06 Representation and elections

1. Popular Sovereignty and Democracy

  • Concept of Popular Sovereignty

    • The idea that power originates from the will of the people.

    • It forms the basis of democracy which can be exercised directly or indirectly.

  • Types of Democracy

    • Direct Democracy: Citizens vote directly on laws and policies. Examples include:

      • Popular Assembly (Ecclesia) in Athens.

      • Landsgemeinde in Swiss cantons.

      • New England town meetings.

      • Referendums, plebiscites, and recalls.

      • Participatory budgeting and e-democracy.

    • Indirect (Representative) Democracy:

      • Citizens elect representatives to make decisions on their behalf.

      • Importance of maintaining a reliable link between the government and the electorate.

      • Concepts of electoral mandates and recall mechanisms.

2. Theories of Representation

  • Main Models of Representation:

    • Trusteeship Model: Representatives exercise independent judgment.

    • Delegate Model: Representatives act strictly as mouthpieces for constituents.

    • Mandate Model: Authority gained through winning elections and implementing campaign promises.

    • Resemblance Model: Representatives should reflect the diversity of society.

3. Functions and Principles of Democratic Elections

  • Functions of Elections:

    • Necessary for legitimizing authority and facilitating peaceful transfer of power.

    • Acts as an accountability tool for politicians.

    • Opportunity for educating voters and legitimizing political elites.

  • Principles of Democratic Elections:

    • Must ensure free and fair elections with political liberties.

    • Universal and equal suffrage.

    • Direct and secret ballot is essential.

    • Establish legal frameworks to contest results and prevent fraud.

4. Extension of Suffrage (1776-1919)

  • Timeline of Suffrage Expansion:

    • 1776: New Jersey saw universal male and female landowner suffrage until 1807.

    • 1869/90: Wyoming allowed universal suffrage for men and active for women.

    • 1918: Many countries, including Germany and the UK, extended suffrage to women.

    • Notable dates illustrating gradual enfranchisement up to 1919.

5. Extension of Suffrage (1919-2015)

  • Post-World War I Developments:

    • 1920: United States granted universal suffrage to men and women.

    • Continued expansions in various countries, reflecting major societal shifts.

    • Specific mention of changes in countries like France, Italy, and Turkey.

6. Variance in Electoral Systems

  • Definition: Electoral systems determine rules for conducting elections.

  • Factors Influencing Electoral Systems:

    • Variety in voting methods: single vs. plural ballots, candidates vs. party systems.

    • Types of Systems:

      • Majoritarian: e.g., First Past the Post (FPTP).

      • Proportional Representation (PR).

      • Mixed systems combining both.

  • Trade-offs: Representation vs. governability.

7. Majoritarian vs. Proportional Electoral Systems

  • Majoritarian Systems: Designed for stable governments, often leading to two-party systems.

  • Proportional Systems: Encourage multi-party representation but may lead to unstable coalitions.

  • Comparison Factors:

    • Voter-representative linkage.

    • Accountability and representation quality.

8. Hungarian Electoral System (1989-2011, 2012-)

  • Basic Features:

    • Two-vote mixed system introduced.

    • Compensation for lost votes, allowing multiple parties representation.

  • Current Regulations:

    • Continual adjustments to enhance representations and meet political needs.

9. Electoral Processes and Designs

  • Electoral Machines and Voting Design: Advances in technology for electoral efficiency.

  • Understanding Voting Behavior: Flow of information and voter responses in various election contexts.

10. Gerrymandering

  • Definition: Manipulation of electoral boundaries for political advantage.

  • Historical Context: Originates from Elbridge Gerry's practices in 1812.

  • Impacts: Distortion of true electoral representation.

11. Conclusion

  • Significance of Electoral Systems: The choice of electoral systems and the conduct of elections critically shape political representation and democratic outcomes.

  • Future Trends: Ongoing evolution and adaptation of electoral practices worldwide.