrant.
Amendment: 4th Amendment (search and seizure)
Decision: Illegally obtained evidence cannot be used in court (exclusionary rule applies to states).
Why it matters:

  • Strengthened Fourth Amendment protections

  • Limited police power

  • Applied exclusionary rule to states


Miranda v. Arizona

Facts: Suspect confessed without being informed of rights.
Amendment: 5th Amendment — Self-incrimination
Decision: Police must inform suspects of rights before questioning.
Why it matters:

  • Created “Miranda rights”

  • Protects accused during interrogation

  • Ensures fair legal process


New York Times v. United States

Facts: Government tried to stop publication of Pentagon Papers.
Amendment: 1st Amendment — Freedom of Press
Decision: Government cannot prevent publication unless direct national security threat is proven.
Why it matters:

  • Strengthened press freedom

  • Limited government censorship

  • Protected investigative journalism


Baker v. Carr

Facts: Tennessee had unequal legislative districts and refused to redraw them.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Redistricting issues are constitutional and can be decided by courts.
Why it matters:

  • “One person, one vote” principle begins

  • Courts can handle redistricting cases

  • Increased voting equality


Reynolds v. Sims

Facts: State legislative districts had unequal populations.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: State legislative districts must have roughly equal populations.
Why it matters:

  • Strengthened “one person, one vote”

  • Equalized representation in states

  • Reduced rural overrepresentation


NFIB v. Sebelius

Facts: Affordable Care Act required individuals to buy health insurance.
Amendment: Commerce Clause / Taxing Power
Decision: Individual mandate upheld as a tax, not under commerce power.
Why it matters:

  • Limited Commerce Clause expansion

  • Upheld Obamacare

  • Strengthened federal taxing authority


United States v. Lopez

Facts: Student brought gun to school under federal Gun-Free School Zones Act.
Amendment: Commerce Clause
Decision: Congress exceeded its commerce power.
Why it matters:

  • First major limit on federal power in decades

  • Defined limits of Commerce Clause

  • Strengthened states’ rights


Obergefell v. Hodges

Facts: Same-sex couples were denied marriage licenses in some states.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection & Due Process
Decision: Same-sex marriage is a constitutional right.
Why it matters:

  • Legalized same-sex marriage nationwide

  • Expanded civil rights

  • Strengthened equal protection doctrine


Shaw v. Reno

Facts: North Carolina created oddly shaped districts based on race.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Racial gerrymandering can violate the Constitution.
Why it matters:

  • Limited race-based redistricting

  • Protected voting fairness

  • Set standards for district drawing


Regents of the University of California v. Bakke

Facts: Medical school used racial quotas in admissions.
Amendment: 14th Amendment — Equal Protection Clause
Decision: Quotas are unconstitutional, but race can be considered in admissions.
Why it matters:

  • Allowed limited affirmative action

  • Banned strict racial quotas

  • Shaped college admissions policy