Political Heritage: Influences on the American System of Government
Political Heritage: Influences on the American System of Government
The American Revolution
- Was the American Revolution justified?
- How can breaking away from a country be justified?
- The Founding Fathers were inspired by Enlightenment thinkers to protect established rights.
Main Ideas
- Rule of Law: No one is above the law.
- Inherent Rights: People have natural, inalienable, or human rights.
The Enlightenment
- A movement in Europe (especially Great Britain and France).
- Shift from attributing events to God to using logic and reason to solve societal problems.
- Isaac Newton: Believed in natural laws governing nature, politics, economics, justice, and religion.
State of Nature
- What happens without government or rules.
- Life is "nasty, brutish, and short" due to people taking advantage of each other.
- Government aims to provide safety and security by individuals giving up some rights.
Thomas Hobbes (1651)
- Wrote Leviathan, describing life without government as chaotic.
- People are inherently selfish and greedy, leading to a constant power struggle.
- Social Contract: People give up some power to an absolute monarch for an organized society.
John Locke (1690)
- Wrote Two Treatises of Government, expanding on Hobbes' ideas.
- People are shaped by their environment (tabula rasa or blank slate).
- Believed people generally do the right thing and have faith in humanity.
- Natural Rights:
- Governments exist to protect these rights.
- If a government fails to protect these rights, the people have the right to overthrow it.
- Justification for the Declaration of Independence.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau
- "Man is born free, but everywhere is in chains."
- Expanded on Hobbes and Locke in The Social Contract.
- The government is a mutual contract between the people and the ruler, existing to protect natural rights.
- Advocated for government intervention only when necessary.
- Believed in democracy, where the government is chosen by the people.
Baron de Montesquieu
- In The Spirit of the Laws, he reviewed historical governments.
- Identified the problem of absolute monarchs taking too much control, leading to corruption.
- Advocated for separation of powers and checks and balances to prevent corruption.
- Legislative, executive, and judicial functions should be separate, with each branch checking the others.
Summary of Philosophers
- Thomas Hobbes: Natural rights, the social contract.
- John Locke: Protecting life, liberty, and property.
- Rousseau: Direct democracy.
- Montesquieu: Separation of powers.
Key Documents Influencing the American System
Magna Carta (1215)
- Forced upon King John due to his abusive taxation.
- Recognizes ancient liberties for all free men (natural rights).
- Limits the king's ability to raise funds (taxes), as reflected in Article 1, Sections 7 and 9 of the Constitution.
- Protects due process of law and trial by jury (found in the American Bill of Rights, 5th-8th Amendments).
- Establishes early forms of a democratic republic with majority rule.
- Establishes rule of law: nobody is above the law.
- Basis for British law and justification for overthrowing the British government.
Mayflower Compact (1620
- Established a "civil body politic" among settlers arriving in the New World.
- Agreement to protect and respect each other, recognizing the distance from British governance.
- First social contract formed in America.
- Governing themselves.
English Petition of Rights (1628)
- Further limited the power of the monarch.
- Established a representative government with a Parliament selected by the people.
- Consent of the governed: people select who governs them.
- Protected free and fair elections without king's interference.
- Ordered government: different offices and positions.
- Protected rights, including parliamentary approval for taxes and protection against cruel and unusual punishment.
English Bill of Rights (1689)
- Forced the king to give up more power to Parliament.
- Protected due process, including trial by jury and no cruel/unusual punishment or excessive bail/fines.
- Guaranteed the right to bear arms and petition the government.
Virginia Declaration of Rights (1776)
- Written by George Mason; influenced the American Constitution and Bill of Rights.
- Outlined rights later protected in the U.S. Bill of Rights.
- Ideas for the Consitutional Convention came from already existing documents.
Comparison Chart
- Rights in Magna Carta, English Bill of Rights, Virginia Declaration of Rights, and American Bill of Rights (1791) show plagiarism and historical precedent.
Declaration of Independence
- Justifies forming a new government because the existing government failed to protect established rights.
Iroquois Confederation (1500s)
- Five Native American tribes united to create peace in the Northeast and Midwest.
- Demonstrated that democracy and self-governance could work in America.
- Inspired the Founding Fathers with the idea of unity and peace through self-governance.