GMS note 11

Project Management Lecture Notes (GMS401 - Mohammad Nikoofal)

What is a Project?

  • Definition: A project is defined as an interrelated set of activities that has the following characteristics:

    • A definite start and end.

    • A unique outcome.

    • A specific allocation of resources.

  • PMI Definition: A project is described as a "temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product or service."

  • Examples of Projects:

    • Business Projects:

    • Building a stadium.

    • Creating advertising campaigns.

    • Developing new services/products.

    • Everyday Life Projects:

    • Wedding planning.

    • Remodeling a bathroom.

    • Writing a scientific paper.

What is Project Management (PM)?

  • PMI Definition of Project Management: The application of knowledge, skills, tools, and techniques to meet the requirements of a project.

  • Key Components of PM:

    • Time management.

    • Cost management.

    • Scope management.

    • Quality management.

    • People management.

    • Risk management.

Famous Project Failures

  1. Sydney Opera House

    • Cost Failure:

    • Initial budget: $7 million.

    • Final cost: over $100 million.

    • Cost overrun: 1,400%.

    • Took more than 10 years to complete.

    • Most expensive blowout in megaproject history.

  2. Montreal Olympic Stadium

    • Time Failure:

    • Built for the 1976 Olympics but was only half-complete at that time.

    • Initial estimate: $134 million.

    • Cost by Games: $264 million.

    • Total repayment completed in 2006: $1.61 billion.

    • Nicknamed "The Big Owe."

  3. Channel Tunnel

    • Design Failure:

    • The tunnel connecting the UK and France.

    • Took 20% longer (6 years instead of 5 years).

    • 80% over budget.

    • Issues stemmed from poor initial design and miscommunication.

Project Management Triangle (Iron Triangle)

  • The Project Management Triangle is also known as the iron triangle.

  • PM must balance the following three constraints:

    1. Time: Relates to the project's schedule and deadlines.

    2. Cost: Involves the budget and resources allocated.

    3. Scope: Defines the work requirements, deliverables, and quality expectations.

  • Key Principle: Changing one of these constraints will affect the others.

Five Major Planning Steps in Projects

  1. Defining the Work Breakdown Structure (WBS).

  2. Diagramming the project network (PERT/CPM).

  3. Developing the project schedule.

  4. Analyzing cost-time trade-offs (crashing).

  5. Assessing risks associated with the project.

Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)

  • Definition: A hierarchical decomposition of the project into tasks, subtasks, and work packages.

  • Structure Levels:

    • Level 1: Major activities identified by the project manager.

    • Level 2: Subtasks assigned to functional groups.

    • Level 3: Detailed action tasks.

  • Example - Community Festival:

    • Level 1 tasks assigned to individuals:

      • Promoting the festival → Lynn.

      • Finding volunteers → Beth.

      • Preparing games → Steve.

      • Offering rides → Pat.

      • Entertainment → Jeff.

      • Food → Bill.

      • Services for guests → Jack.

Project Scheduling

  • A project schedule lists:

    • Activities involved.

    • Start and finish times.

    • Milestones for tracking progress.

    • Deliverables expected from the project.

  • Three Scheduling Formats:

    1. Gantt Chart

    2. PERT Network (probabilistic times)

    3. CPM Network (deterministic times)

PERT vs. CPM Methods
  • CPM (Critical Path Method):

    • Based on fixed (deterministic) durations.

    • Primarily used for understanding time-cost trade-offs.

  • PERT (Program Evaluation & Review Technique):

    • Based on probabilistic durations.

    • Used for managing uncertainty in the project timeline.

  • Both methodologies utilize network diagrams depicting activities and events within the project.

Key PERT/CPM Terminology

  • Activity: A task that requires resources and time to complete.

  • Event: A completion point for one or more activities; events do not take any time.

  • Network: Composition of nodes and arrows that show dependencies between activities.

  • Path: A sequence of connected activities.

  • Critical Path: The longest path through the network which determines total project duration.

    • If any activity on the critical path is delayed, the entire project is delayed.

  • Critical Time: The total time required to complete the critical path.

Precedence Relationships

  • Precedence relationships illustrate which activities must be completed before others can start.

  • Example: Before painting the walls, the following activities must be completed:

    • Clear and cover the floor.

    • Remove any pictures from the walls.

    • Clean the walls.

    • Fill any holes or cracks.

    • Mask areas that should not be painted.

Activity-on-Node (AON) Network Example

  • An example network will display tasks A–G with their predecessors graphically outlined.

  • Hospital Relocation Example:

    • Given Table:

    • Activities labeled A–K.

    • Immediate predecessors listed.

    • Estimated durations (in weeks).

  • Network Analysis:

    • Total time calculated for each path:

    • Path A–I–K: 33 weeks

    • Path A–F–K: 28 weeks

    • Path A–C–G–J–K: 67 weeks

    • Path B–D–H–J–K: 69 weeks (CRITICAL PATH)

    • Path B–E–J–K: 43 weeks

    • Critical Path Conclusion:

    • Critical Path: B–D–H–J–K

    • Total Project Length: 69 weeks

Scheduling Calculations

  • Gantt Charts:

    • Gantt charts visually represent activities as horizontal bars spread across a time axis.

    • Helpful in visualizing overlaps and deadlines.

  • Critical Path Example - Accounting Software Project:

    • The network comprises six significant paths; the longest path is identified as:

    • Critical Path: A–E–H–I, estimated at 13 months.

Project Crashing (Time–Cost Trade-offs)

  • Goal of Crashing: The principal aim is to reduce the total project duration with the least additional cost incurred.

  • Types of Costs Involved:

    • Direct costs: Costs that directly relate to performing the work.

    • Indirect costs: Costs related to administrative and overhead activities.

    • Penalty costs: Fees for late completion of the project.

  • Crash Cost Formula:

    • Hospital Crashing Example:

    • Important Data Provided:

      • Indirect cost: $8,000/week.

      • Penalty if exceeding 65 weeks: $20,000/week.

    • Stage-by-Stage Crashing:

      • Stage 1: Crash task J by 3 weeks.

      • Savings: $81,000.

      • New project cost: $2,543,000.

      • New duration: 66 weeks.

      • Stage 2: Crash task D by 2 weeks.

      • Savings: $32,000.

      • New cost: $2,511,000.

      • New duration: 64 weeks.

      • Stage 3: Crash task K by 1 week.

      • Savings: $4,000.

      • New cost: $2,507,000.

      • New duration: 63 weeks.

      • Stage 4: Crash tasks B and C by 2 weeks.

      • Savings: $800.

      • New cost: $2,506,200.

      • New duration: 61 weeks.

      • Minimum Cost Schedule Achieved:

        • Final duration: 61 weeks.

        • Total cost: $2,506,200.

Risk Assessment in Projects

  • Project Risk: Defined as the probability multiplied by the consequence of not achieving project goals.

  • Common Sources of Uncertainty:

    • Labour strikes.

    • Weather disruptions.

    • Supplier delays.

    • Quality issues.

  • Risk Analysis Tools:

    • Simulation techniques.

    • Statistical analysis (e.g., PERT).

  • PERT Time Estimation (Probabilistic):

    • Activity durations follow a beta distribution.

    • Three Estimates Required:

    • a = optimistic time estimate.

    • m = most likely time estimate.

    • b = pessimistic time estimate.

Probabilistic Completion Time

  • Employing central limit theorem, the project duration is evaluated through these calculations:

    • Project Mean Time.

    • Project Variance.

    • To find the probability of finishing by a certain time T:

    • TE=teTE = te

    • extVariance<br>ightarrowextVari=extSumofvariances<br>ightarrowextProbabilisticcalculationext{Variance } <br>ightarrow ext{Vari} = ext{Sum of variances} <br>ightarrow ext{Probabilistic calculation}

    • Z=rac(T−TE)extStandarddeviationZ = rac{(T - TE)}{ ext{Standard deviation}}

  • Use Normal Cumulative Distribution with Casio fx-9750GIII Calculator:

    1. Press STAT.

    2. Select F5 (DIST).

    3. Choose F1 (NORM) followed by F2 (Ncd).

    4. Set Lower bound = 0.

    5. Set Upper bound = target time.

    6. Indicate standard deviation.

    • extStandarddeviation=extsqrt(variance)ext{Standard deviation} = ext{sqrt(variance)}

    1. Indicate mean or expected duration.

    2. Execute the calculation.

  • Hospital Example Overview (Slide 60):

    • Critical path identified as B-D-H-J-K.

    • Mean time for project completion estimated at 69 weeks.

    • Variance calculated as 11.89 leading to a standard deviation of approximately 3.45.

    • Probability of finishing in less than 72 weeks calculated as 0.81 (indicative of a high chance of early completion).