St Anselm

Medieval Thought

  • Augustine

  • Anselm

Introduction

Fundamental question: Which is better/greatest?

  • Something that exists only in the mind

  • Something that exists both in the mind and in reality

Why

  • Existence in reality is greater than existence only in the mind:

    • Something that exists in reality can influence our lives.

    • The concept becomes fully 'realized' when it is outside the mind.

    • Something that exists only in the mind is limited by imagination, while something that exists in reality transcends those limitations.

Review – Augustine (1)

  • Augustine as a follower of Manichaeism (to explain the existence of evil).

    • Manichaeism: Religious philosophy that combines elements of Christianity, Zoroastrianism, and Buddhism, featuring a dualistic worldview that explains the existence of good and evil as opposing forces

  • About Knowledge: Divine Illumination aids in understanding God (The Form – The One).

  • Humans, as images of God, have the capacity to know Him.

  • Rationes seminales (seminal reasons): Creation has the potential to develop naturally.

  • Evil as a loss of existence (privatio), for example: blindness as the loss of sight (which is good).

St. Anselm

  • Fides Quaerens Intellectum (faith seeking understanding).

  • Emphasizes the importance of reason and intellectual exploration in relation to faith.

  • Faith is the starting point for acquiring knowledge and understanding of God.

Ontological Argument

  • Ontology: A branch of philosophy about existence and essence.

  • Ontological Argument: Based on the nature/essence of God.

  • Anselm's argument starts from logic, not observation or experience. (rationalist approach similar to Plato)

  • Logic: Starts from the definition of "God" and draws conclusions based on that definition.

Explanation of the Ontological Argument

  • Definition: "God" as the greatest being (Omnipotent, Omniscient, etc.).

  • Something can exist in:

    • The mind/idea

    • The mind and reality.

  • Example: The image of a painter (idea) vs. the painting that exists (reality).

  • Something that exists in reality is more perfect than something that exists only in the mind.

  • If God only exists in our minds, God cannot be considered perfect, because perfection means existing in reality.

  • Definition of God: "He is perfect/great."

  • Logically, God must also exist in reality.

Concept of the Greatest Possible Being

  • What is the greatest possible being?

  • Critique: "The Perfect Island"

    • Gaunilo's critique: Men's identical logic could apply to an island that no greater island could be conceived.

    • If it only exists in the mind, the island is not the greatest, because what exists in reality is better (it can be visited).

    • The critique shows that Anselm's logic could prove the existence of absurd things.

  • Critique: "The Perfect Pizza"

    • Parody argument about the perfect pizza based on the same logic.

    • If it only exists in the mind, that pizza is not the greatest, because the pizza that exists in reality is better (it can be eaten).

Response to the Critique

Anselm argues that the concept of God is fundamentally different, as God is defined as the greatest conceivable being whose existence in reality is necessary for perfection. Thus, Gaunilo's argument fails because it does not apply to the unique nature of God, whose essence includes existence.