Untitled
INTRODUCTION TO LAW AND THE GHANA LEGAL SYSTEM
Overview of the Ghana Legal System
- University of Professional Studies, Accra (UPSA) promotes scholarship with professionalism.
WHAT IS LAW?
- The question "What is law?" is a complex and widely debated topic.
- It has been approached by priests, poets, philosophers, kings, and the general populace, including prophets.
- Numerous definitions exist but the nature of law remains elusive.
- Key definitions include:
- Law as a System of Rules: A system of rules created by a body or person with the power and authority to make laws.
- Law as Action: Law is defined by the activities of legislators, judges, and lawyers.
- Law as Oppression: Often viewed as a tool used by the ruling class to advance their interests.
- Law as Morality: It is also perceived as a system grounded on fundamental principles of morality.
- Basic Definition: Law is a set of rules that individuals are bound to obey, enforceable by the State, with repercussions for failures to comply.
The Purpose of Law
- Described as the ‘glue’ that binds society together.
- Law protects against social disorder and anarchy.
- Functions of law:
- Protection: Safeguarding individuals from each other and from threats.
- Freedom: Allowing individuals to exercise their rights.
- Dispute Resolution: Facilitating resolution of conflicts.
- Social Control: Used to regulate behavior within society.
What is a Legal System?
- Defined as the procedure or process for interpreting and enforcing laws.
- Purpose: Establishes societal rules and defines individual rights.
- Components of a legal system:
- A collective of rules and institutions that govern society.
- Governs relationships between individuals and between the state and individuals.
- Key Institutions constituting Ghana's legal system include:
- Commission on Human Rights and Administrative Justice (CHRAJ)
- Police
- Executive
- Judiciary
- Legislature
- Nature of Ghana’s Legal System:
- Pluralistic; includes legal rules of British origin, customary rules of specific communities, and legislation from Parliament.
Major Legal Systems Worldwide
- Common Law: Judge-made laws; based on judicial precedents (stare decisis); adversarial process.
- Civil Law (Romano-Germanic): Inquisitorial in nature.
- Religious Legal Systems: Includes Islamic laws.
- Socialist Legal Systems: Governed by socialist ideologies.
SOURCES OF LAW IN GHANA
- The term “sources of law” has multiple meanings:
- Formal Source: Provides legitimacy to the law (e.g., the Constitution).
- Direct Source: Where law originates (e.g., legislation, judicial precedents).
- Article 11 (1) of the 1992 Constitution defines the laws of Ghana:
- a) This Constitution
- b) Enactments made by or under the authority of Parliament
- c) Orders, rules, and regulations issued under constitutional authority
- d) Existing law
- e) Common law
- Article 11(2) specifies the common law of Ghana, which consists of:
- General rules of common law
- Doctrines of equity
- Customary law determined by the Superior Court of Judicature.
Common Law in Ghana
- Developed through judicial decisions rather than through legislative statutes.
- Operates under the principle of precedent, asserting fairness in applying similar facts consistently.
- Adversarial legal nature.
What is Equity?
- Equity refers to a set of legal principles within jurisdictions following the English common law tradition.
- Supplements the law, addressing deficiencies in common law.
- Aims to mitigate harshness inherent in the common law.
- Maxims of Equity:
- Equity will not suffer a wrong without remedy.
- Equity follows the law.
- He who seeks equity must do equity.
- Equality is equity.
- Equity looks to the intent rather than the form.
- Where there is equal equity, the law shall prevail.
- Article 11(3) defines “customary law” as applicable rules based on the customs of specific communities.
Customary Law in Ghana
- Defined in Section 18 (1) of the Interpretation Act 1960, customary law consists of rules applicable to communities, distinct from common law.
- Must comply with natural justice and not contradict the Constitution.
- Article 11(4) states that existing law comprises:
- Written and unwritten laws preceding the Constitution's enactment.
Law-Making Process in Ghana
- Promulgation of the Constitution: The 1992 Constitution came into force in January 1993:
- Drafted by experts commissioned by the PNDC.
- A consultative assembly deliberated the draft.
- Public referendum held allowing voting by citizens aged eighteen and above.
- Supremacy of the Constitution:
- Article 1(2) states it is the supreme law, voiding any inconsistent laws.
- Referenced Case: Ghana Independent Broadcasters Association (GIBA) vs National Media Commission involving content authorization requirements.
Enactments by Parliament
Acts of Parliament:
- Follow procedures as per Article 93 of the Constitution, e.g., Labour Act, 2003 (Act 651).
Procedure for Enactment:
- Bills introduced by the president or appointed individuals (ministers).
- Must be published at least 14 days in advance (Article 106(2)(b)).
- Often requires consultation with the National House of Chiefs for specific bills (Article 106(3)).
- Approximately includes:
- First reading and referral to committee.
- Second reading and committee report.
- Final third reading and presidential assent.
Delegated Legislation:
- Rules made by ministers or local authorities under authority from Parliament (Legislative Instruments, Executive Instruments).
- Examples include Labour Regulations, Road Traffic Regulations.
Constitutional Instruments:
- Orders, Rules, and Regulations made under constitutional power.
- Must comply with Article 11(7) of the Constitution.
Law Enforcement: The Court System in Ghana
- Judicial structure consists of:
- Superior Courts of Judicature: Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court.
- Lower Courts: Circuit Courts, District Courts.
- Recognized traditional councils (National House of Chiefs, Regional Houses of Chiefs).
- Specialized courts established for expeditious dispute resolution (Commercial Courts, Human Rights Courts, etc.).
SUPREME COURT
- It holds the highest appellate authority in Ghana.
- Supervises lower courts, issuing orders to enforce its directives.
- Exclusive jurisdiction over constitutional interpretation and enforcement-related matters.
- Composed of the Chief Justice and at least nine Justices; cases are heard in panels of five.
COURT OF APPEAL
- Serves as the appellate court for decisions from the High Court and subordinate courts.
- Purely an appellate court with no original jurisdiction.
- Composed of the Chief Justice and a minimum of ten Justices; generally convenes in panels of three.
HIGH COURT
- Constituted by a single judge unless otherwise specified.
- Holds original jurisdiction in civil and criminal matters.
- Appellate jurisdiction over District and Circuit Courts, and exclusive jurisdiction over the enforcement of fundamental rights.
- Composed of the Chief Justice and at least twenty Justices.
REGIONAL TRIBUNAL
- Handles serious criminal matters as legislated by Parliament.
- Concurrent original and appellate jurisdiction with the High Court in criminal cases.
- No jurisdiction over civil matters and does not hold supervisory authority.
- Composition includes the Chief Justice, a chairman, and a minimum of two additional members.
CIRCUIT COURT
- Led by a Circuit Judge with jurisdiction over civil actions under contract/tort with claims up to GHC 50,000.00.
- Jurisdiction extends to criminal matters excluding treason and death-penalty offences.
- Appeals in civil matters directed to the Court of Appeal and in criminal matters to the High Court.
DISTRICT COURT
- Predominates in quantity across the country, handling various special courts (Family, Juvenile, Motor).
- Civil jurisdiction in actions under contract/tort up to GHC 20,000.00.
- Criminal jurisdiction includes summary offences punishable with fines up to 500 penalty units or imprisonment of up to two years.
FAMILY TRIBUNAL
- Specialized court focusing on matters under the Children’s Act 1998 (Act 560).
- Jurisdiction includes custody, parentage, and children's welfare.
- Hears cases needing special care with oversight from a social welfare officer.
JUVENILE COURT
- Focuses on cases involving individuals under 18.
- Composed of a District Magistrate and appointed members including a social welfare officer.
MOTOR COURT
- Specializes in motor traffic cases as designated by the Chief Justice.
LITIGATION AS A MEANS OF DISPUTE RESOLUTION
- Definition: A dispute is a disagreement, particularly about rights and obligations in business relationships.
Causative Factors of Business Disputes:
Lack of clear communication of rights and responsibilities.
External conditions leading to non-fulfillment of obligations.
Bad faith strategies by one party.
Incompetent performance by involved parties.
Legal consequences of non-fulfillment include the right to take legal action against the defaulting party for remedy.
The judiciary’s role is crucial in adjudicating these disputes.
THE ROLE OF THE JUDICIARY
- The judiciary comprises various courts with a mandate to interpret and apply laws.
- Courts do not create contracts but enforce agreements made by conflicting parties.
- Their purpose is to respect the intentions of the parties involved in the agreements.
CHALLENGES ASSOCIATED WITH LITIGATION
- Litigation can be time-consuming and costly (filing fees, legal fees).
- It may destroy existing relationships between parties.
- Remedies provided by courts (like damages) may not ensure recovery if the opposing party is financially incapable of paying.
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR)
- ADR encompasses means of resolving disputes outside of litigation, valued for being expeditious and less adversarial.
- Main forms of ADR practiced in Ghana include:
- Negotiation: Involves parties reaching an agreement without third-party involvement.
- Mediation: An impartial third party facilitates resolution while remaining neutral.
- Arbitration: A neutral arbitrator decides the outcome of a dispute, which is binding on parties.
Court-Connected ADR
- Established to alleviate court backlog and enhance justice access.
- Options for disputing parties who are already in the court system.
- Mediator selection from court-assigned lists and potential judicial adoption of agreements reached.
Advantages of ADR over Litigation
- Reduction of court case backlogs, cost-saving, quicker resolutions, and restoration of strained relationships.
- Legal frameworks supporting ADR include sections from the Courts Act 1993 (Act 459) and the Labour Act 2003 (Act 651).
- The Chief Justice formed the Commercial Division of the High Court for efficient handling of commercial disputes which also mandates ADR usage.