Direct Evidence and Body Paragraph Construction
Proficient Body Paragraph Components
- Clear Topic Sentence: A beautifully articulated statement defining the paragraph's focus.
- Direct Evidence: Word-for-word text utilized to support the argument development.
- Commentary: Explanation pairing the evidence with the topic sentence; evidence must not be "dropped in" without analysis.
- Organizational Structure: Transitions that lead the reader toward a specific conclusion.
Standards for Direct Evidence
- Visual Representation: Evidence must be set apart visually with quotation marks.
- AP Requirement: Aim for a minimum of pieces of evidence per body paragraph to prove remarks are not coincidental; more than makes the argument definitive.
- Integration Technique: Narrow evidence to short phrases or single high-impact words rather than whole sentences or paragraphs to prevent the reader from losing track.
- Writer Authority: Using the author's language as an extension of one's own increases the writer's perceived expertise.
- Direct vs. Paraphrase: Use direct quotes when the source material is available; utilize textual references or paraphrasing when it is not.
Foundation of Evidence and Argument
- Purpose: Evidence provides a foundation for clarity and helps "win" an argument by ensuring statements are not made without basis.
- Scientific Application: Topics like serendipity (discovery by chance) are supported by specific evidence, such as the invention of penicillin.
- Justification Example: A nine years old child named Andrew supports a request for video game money by providing evidence of a finished book and an owed bill.