GMS note 11
Project Management Lecture Notes (GMS401 - Mohammad Nikoofal)
What is a Project?
Definition: A project is defined as an interrelated set of activities that has the following characteristics:
A definite start and end.
A unique outcome.
A specific allocation of resources.
PMI Definition: A project is described as a "temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product or service."
Examples of Projects:
Business Projects:
Building a stadium.
Creating advertising campaigns.
Developing new services/products.
Everyday Life Projects:
Wedding planning.
Remodeling a bathroom.
Writing a scientific paper.
What is Project Management (PM)?
PMI Definition of Project Management: The application of knowledge, skills, tools, and techniques to meet the requirements of a project.
Key Components of PM:
Time management.
Cost management.
Scope management.
Quality management.
People management.
Risk management.
Famous Project Failures
Sydney Opera House
Cost Failure:
Initial budget: $7 million.
Final cost: over $100 million.
Cost overrun: 1,400%.
Took more than 10 years to complete.
Most expensive blowout in megaproject history.
Montreal Olympic Stadium
Time Failure:
Built for the 1976 Olympics but was only half-complete at that time.
Initial estimate: $134 million.
Cost by Games: $264 million.
Total repayment completed in 2006: $1.61 billion.
Nicknamed "The Big Owe."
Channel Tunnel
Design Failure:
The tunnel connecting the UK and France.
Took 20% longer (6 years instead of 5 years).
80% over budget.
Issues stemmed from poor initial design and miscommunication.
Project Management Triangle (Iron Triangle)
The Project Management Triangle is also known as the iron triangle.
PM must balance the following three constraints:
Time: Relates to the project's schedule and deadlines.
Cost: Involves the budget and resources allocated.
Scope: Defines the work requirements, deliverables, and quality expectations.
Key Principle: Changing one of these constraints will affect the others.
Five Major Planning Steps in Projects
Defining the Work Breakdown Structure (WBS).
Diagramming the project network (PERT/CPM).
Developing the project schedule.
Analyzing cost-time trade-offs (crashing).
Assessing risks associated with the project.
Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)
Definition: A hierarchical decomposition of the project into tasks, subtasks, and work packages.
Structure Levels:
Level 1: Major activities identified by the project manager.
Level 2: Subtasks assigned to functional groups.
Level 3: Detailed action tasks.
Example - Community Festival:
Level 1 tasks assigned to individuals:
Promoting the festival → Lynn.
Finding volunteers → Beth.
Preparing games → Steve.
Offering rides → Pat.
Entertainment → Jeff.
Food → Bill.
Services for guests → Jack.
Project Scheduling
A project schedule lists:
Activities involved.
Start and finish times.
Milestones for tracking progress.
Deliverables expected from the project.
Three Scheduling Formats:
Gantt Chart
PERT Network (probabilistic times)
CPM Network (deterministic times)
PERT vs. CPM Methods
CPM (Critical Path Method):
Based on fixed (deterministic) durations.
Primarily used for understanding time-cost trade-offs.
PERT (Program Evaluation & Review Technique):
Based on probabilistic durations.
Used for managing uncertainty in the project timeline.
Both methodologies utilize network diagrams depicting activities and events within the project.
Key PERT/CPM Terminology
Activity: A task that requires resources and time to complete.
Event: A completion point for one or more activities; events do not take any time.
Network: Composition of nodes and arrows that show dependencies between activities.
Path: A sequence of connected activities.
Critical Path: The longest path through the network which determines total project duration.
If any activity on the critical path is delayed, the entire project is delayed.
Critical Time: The total time required to complete the critical path.
Precedence Relationships
Precedence relationships illustrate which activities must be completed before others can start.
Example: Before painting the walls, the following activities must be completed:
Clear and cover the floor.
Remove any pictures from the walls.
Clean the walls.
Fill any holes or cracks.
Mask areas that should not be painted.
Activity-on-Node (AON) Network Example
An example network will display tasks A–G with their predecessors graphically outlined.
Hospital Relocation Example:
Given Table:
Activities labeled A–K.
Immediate predecessors listed.
Estimated durations (in weeks).
Network Analysis:
Total time calculated for each path:
Path A–I–K: 33 weeks
Path A–F–K: 28 weeks
Path A–C–G–J–K: 67 weeks
Path B–D–H–J–K: 69 weeks (CRITICAL PATH)
Path B–E–J–K: 43 weeks
Critical Path Conclusion:
Critical Path: B–D–H–J–K
Total Project Length: 69 weeks
Scheduling Calculations
Gantt Charts:
Gantt charts visually represent activities as horizontal bars spread across a time axis.
Helpful in visualizing overlaps and deadlines.
Critical Path Example - Accounting Software Project:
The network comprises six significant paths; the longest path is identified as:
Critical Path: A–E–H–I, estimated at 13 months.
Project Crashing (Time–Cost Trade-offs)
Goal of Crashing: The principal aim is to reduce the total project duration with the least additional cost incurred.
Types of Costs Involved:
Direct costs: Costs that directly relate to performing the work.
Indirect costs: Costs related to administrative and overhead activities.
Penalty costs: Fees for late completion of the project.
Crash Cost Formula:
Hospital Crashing Example:
Important Data Provided:
Indirect cost: $8,000/week.
Penalty if exceeding 65 weeks: $20,000/week.
Stage-by-Stage Crashing:
Stage 1: Crash task J by 3 weeks.
Savings: $81,000.
New project cost: $2,543,000.
New duration: 66 weeks.
Stage 2: Crash task D by 2 weeks.
Savings: $32,000.
New cost: $2,511,000.
New duration: 64 weeks.
Stage 3: Crash task K by 1 week.
Savings: $4,000.
New cost: $2,507,000.
New duration: 63 weeks.
Stage 4: Crash tasks B and C by 2 weeks.
Savings: $800.
New cost: $2,506,200.
New duration: 61 weeks.
Minimum Cost Schedule Achieved:
Final duration: 61 weeks.
Total cost: $2,506,200.
Risk Assessment in Projects
Project Risk: Defined as the probability multiplied by the consequence of not achieving project goals.
Common Sources of Uncertainty:
Labour strikes.
Weather disruptions.
Supplier delays.
Quality issues.
Risk Analysis Tools:
Simulation techniques.
Statistical analysis (e.g., PERT).
PERT Time Estimation (Probabilistic):
Activity durations follow a beta distribution.
Three Estimates Required:
a = optimistic time estimate.
m = most likely time estimate.
b = pessimistic time estimate.
Probabilistic Completion Time
Employing central limit theorem, the project duration is evaluated through these calculations:
Project Mean Time.
Project Variance.
To find the probability of finishing by a certain time T:
Use Normal Cumulative Distribution with Casio fx-9750GIII Calculator:
Press STAT.
Select F5 (DIST).
Choose F1 (NORM) followed by F2 (Ncd).
Set Lower bound = 0.
Set Upper bound = target time.
Indicate standard deviation.
Indicate mean or expected duration.
Execute the calculation.
Hospital Example Overview (Slide 60):
Critical path identified as B-D-H-J-K.
Mean time for project completion estimated at 69 weeks.
Variance calculated as 11.89 leading to a standard deviation of approximately 3.45.
Probability of finishing in less than 72 weeks calculated as 0.81 (indicative of a high chance of early completion).