Professional Liability in Real Estate

DISCLAIMER

This publication is intended for educational purposes only.
Information may change without notice; accuracy, completeness, and usefulness are not guaranteed by the UBC Group.
UBC Group includes UBC, affiliates, authors, editors, and staff.
Liability for losses or damages from reliance on this information is denied by UBC Group.
This document does not provide legal, accounting, or professional advice; consult professionals for specific circumstances.
© Copyright: 2023 by the UBC Real Estate Division, printed in Canada. All rights reserved.

PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY CHAPTER 4

Learning Objectives

After studying this chapter, a student should be able to:

Understand and apply the provisions of the Competition Act to registrants’ advertising and business practices.
Understand the significance of the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act (PCMLTFA) concerning registrants' obligations.
Understand the application of the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) to registrants.
Apply the 10 Fair Information Principles to the protection of personal information.
Identify the three elements of negligence with examples relevant to real estate registrants.
Discuss vicarious liability and its significance for real estate registrants.
List the elements of negligent misrepresentation and deceit and provide examples from real estate practice.

4.1 INTRODUCTION

Previous chapter covered The Real Estate Act, The Real Estate Regulations, and the Saskatchewan Real Estate Commission Bylaws.
This chapter discusses federal legislation:
  - Competition Act
  - Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA)
  - Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act (PCMLTFA)
Discusses the legal framework for negligence liability against real estate registrants.

THE ROLE OF THE COMPETITION ACT

Overview

Competition Act: Governs competition law in Canada; comprises criminal and civil sections, applicable to most business activities, including real estate services.
Aims to hold businesses accountable for misleading or anti-competitive practices and to maintain competition in Canadian markets.
Enforced by the Competition Bureau, led by the Commissioner of Competition.
Relevant sections for real estate registrants primarily include:
  - Criminal Offences:
    - Section 45: Agreements in restraint of trade.
    - Section 52: Misleading advertising.
  - Civil Offences:
    - Section 90.1: Similar to Section 45 but assessed on a balance of probabilities.
    - Section 74.01: Misleading representations similar to Section 52.
Price maintenance provisions in Section 76.
Ignorance of law is not a defense against breaches.

Enforcement

The Commissioner of Competition investigates complaints, can initiate investigations, and has powers to obtain search warrants and conduct interviews.
Private parties may sue for damages from violations.

Criminal Provisions: Agreements in Restraint of Trade

Section 45 defines conspiracy offences for agreements among competitors.
Indictable offence; penalties include imprisonment up to 14 years or fines of up to $25 million.
No need for the Crown to prove that competition was adversely affected.
Agreements inferred from circumstantial evidence (e.g., discussions leading to price stabilization).

Internet and Social Media Marketing

Misleading advertising provisions apply across all media, including digital marketing.
The Competition Bureau monitors online advertising compliance.

Specific Violations in Real Estate

Breaches may include agreements to:
  - Fix commission rates.
  - Allocate territories or customers.
  - Restrict service offerings.
  - Control service supply.

Misleading Advertising/Deceptive Practices

Section 52(1) prohibits false or misleading representations related to products or services.
Courts apply a two-step test to determine if representations are misleading in a material respect.
Example: Accurate but misleading advertising through visuals (e.g., showing a more expensive property).

Penalties

Indictable offence penalties: fines at the court’s discretion, up to 14 years imprisonment.
Summary offence maximum penalty: $200,000 fine or 1 year imprisonment.

PHASE 1: REAL ESTATE AS A PROFESSIONAL CAREER

Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act (PCMLTFA)

Overview

PCMLTFA targets sectors at risk of being exploited for money laundering or terrorist financing.
Key objectives:
  - Detect and deter money laundering.
  - Support law enforcement in prosecution.
  - Fulfill international commitments against crime.
  - Protect financial systems.

Money Laundering Defined

Defined as acts to disguise sources of money from illegal activities.
Stages of Money Laundering:
  1. Placement: Introducing illegal money into the financial system.
  2. Layering: Concealing the origins of funds through complex transactions.
  3. Integration: Reintroducing laundered money into the economy.

Methods Used in Real Estate

Money laundering can occur through:
  - Use of unregulated lenders.
  - Cash transactions in rentals or sales.
  - Overpricing properties.
  - Inducing payments for cleaning or renovation.

Compliance Obligations

Registrants must identify clients under specific methods:
  1. Government-issued Photo Identification
  2. Credit File Method
  3. Dual-Process Method
Must keep records of all client identification for at least five years.

Reporting Obligations

Required to report suspicious transactions and large cash transactions ($10,000+).
Importance of training staff to recognize red flags associated with potential money laundering activities.

PERSONAL INFORMATION PROTECTION AND ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS ACT (PIPEDA)

Overview

PIPEDA governs the collection, use, and disclosure of personal information in commercial activities.
Applies across Canada, with exceptions in provinces with similar legislation (e.g., Quebec, BC, Alberta).

Fair Information Principles

Accountability: Organizations must designate individuals responsible for compliance.
Identifying Purposes: Organizations must define why they collect personal data.
Consent: Knowledge and consent required for data collection.
Limiting Collection: Collect only necessary personal information.
Limiting Use, Disclosure, and Retention: Use for original purposes only and retain only as long as necessary.
Accuracy: Maintain accuracy of information.
Safeguards: Implement appropriate security measures.
Openness: Share information on privacy practices with the public.
Individual Access: Individuals can access their personal information.
Challenging Compliance: Procedures for addressing compliance challenges must be easily accessible.

Registration and Compliance

Brokerages must create and maintain policies regarding PIPEDA.
Registrants must be trained regarding privacy obligations.

LIABILITY FOR NEGLIGENCE

Overview

Real estate registrants have a duty of care to their clients.
Standard of care expected is that of an experienced industry professional.
Elements of negligence include:
  1. Duty of care owed.
  2. Breach of standard of care.
  3. Causation of damages.

Examples of Negligence in Real Estate

Common negligence cases include:
  - Failing to provide competent property valuation advice.
  - Not recommending protective clauses in contracts.
  - Failing to disclose properties’ material facts.

Vicarious Liability

Brokerages are liable for negligent acts of registrants during employment.

Conclusion

High standards of professionalism are required in the real estate industry.
Registrants must keep informed of legislative changes and industry standards to mitigate liability risks.
Regular training and compliance reviews are necessary to ensure adherence to laws, including the Competition Act, PCMLTFA, and PIPEDA, to prevent liability issues.