Gentrification - Lecture 7
2/11/2026
Ruth Glass - Urban Sociologist (1964)
Coined the term gentrification: ‘‘One by one, many of the working-class quarters of London have been invaded by the middle classes - upper and lower. Shabbu, modest mews and cottages… have been taken over, when their leases expired, and have become elegant, expensive residences’.
The Social status and value of dwellings are inflated despite their size and previous values in the neighbourhood.
Once ‘gentrification’ starts, it goes on until all or most of the original occupiers are displaced and the whole social character of the district is changed.
‘This is an inevitable development, in view of the demographic, economic and political pressures to which London… has been subjected’ (1964:7).
Neil Smith (1979)
Rent Gap = Disparity between current rental income and potential rental income attracts investors/speculators.
Previous deprived areas in the city centee become prime real estate = increase in land/property values = increase in rents = increase in ‘development’ (demolitions and new buildings/infillings) = increase in displacement of existing community (squeezed out or evicted).
Plays down cultural/social explanations in favour of economic model of gentrification = ‘A back to city movement by capital, not people’ (p85).
Economic or cultural?
Slow Gentrification = gradual emergence of cool or ‘trendy’ consumer spaces (e.g. organic cafes, microbrewies, coffee shops) which transform inner-city districts into hipster havens.
‘Displacement is not just about direct replacement of poorer by wealthy groups; it also involves forms of social, economic and cultural transition which alienate established popuations. This can ential forms of solw violence, which render particular neighbourhoods less hospitable and accommodating to establoshed residents, as well as direct and forceful acts of expropriation which the vulnerable and precarious seem least able to cope with’. (Elliot-Cooper, Hubbard & Lee 2019:504).
Impact of gentrification
‘Altogether there has been a great deal of displacement… All those who cannot hold their own - the small enterpirises, the lower ranks of people, the odd men out - are being pushed away’ (Glass, 1964).
Suburbanisation of poverty = low-income residents moving out from central cities that are no longer affordable to them.
Elite never use term ‘gentrification’ (negative connotations) = urban regeneration, renaissance, renewal, or re-development.
Gentrification can also involve more subtle processes of cultural appropriation, processes of displacement are not always as obvious as these mass evictions imply.
Gentrification as economic - Gentrification as cultural.
Displacement
Marcus (1986) = Housing’s relationship to oppression and liberation.
Existing residents might not feel at home anymore in a changing neighbourhood because of the general decline of working-class culture and identity.
‘When a family sees the neighbourhood around it changing dramatically, when their friends are leaving the neighbourhood, when the stores they patronise are liquidating and new stores for other clientele, in trasportation patterms, and in support services all clarly are making the area less and less liveable, then the pressure of displacement is severe.’ (Marcuse, 1986:207).
A loss of a feeling of belonging in the areas - Last resident.
Signs of gentrification
‘Higher end’ high street stores (Almost always coffee shops first, then other food & drink establishments).
Newly establishment independently owneed businesses.
Increases in Housing/rental prices - Changes class demographic of the area.
The demolition of older buildings. Building of new build homes and apartments.
Opening of arts/cultural spaces.
Increased security measures (gated areas-residental specifically, and more parking restrictions).
It often starts when people start to ‘fall in love with the area’ - people are attracted to the attractiveness of the place.
Post-industrial urban Economies
Shift towards Information/knowledge-based economy, where creativity is now the major source of competitive advantage (neo-lib).
Growth of a creative class, includes knowledge and symbolic workers, professional and technical occupations.
One theory that has captured the interest of local policy markers is Richard Florida’s account of the rise of a creative economy.
New imperative: ‘Be creative - or die’. ‘Technology, Talent, Tolerance’.
Rise of the Creative Class (Florida, 2002)
‘Creative class’ = ‘People who are paid principally to do creative work for a living… the scientists, engineers, artists, musicians, designers and knowledge-based professionals’.
‘From Singapore to London, Dublin to Auckland, Memphis to Amsterdam; indeed all the way to Providence, RI and Green Bay, WI, cities have paid handsomely to hear about the new credo of creativity, to learn how to attract and nurture creative workers, and to evaluate the latest ‘hipsterisation strategies’ of the established creative capitals (Peck 2005: 740).
Post-industrial Birmingham
‘At the centre of the Fordist hearland of the West Midlands, deindustrialisation deal the city and region some devastating blow from the 1970s onwards’. (Henry, McEwan & Pollard 2001:117).
More than two-rhirds of manufacturing jobs were lost between 1978 and 2002. High levels of unemployment and social and urban deprivation resulted.
‘The city’s reponse has been massive investment in service industries. One of the first UK cities ‘to swallow the entrepreneurial pill’ (2001:117).
Creativity and ‘Equality’
Florida argues that creative jobs are fundamentally about equality = The idea is that these jobs reward meirt, hiring the best people for the job, regardless of race, gender, or sexual preference (Florida 2002:78).
Cities now focus on ‘quality of place’ = vibrant music scene, art galleries, authentic neighbourhoods (?), outdoor spaces, historic architecture, cafes… tolerance.
‘Indicators of tolerance’ = Sizeable LGBTQ community, Foreign-born population
‘Those who choose to leave their countries are prediposed to risk and can be thought of as ‘innovative outsiders’.
This generates economic growth since a diverse mix of cultures furnishes a variety.
Class in the creative city: A critical engagement
Florida assumes that the market is class/race/gender blind = Neutral arbiter of social relations that allocated resources fairly according to merit.
Privileges elite creative class above all others. Message boils doen to the argument that cities/regions should subsidise their elites.
False neo-liberal promise of trickle-down social justice.
Creative class cities tend to have greater socio-economic polarisation. Growth of creative class goes hand in hand with growth of ‘army of service workers’ = presence of creative class fuels the growth of low paid of precarious jobs (cleaning, childcare, food/drink service).
Tend to emphasise bohemian neighborhoods and art districts. Cultural quarters typically associated with gentrification, rising real estate prices, displacement.
Urban Regeneration: The sibling of gentrification
The idea is to establish the ‘world class’ nature of a city’s cultural attractions, to put a city on the map of possible destinations for ‘desirable citizens’.
Starchitecture (flagship buildings)
Trendy cultural quarters in post-industrial landscape.
Bike lanes.
‘Ethnic’ festivals.
‘Cities should be liberal, ‘cosmopolitan’, ‘bohemian’ and ‘multicultural’ (poorly defined). They should contain ‘cool’ communities. Atmosphere and an acceptance of difference. Significant concentrations of immigrant, artisticm and gay and lesbian populations’ (Boren & Young 2013: 1800).
Summary
First coined in 1964 by Ruth Glass, the causes, definition, and impact of gentrification has been hotly debated, both within academic and policy circles.
Birmingha, is a classic example of an industrial city moving towards a post-industrial ‘creative economy’ model. But we need to ask whethr it has been successful and for who?
Florida’s creative cities plan has been very popular but heavily criticised, particularly about the new hierarchies and exclusion it creates, which are heavily oriented about class and race