High-Leverage Practices and Evidence-Based Practices: A Promising Pair


Introduction

  • Authors: Erica D. McCray, Margaret Kamman, Mary T. Brownell (University of Florida); Suzanne Robinson (University of Kansas)

  • The brief discusses the combination of High-Leverage Practices (HLPs) and Evidence-Based Practices (EBPs), which can effectively improve student outcomes, particularly for students with disabilities or those who struggle.

  • It aims to illustrate how these practices contribute to the advancement of educator preparation and instructional strategies within Multi-Tiered Systems of Support (MTSS).

High-Leverage Practices (HLPs)

Definition and Importance
  • Educator preparation programs face criticism for not demonstrating the impact of their graduates on student achievements.

  • Teachers and educational leaders are crucial in enhancing learning outcomes for students with disabilities.

  • Preparation experiences: Must include well-supervised opportunities for candidates to practice what they learn in coursework, with feedback to solidify learning.

  • Field placements: Should reinforce theoretical knowledge with practical applications.

  • Scholars advocate for identifying critical practices essential for improving student learning and behavior. Research suggests HLPs must:

    • Be demonstrably impactful on student achievement.

    • Be applicable across various content areas and grade levels.

  • HLPs should facilitate a “common core of professional knowledge and skill” to be taught across all teacher training programs.

  • Establishes a foundational infrastructure supporting effective teaching and consistent student learning.

Specialized Practices for Special Education

Development of HLPs in Special Education
  • Organizations including the CEEDAR Center and CEC have developed specialized HLPs for K-12 special education teachers.

  • These practices were developed across four domains:

    1. Collaboration:

    • Collaborate with professionals to enhance student success.

    • Organize and facilitate effective meetings with professionals and families.

    • Collaborate with families to bolster student learning and access necessary services.

    1. Assessment:

    • Utilize multiple sources to comprehend a student's strengths and needs.

    • Interpret and share assessment data with stakeholders.

    • Analyze instructional practices based on assessment data to improve student outcomes.

    1. Social/Emotional and Behavioral Support:

    • Create a consistent, organized, and respectful learning environment.

    • Deliver positive and constructive feedback to guide student behavior and learning.

    • Teach social behaviors directly.

    • Conduct functional behavioral assessments to formulate individual behavior support plans.

    1. Instruction:

    • Define and prioritize learning goals (both short- and long-term).

    • Design instruction systematically towards specified learning goals.

    • Adapt materials and tasks for identified learning goals.

    • Teach cognitive and metacognitive strategies to promote independence.

    • Employ scaffolded supports during instruction.

Evidence-Based Practices (EBPs)

Definition and Importance
  • EBPs in special education represent instructional strategies grounded in research and professional understanding that enhance the learning and behavior of students with disabilities (as noted by Cook, Tankersley, & Harjusola-Webb, 2008).

  • Focused on content and applicable for various developmental levels.

  • Example: Teaching summarization strategies is effective only for students in third grade and higher.

  • Collectively catalogued at the CEEDAR Center, these EBPs are delineated in Innovation Configurations (ICs) available on their website, which assess whether teacher preparation programs include opportunities for candidates to learn and practice vital EBPs, some of which integrate HLPs.

The Complementary Nature of HLPs and EBPs

Implementation in Multi-Tiered Systems of Support (MTSS)
  • Many educational districts and states adopt MTSS frameworks to enhance the success for all students.

  • MTSS Definition: A preventative and intervention-focused instructional framework that ensures all students receive evidence-based instruction.

    • Tier 1 (Universal): Core curriculum accessible to all students.

    • Tier 2 (Targeted): Supplemental instruction for students identified as at-risk based on screening.

    • Tier 3 (Intensive): Individualized, intensive interventions for students not thriving in previous tiers.

  • HLPs and EBPs are integral to the successful implementation of the MTSS framework, particularly in core and targeted instruction settings.

Case Example: Grand Valley State University (GVSU) Implementation

GVSU Initiative
  • GVSU aims to embed HLPs in their educator preparation programs across general and special education.

  • The faculty asserts that all new teachers should be capable of teaching all students from day one.

  • The initiative addresses educational equity, asserting that all children deserve a skilled educator.

  • A professional learning community (PLC) was established for faculty and field coordinators, focusing on:

    • Analyzing and unpacking HLPs for both general and special education.

    • Developing a pedagogical approach to teaching HLPs to teacher candidates and new educators.

    • Building a common understanding and vocabulary regarding HLPs.

    • Streamlining educator roles across pre-service and in-service levels.

Practical Application: Integrating HLPs and EBPs in Instruction

Example of Reading Instruction Using HLPs and EBPs

Tier 1: Universal Instruction

  • Teacher: Ms. Lexicon

  • Lesson includes explicit instruction with Text Talk to teach about vivid verbs during a read-aloud session where students identify and infer meanings of the words. Focus on connecting new vocabulary to familiar terms.

Tier 2: Supplementary Instruction

  • Identified students receive flexible group instruction focused on vocabulary exploration, with active student engagement and guidance provided through positive feedback.

Tier 3: Intensive Instruction

  • Ms. Lexicon provides one-on-one support for a student needing additional practice, segmenting reading material and engaging in guided discussions, summarizations, and vocabulary usage to prepare for written assignments.

Conclusion

  • The integration of HLPs with EBPs provides a robust framework for implementing effective instruction, particularly for students facing challenges. The collaborative design fosters an educational environment conducive to comprehensive learning and student success. Training and preparation for educators is paramount to effectively cater to diverse learner needs.