Inventing aliens

Introduction

  • The paper discusses rising popular racism in Japan against ethnic minorities, particularly Koreans.

  • Critiques the framing of this issue as ‘xenophobia’ instead of racism.

  • Emphasizes the importance of acknowledging Japan's colonial history and immigration control system that marginalizes ethnic minorities.

Background on Racism in Japan

  • Since 2009, ultra-right groups, such as Zaitokukai, have propagated racism online and through public demonstrations.

  • In 2013, the Zaitokukai began large-scale protests in major Japanese cities.

  • Activists and politicians are pushing for legislation against hate speech, but governmental responses underestimate the severity and historical roots of racism.

  • The usage of 'xenophobia' diminishes the complexity of racism that affects long-standing minorities like the Zainichi (Koreans living in Japan).

The Current Landscape of Hate Speech

  • A significant incident in July 2015 involved the Immigration Control Bureau facing backlash from false reports regarding the deportation of Koreans.

  • Reports by the UN Committee highlighted the inadequacy of Japan's legal measures against hate speech and the prevalence of racist discourse targeting Koreans and Chinese.

  • Concerns included harassment of ethnic minorities and notices excluding non-Japanese from businesses.

The Role of Extremist Groups

  • Zaitokukai, formed in 2007, claims to act against the privileges of Koreans in Japan.

  • Their methods involve online activism and public rallies, often using derogatory language against Koreans.

  • Notable protests included harassment of Korean schools and derogatory rallies against alleged illegal immigrants.

Mislabeling of Racism as Xenophobia

  • The categorization of Koreans as ‘foreigners’ in Japan's context perpetuates misunderstanding and racism.

  • Social scientists often frame racial discourse and hate crimes as xenophobia, ignoring deeper racist structures.

  • The focus on ‘foreigners’ excludes long-term residents who are considered ethnic minorities despite their Japanese nationality.

Historical Context of Racism in Japan

  • The emergence of Koreans in Japan can be tied to Japan’s colonial expansion and policies after major wars.

  • Korean migration increased significantly post-1910 with formal annexation of Korea, linking their presence to Japan's imperial past.

  • The historical movement of Koreans during labor shortages endorsed by the Japanese state during wartime affects present-day perceptions and treatments.

  • The contemporary immigration control policy traces its roots to how Koreans were treated during and after the occupation, establishing a pattern of systemic discrimination.

Institutionalizing Racism through Legal Frameworks

  • Japan's immigration control regime, initiated post WWII, was designed to exclude and categorize individuals based on ethnicity.

  • The Imperial Ordinance of Alien Registration of 1947 classified Koreans as aliens, despite their historical status as subjects of the empire.

  • This legal framework allowed the state to implement strict immigration measures and deny residential rights to Koreans, marking a deep-rooted connection between policy and racism.

Ongoing Struggles and Activism Against Racism

  • The Zaitokukai’s influence is supported by various political entities, signaling an institutional endorsement of racism.

  • Counteractions have emerged from both Japanese and non-Japanese activists who protest against Zaitokukai's actions.

  • Social movements and legal initiatives have been established to challenge the status quo, seeking to change perceptions and treatment of ethnic minorities in Japan.

Conclusion

  • Understanding the racism embedded within Japan's immigration controls is vital in addressing current issues of discrimination.

  • Mislabeling this issue as ‘xenophobia’ fails to address the historical and systemic roots of racism affecting long-term ethnic minorities.

  • Recognition and critical assessment of Japan's colonial legacy and its ongoing impact on immigration policies are crucial for fostering a more inclusive society.