Existentialism, Repetition Compulsion, and the Web of Wyrd

Foucault, the Ship of Fools, and the Internalization of Madness

  • Societal Definition via Exclusion:

    • Societies historically construct and define their internal identity, sanity, and order by establishing what they are not on their geographic and conceptual peripheries.

    • The Ship of Fools (Stultifera Navis):

      • In medieval and early modern European history, individuals deemed "fools"—those incapable of labor or whose speech and behavior lacked societal coherence—were placed onto river barges along major waterways.

      • The vessel was navigated downriver to neighboring towns; each municipality assumed temporary custody until local patience or resources expired, after which the ship was unmoored and cast further downstream.

      • This served as a public, visceral ritual enabling mainstream society to reinforce its self-conception as benevolent, rational, moral, and industrious by directly contrasting itself with the excluded population.

  • Historical Evolution of Carceral and Psychiatric Control:

    • Over historical epochs, the mechanism of exclusion shifted from nautical exile to moral indictment and criminalization, culminating in the institutional confinement of the mentally ill in prisons.

    • The Contemporary American Carceral-Psychiatric Nexus:

      • The United States penal system functions as the largest and least effective mental health infrastructure in the world, incarcerating vast numbers of individuals suffering from severe psychological disorders.

      • Incarcerated individuals are routinely subjected to abrupt medication discontinuations for minimum periods of 2 weeks2\,\text{weeks} or longer upon intake, drastically destabilizing their clinical condition.

  • Foucault’s Anti-Psychiatry Critique in Madness and Civilization:

    • The structural critique begins with historical irony: contemporary society views past rituals (such as the Ship of Fools) as quaint and primitive, congratulating itself on enlightened progress while executing equally brutal institutional practices.

    • Foucault aligns with foundational anti-psychiatric thought, arguing that progressive over-medicalization fails to achieve its promised therapeutic liberation.

    • Psychotherapy as Internalized Moral Blame: Rather than abolishing culpability, modern psychotherapeutic frameworks merely internalize blame—targeting the individual's internal psychological apparatus rather than external moral frameworks or societal conditions.

  • Artistic Subversion and the Universality of Madness:

    • At the conclusion of Madness and Civilization, Foucault examines modern aesthetic movements—surrealism, Dada, absurdist theatre, sculpture, literature, and music.

    • Madness as Inherent to Human Nature: Foucault posits that madness is an intrinsic component of human subjectivity, creative capacity, and irrationality.

    • Projection and Disavowal: Societies pathologize, label, and isolate specific individuals to disavow their own fundamental madness, projecting internal irrationality outward onto designated scapegoats.

Thomas Ligotti, the New Weird, and the Web of Wyrd

  • Ligotti’s Dialogue with Foucault:

    • Author Thomas Ligotti extends Foucault’s thesis in fiction, exemplified by the narrative Dr. Locrian's Asylum.

    • The character Dr. Locrian directly acknowledges madness as an inherent human condition, choosing to actively unleash and explore it rather than suppress or cure it.

    • Cosmic Emptiness: Ligotti's descriptive prose reorients human vision away from the illuminated stars and directs it toward the black void and absolute nothingness existing between the stars, unlocking primary existential terror and madness.

  • Literary Genealogy of Weird Fiction:

    • Ligotti functions as a mid-to-late 20th20\text{th}-century bridge connecting the cosmic horror of H. P. Lovecraft to the contemporary "New Weird" genre.

    • The New Weird encompasses authors such as Jeff VanderMeer and China Miéville, though many contemporary practitioners have moved past or rejected the genre categorization.

  • Etymology and Philosophical Tenets of Weird (Wyrd):

    • The concept originates from the Nordic and Anglo-Saxon term Wyrd, intrinsically tied to destiny, fate, and the uncanny.

    • The Inscrutable Universe: Weird philosophy asserts that humans are fundamentally incapable of comprehending the underlying mechanisms of the cosmos or the self.

    • The Web of Wyrd: Represents the vast, complex nexus of cosmic and metaphysical forces governing existence beyond human perception; mortals catch only fragmented glimpses while remaining blind to the complete, incomprehensible architecture.

    • Subversion of Modern Rationalism: Weird fiction directly opposes modern institutional dogmas asserting that the world is rationally ordered, transparent, and navigable through informed, outcome-optimizing decisions.

Repetition Compulsion, Working Through, and Psychoanalytic Theory

  • Repetition Compulsion (Wiederholungszwang):

    • Sigmund Freud identified repetition compulsion as a clinical manifestation of psychological arrest and unresolved psychic conflict.

    • The ego erects defensive structures against instinctual drives; because drives are relentless throughout life, defensive failures manifest as repetitive, irrational behavioral patterns.

    • Everyday manifestations include persistent interpersonal dynamics (e.g., repeatedly selecting identical toxic partners), recurring broken promises, chronic behavioral addictions, and pica behaviors.

    • Distinction from Clinical OCD: While Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder can function as an example of repetition, repetition compulsion designates a far broader psychological drive to reenact unresolved trauma.

    • Critique of the Physiological vs. Psychological Addiction Dichotomy: Historical attempts to separate chemical dependency from "purely psychological addiction" (often applied to substances like cannabis) represent a false conceptual dichotomy that contemporary clinical literature has largely discarded.

    • The Idée Fixe: Underneath the compulsion frequently lies a fixed, unexamined idea or central obsession that endlessly reproduces itself in dreams, statements, relationships, and creative work.

  • Working Through (Durcharbeitung):

    • Freud established that repetition compulsion can simultaneously represent an unconscious effort to master and transform historical pain.

    • Patients unconsciously recreate distressing scenarios hoping that a different, reparative outcome will manifest (e.g., entering destructive situations with the expectation of finally gaining agency or respect).

    • Transference and Therapy: Clinically, the repetition compulsion must be drawn directly into the therapeutic encounter, allowing the patient's underlying relational desires (such as winning parental validation) to be recognized, metabolized, and re-negotiated within a safe social interaction.

  • Post-Freudian and Literary Extensions:

    • Object Relations and Self Psychology: Theorists following Freud, particularly Heinz Kohut, positioned working through as the core mechanism of therapeutic self-transformation.

    • Jungian Complexes: Carl Jung conceptualized complexes as autonomous constellations around archetypes that mimic the big picture while keeping the individual trapped in small, repetitive loops.

    • Gothic Literature and Repetition:

      • Gothic fiction relies systematically on generational cycles, ancestral repetition, and enclosed loops.

      • Gabriel García Márquez’s One Hundred Years of Solitude functions structurally as a Colombian Gothic narrative, featuring continuous generational recurrence of identical character names (e.g., Aureliano) and behavioral catastrophes.

      • Ahmed Saadawi’s novel Frankenstein in Baghdad (20052005 setting): The monster ("Whatsitsname"), stitched together from the fragmented corpses of bombing victims, compulsively returns to explosive blast sites to make sense of violence, embodying cyclical national trauma and political fragmentation.

The Myth of Novelty, Cultural Amnesia, and Nietzsche’s Eternal Return

  • Friedrich Nietzsche and the Eternal Return (Ewige Wiederkunft):

    • Nietzsche rejected the Enlightenment paradigm of history as a linear, forward-marching narrative of human progress, presenting it instead as an endless circular repetition of patterns.

    • The concept warns against civilizational nihilism and counters the illusion of moral evolution.

  • The Fallacy of the "Unprecedented" and Cultural Amnesia:

    • Modern sociopolitical discourse relies heavily on the term "unprecedented" to characterize current crises, executive overreach, or unilateral warfare.

    • Historical actions taken by Theodore Roosevelt, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Lyndon B. Johnson, and Richard Nixon demonstrate that contemporary political manipulations are repetitive iterations of established patterns.

    • Compressed news cycles foster cultural amnesia, stripping events from historical context and selling old systemic crises as shocking novelties.

    • Institutional DNA: Modern instances of police violence are not anomalies within an evolved system, but the historical recurrence of American policing roots embedded in slave patrols and early municipal gangs.

  • Technological Continuity vs. Radical Novelty:

    • Technological innovations represent scalar degrees of variation rather than qualitative breaks from past traditions.

    • Automated drone warfare was researched in Boston laboratories during the 1980s1980\text{s}; the internet existed across institutional networks throughout the 1980s1980\text{s}; mobile cellular phones originated in the 1970s1970\text{s}.

    • Contemporary media panics concerning automated systems or information floods echo historical outcries over yellow journalism 150 years150\,\text{years} ago.

    • Obsession with surface-level novelty (analogous to the satire of The Simpsons where "Malibu Stacy has a new hat") blinds populations to cyclical structural traps.

  • Theological and Metaphysical Parallelisms:

    • The eternal return conceptually mirrors the Karmic Wheel (Samsara) across Indian philosophical systems.

    • In Buddhist thought, liberation from the cyclical wheel of suffering is attained not through self-deceptive notions of personal novelty, but through the realization of the Dharma.

Memory Reconstruction, Nachträglichkeit, and Intergenerational Trauma

  • The Malleability of Memory:

    • Memory does not function as an immutable archival recording; every cognitive retrieval alters the file, encoding the present act of remembering into the reconstructed memory itself.

    • In legal and interrogative settings, the rhetorical framing of questions permanently shifts eyewitness recollections.

    • Identity exists in circular causality: current identity rewrites past memory, and the rewritten memory dictates current identity.

  • Nachträglichkeit and Après-coup:

    • German psychoanalytic term: Nachträglichkeit (translated into French as après-coup), denoting deferred action, retroaction, or retroactive meaningfulness.

    • Subsequent life events rewrite the psychological valence, meaning, and subjective reality of earlier experiences.

    • Cultural examples: The book and cinematic adaptation of All the President’s Men came to fully replace the historical reality of the Watergate break-in within the American cultural imagination.

  • Atavism and Transgenerational Trauma:

    • Atavism: The theoretical survival of ancestral, bodily, or physiological memory inherited across generations (historically linked to concepts of "blood memory" or archaic anthropology).

    • Intergenerational Trauma: Modern clinical formulations of atavism examine how unassimilated historical and collective trauma (e.g., ongoing war in Iraq) transmits psychically across family units, migrations, and successive generations without conscious awareness.

Heideggerian Existentialism: The Existential Givens, Angst, and Das Man

  • The Four Existential Givens:

    1. Death: The inescapable finitude of personal existence. Confronting mortality provides urgency, transformation, and aesthetic depth (contrasted with the stagnation of mythical immortality, as depicted in Anne Rice's Interview with the Vampire, where Louis wrestles with mortality while Lestat defaults to shallow narcissism).

    2. Being in Question: The fundamental condition that human nature lacks an innate blueprint or pre-determined essence; every individual is an open question demanding lived resolution.

    3. Existential Isolation: Absolute experiential aloneness. No other consciousness can fully occupy one's subjective experience; recognizing this isolation serves as the necessary precondition for genuine intimacy.

    4. Meaninglessness / Ambiguity: The cosmos possesses no built-in instruction manual. Dogmatic texts (whether from L. Ron Hubbard, Mary Baker Eddy, or traditional Judeo-Christian scriptures) represent fabricated structures overlaying radical ambiguity. All meaning is individually produced, requiring total personal responsibility.

  • Existentialism vs. Nihilism:

    • While nihilism concludes that the absence of cosmic meaning renders human actions void of significance, existentialism asserts that the existential givens establish the frontiers against which authentic personal meaning must be forged.

  • Das Man (The "They") and Inauthenticity:

    • To evade confrontation with the givens, individuals flee into Das Man (the collective, impersonal "They"), surrendering to conventional public everydayness.

    • Inauthentic living relies on prefabricated identities, social consensus ("everybody knows that"), and external blame (attributing life outcomes to parental failures or historical conditions).

  • The Function of Angst (Existential Anxiety):

    • Angst is not a clinical symptom or standard psychological stress; it is the fundamental ontological discomfort signaling that everyday existence is built on bad faith and denial of the givens.

    • Analogous to Neo's gnawing unease regarding "What is the matrix?" in the film The Matrix.

    • Fallenness (Verfallen): Responding authentically to Angst reveals the "call of conscience," which indicts the individual as "guilty" of abandoning personal subjectivity to Das Man.

Authenticity, Existential Psychotherapy, and Modern Escapism

  • The Dialectic of Authentic and Inauthentic States:

    • Authenticity is not an enduring state of enlightenment; human beings repeatedly slip back into inauthenticity (Das Man).

    • Certain functional tasks require inauthenticity (e.g., driving 80 mph80\,\text{mph} on a Boston highway requires mechanical compliance, not existential contemplation of mortality).

    • Disruptions—such as relational breakups, encounters with the uncanny, or the sudden blow of the Zen master's stick (keisaku)—fracture public complacency and restore raw presence.

  • The Commodification of Authenticity:

    • Capitalism packages synthetic authenticity (e.g., 1990s1990\text{s} Gen X grunge aesthetics, "Coca-Cola: The Real Thing") to monetize the public's underlying Angst.

    • Consuming commercialized authenticity functions like drinking salt water to quench thirst, leaving existential hunger unresolved.

  • Existential Clinical Practice:

    • Pioneered by figures such as Rollo May and psychiatrist Irvin Yalom as an alternative to deterministic psychoanalysis.

    • Yalom’s clinical work (documented in texts like Love’s Executioner) centers on sitting with end-of-life crises, confronting mortality, and embracing therapeutic uncertainty.

    • Hospice Care Dynamics: Hospice professionals navigate existential realms without aggressively forcing confrontation onto dying individuals, allowing patients to draw comforting solace from traditional faith frameworks when appropriate.

  • Cult Dynamics and Social Self-Deception:

    • Cults systematically deploy basic principles of social and cognitive psychology, leveraging systemic biases to relieve adherents of existential anxiety in exchange for total conformity.

    • Mainstream society mocks visible cults (such as apocalyptic groups wearing matching sneakers awaiting alien comets) to reassure itself that everyday institutional conformity is rational, despite mainstream society exhibiting identical patterns of brainwashing and uncritical consumption (e.g., uncritical adoption of GLP-1 weight-loss pharmaceuticals).

    • Ari Aster’s film Midsommar illustrates this psychological ambiguity, turning the critical gaze back onto the viewer rather than simply mocking the commune.

  • The Sociological Myth of the Midlife Crisis:

    • Carl Jung posited that true psychological maturation begins only after age 4040, prioritizing the challenges of the second half of life.

    • Empirically, midlife crisis models lack robust longitudinal statistical support, prompting the modern socio-economic invention of the "quarter-life crisis."

    • Historically nonexistent before 19001900, the midlife crisis emerged post-World War II due to the erosion of traditional cultural rites of passage following Nietzsche’s "death of God," leaving adults without symbolic frameworks to navigate middle-age existential reckonings.

Questions and Discussion

  • Assignment Mechanics and Genre Criteria:

    • Question: For Assignment 4, if a source analyzes three separate fantasy books, should the individual books and publication dates be identified, or can the student broadly state that the article analyzes fantasy works?

    • Response: It depends on the centrality of those specific literary objects to the theoretical argument. Identifying the literary texts requires citing their authors and publication dates, but when shifting back to the secondary scholarship, the student must cite the scholarly article's authors and publication year to prevent conflating analytical objects with critical sources.

    • Question: Is Assignment 4 simply another article summary identical to Assignment 3, or should it explicitly pivot toward Assignments 5 and 6?

    • Response: At minimum, it requires summarizing a new scholarly source. However, it should be utilized to build out the specific theoretical framework (e.g., Jung’s shadow and persona, existential inauthenticity, or meaning-making models) that will eventually be applied to the fictional case study (such as Shadow and Bone) in Assignments 5 and 6. A brief concluding tagline must indicate the student's prospective thematic direction.

    • Question: Must the genre selected for Assignments 5 and 6 match the genre chosen in Assignment 1?

    • Response: No. Students are free to choose an alternative genre from the approved syllabus list. Unconventional genre arguments (e.g., demonstrating that a seemingly non-horror text operates fundamentally as horror) are acceptable provided the textual justification is systematically made.

  • Psychological and Addictive Distinctions:

    • Question: Is the distinction between psychological addiction and physiological addiction valid in clinical theory, or was it an incorrect diagnostic framework?

    • Response: The distinction was historically deployed to argue that substances like cannabis were exclusively psychological and devoid of physiological dependency, a stance contradicted by modern physiological research. While psychology plays a decisive role in dependency, rigid boundaries between the two categories are clinically flawed.

  • Cyclical History, Reincarnation, and Human Novelty:

    • Question: Is the repetition of history an iron law across all historical habits, and did Nietzsche endorse literal reincarnation through the Eternal Return?

    • Response: Nietzsche was reading rudimentary, flawed translations of Eastern religious texts and romantic philosophies, leading him to explore cyclical existence metaphorically rather than dogmatically. The cyclical paradigm parallels Hindu concepts of Samsara, where the karmic wheel produces ceaseless repetition until broken by spiritual discipline.

    • Question: Have recent cultural and technological developments—such as proposals to rename geographic entities like the Gulf of Mexico, or the rise of autonomous AI drones—transcended history as truly unprecedented phenomena?

    • Response: Political renamings and imperial land reclassifications have been foundational to American statecraft since its origin. Similarly, autonomous drone prototypes and computational network theories were heavily developed in academic laboratories during the 1980s1980\text{s}. Novelty represents cosmetic shifts in scale or presentation, rather than structural anomalies.

    • Question: Does an adherence to the Eternal Return foster human carelessness by implying that civilization will always survive catastrophic collapses?

    • Response: Catastrophic events such as the Black Plague demonstrate that while the human species may persist, individual suffering and civilizational devastation remain severe. Assuming that society will effortlessly reset itself represents an inauthentic defense mechanism designed to numb present moral outrage.

  • Authenticity, Religious Belief, and Cultural Films:

    • Question: Does turning to religion represent an authentic act of personal meaning-making, or is it merely an inauthentic surrender to institutional dogma?

    • Response: From an existential phenomenological standpoint, the how of belief supersedes the what. An individual can embrace intricate philosophical doctrines in an inauthentic, emotionally defended posture, or hold simple religious convictions in an authentic, deeply lived manner that remains open to mortality and uncertainty.

    • Question: Can Ari Aster’s Midsommar be classified primarily as an existential film?

    • Response: Yes. The narrative arc is catalyzed by profound existential trauma, isolation, and unacknowledged grief, compelling the protagonist to confront the breakdown of conventional emotional stability and seek meaning within a radically challenging collective structure.