Property Law: Week 10 Lecture Notes Covenants and Equitable Servitudes, Real Estate Contracts, Marketable Title, and Disclosures
I. Covenants and Equitable Servitudes: Evolution and Modern Approach
A. Traditional Distinctions vs. Modern Trends
Traditional Approach: The law historically drew a strict procedural and substantive line based on the requested remedy. If a plaintiff sought money damages for the breach of a written promise in a deed, it was classified as a "real covenant" and required strict horizontal privity, vertical privity, and the "touch and concern" requirement. If a plaintiff sought an injunction to prevent a violation, it was classified as an "equitable servitude," which did not require privity but hinged on whether the subsequent purchaser took the property with notice of the restriction (Tulk v. Moxhay).
Modern Restatement Approach: Modern jurisprudence and the Restatement seek to eliminate these redundant labels by dropping the artificial distinction between real covenants and equitable servitudes. Instead, courts refer to them uniformly as covenants running with the land, granting courts the equitable flexibility to award money damages, injunctive relief, or both, as appropriate to the circumstances. Furthermore, the modern trend minimizes or discards rigid privity and touch-and-concern hurdles, treating covenants contained in deeds as presumptively enforceable.
B. Requirements and Enforceability (Neponsit Property Owners' Association)
In Neponsit Property Owners' Association v. Emigrant Industrial Savings Bank, the court addressed whether an affirmative covenant requiring property owners to pay an annual four-dollar fee for maintaining common roads, parks, and amenities ran with the land and bound subsequent bank purchasers via foreclosure.
The court established that affirmative covenants to pay money for common-area maintenance touch and concern the property because they directly affect the legal relations, value, and enjoyment of the land. This precedent established the vital legal foundation for modern Homeowners Associations (HOAs) and condominium assessments.
C. Common Development Plans and Implied Negative Reciprocal Servitudes (Sanborn v. MacLean)
When a developer creates a common residential subdivision, individual deeds may lack an explicit restriction, yet courts will still enforce a negative reciprocal servitude if the owner had notice.
In Sanborn v. MacLean, the defendants attempted to build a gas station on a residential lot whose deed lacked a commercial restriction. The court held that because a substantial majority of the lots in the common plan originated from a common grantor and contained residential restrictions, a uniform scheme existed. The defendants had constructive notice because a reasonable inspection of the uniform neighborhood would reveal that all surrounding lots were strictly residential.
D. Termination of Covenants Covenants can be extinguished through several recognized mechanisms:
Expiration by Limitation: The covenant contains an explicit time limit or durational term.
Merger: The burdened and benefited parcels come under exact common ownership (an individual cannot hold a covenant against their own land).
Release: The beneficiaries of the covenant formally release the burdened parcel in writing.
Acquiescence and Abandonment: If the benefited parties chronically allow widespread, unpunished violations of the covenant across the subdivision, the covenant is deemed abandoned.
Estoppel: The burdened party detrimentally relies on the benefited party's representation that the covenant will not be enforced.
Operation of Law & Laches: Extinguished via unreasonable delay in enforcement (laches), statutory time caps (e.g., 30-year limits in Rhode Island and Massachusetts), or unconstitutionality (e.g., racially restrictive covenants).
Changed Circumstances: For a covenant to terminate due to changed circumstances, the transformation must occur within the protected subdivision itself, not merely along its external commercial borders (River Heights Associates L.P. v. Batten).
II. Common Interest Communities and Condominiums
A. Structure and Governance
Common interest communities include condominiums, planned unit developments, and cooperatives (where owners hold shares in a corporation that grants proprietary leases, common heavily in New York City).
In California, the Davis-Stirling Act governs extensive operational, electoral, financial reserve, and inspection requirements for common interest developments.
B. Enforceability of CC&Rs (Nahrstedt v. Lakeside Village Condominium Association)
Original covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) recorded in the master deed are presumptively valid and enforceable, even if they appear restrictive or unreasonable to an individual owner.
In Nahrstedt, the California Supreme Court upheld a complex-wide pet ban against a resident with indoor cats, reasoning that judicial deference to original CC&Rs ensures predictability, stability, and reliance for all purchasers in a shared community.
Note on Legislative Overrides: Subsequent legislative enactments (such as California Civil Code provisions) have since modified strict blanket pet bans, guaranteeing condo owners the right to maintain at least one pet, subject to reasonable association management rules.
C. Board Powers and the Fair Housing Act (Curto v. A Country Place Condominium Association)
HOA boards operate under corporate governance principles and the business judgment rule, meaning courts will not second-guess board management decisions absent a breach of care or loyalty.
However, board rules must comply with federal and state civil rights laws. In Curto v. A Country Place Condominium Association, an age-restricted senior condominium instituted sex-segregated pool hours to accommodate an Orthodox Jewish demographic. The court held that facial sex-based scheduling violates the Fair Housing Act (FHA), emphasizing that good intentions or mathematically "equal" split hours do not excuse unlawful discrimination based on protected classifications.
III. Real Estate Contracts, Brokers, and Marketable Title
A. Real Estate Brokers
Agency and Loyalty: Listing brokers and their agents traditionally represent the seller, owing their primary fiduciary duty and loyalty to maximize the seller's sales price, even when assisting a buyer.
Listing Agreements:
Open Listing: Multiple agents can market the property; only the procuring broker earns a commission.
Exclusive Agency: A single broker is granted exclusive marketing rights, but if the owner independently sells the property, no commission is owed.
Exclusive Right to Sell: The most protective agreement; the broker is entitled to a commission regardless of who procures the buyer—even if the owner finds the buyer independently.
Commission Earning & Industry Changes: Under the traditional majority rule, a broker earns their commission upon producing a buyer who is ready, willing, and able to purchase, regardless of whether the deal ultimately closes. Following landmark antitrust litigation and National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlements, compensation structures are rapidly shifting toward fixed fees and hourly buyer-broker rates.
B. Core Provisions of a Land-Sale Contract
Fixtures vs. Personal Property: Fixtures are items permanently attached to the real property (e.g., built-in cabinets, plumbing, chandeliers) and automatically transfer with the sale unless specifically excluded. Freestanding personal property requires explicit contractual negotiation. In commercial settings, tenants may remove trade fixtures if removal causes no structural damage.
Earnest Money: A good-faith deposit required from the buyer to ensure serious intent; subject to forfeiture rules if the buyer defaults.
Inspection & Contingencies: Provisions allowing professional evaluations of structural, plumbing, and electrical systems, alongside mortgage contingencies that permit buyers to cancel and recover their deposit if financing cannot be secured under specified loan amounts and interest caps.
Time of the Essence: A strict contractual clause making any delayed performance a material breach, carrying profound importance for closing dates.
C. The Statute of Frauds and Exceptions
Real estate purchase contracts must be in writing, signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought, and contain a property description and price.
Exception - Detrimental Reliance (Hickey v. Green): An oral agreement for land sale can be specifically enforced despite the Statute of Frauds if one party reasonably and justifiably changed their position to their detriment in reliance on the oral promise (e.g., selling one's own home to buy the promised lot).
Exception - Part Performance: Courts may enforce oral contracts if the buyer takes physical possession, makes substantial improvements, or renders full or partial payment, depending on jurisdictional standards.
D. Marketable Title
Every land-sale contract contains an implied condition that the seller will deliver marketable (merchantable) title at closing—meaning title free from reasonable doubt and unencumbered by undisclosed liens, mortgages, or easements.
Violations of Marketable Title (Lohmeyer v. Bower): A property's existing violations of private building covenants or municipal zoning/setback ordinances render title unmarketable because they expose the purchaser to immediate litigation hazards. Mere background zoning laws do not impair marketability unless the property is currently in active violation.
Adverse Possession: Title acquired via adverse possession is unmarketable until a formal judicial quiet title action confirms ownership.
E. The Doctrine of Equitable Conversion
Once a valid real estate contract is executed, the doctrine of equitable conversion treats the buyer as the equitable owner of the land and the seller as the owner of the personal property right to the purchase price.
In jurisdictions recognizing this doctrine, the risk of loss shifts to the buyer if the property is accidentally destroyed by fire or natural disaster between contract signing and closing.
IV. Seller's Duty to Disclose Defects
A. From Caveat Emptor to Modern Disclosure
Traditional View (Caveat Emptor): Under "let the buyer beware," sellers had no affirmative duty to disclose physical defects, remaining liable only for active fraud or intentional misrepresentations.
The "Haunted House" Exception (Stambovsky v. Ackley): The court carved out an equitable exception to caveat emptor where a condition (a reputedly haunted house actively publicized by the seller) materially impairs the property's value and cannot be discovered through reasonable inspection by a prudent buyer. Standard "as-is" clauses only bar claims regarding physical defects, not psychological impairments created and exploited by the seller.
B. The Modern Disclosures Rule (Johnson v. Davis)
Affirmative Duty: The modern judicial and statutory trend has largely dismantled caveat emptor, imposing a strict duty of good faith and fair dealing.
Rule: Where the seller of a home knows of facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer, the seller is under a duty to disclose them. Failure to disclose material defects (such as a known leaking roof) is legally equivalent to affirmative fraud. Most states now enforce these obligations through comprehensive statutory seller property disclosure forms and specific environmental warnings (e.g., lead-based paint, radon).