Study Notes on the Persecution of LGBTQ+ Individuals under Nazi Germany

Introduction

  • Host: Edna Friedberg, Historian

  • Context of Pride Month: Current attacks and legal threats to LGBTQ+ individuals in the U.S. and abroad.

  • Focus of the program: Persecution of LGBTQ+ people under Nazi Germany.

  • Guest speaker: Dr. Mark Alexander, fellow historian.

Historical Context: LGBTQ+ Life in Pre-Nazi Germany

  • Timeline: 1920s-1930s

  • Setting: Berlin as the gay capital of the world

    • Cultural and social upheaval due to World War I and the end of the German Empire.

    • Emergence of the Weimar Republic introducing a new democracy.

    • Description of societal experiences of relative freedom in urban centers.

    • Berlin’s nightlife and cultural centers attracting LGBTQ+ individuals globally.

  • Venues:

    • By 1925, at least 80 establishments catered to gay men, lesbian women, and non-conforming individuals.

    • Example publication: "Berlin's Lesbian Women" (1928 guide listing venues).

Pioneering Research on Sexuality and Gender

  • Establishment: Institute for Sexual Science in Berlin

    • Focus on new ideas regarding sexual orientation and gender identity.

    • Understanding that sexuality is innate and uncorrelated to one's character.

    • Reputation as a tourist destination, hosting lectures and events attracting diverse visitors including celebrities.

Tension in Society

  • Despite the progressive atmosphere, many Germans visibly disapproved of non-heteronormative behaviors.

  • Rise of the Nazi party quickly led to significant changes for LGBTQ+ individuals.

Nazi Regime and the Persecution of LGBTQ+ Individuals

  • Immediate Measures Post-1933:

    • Persecution of social outsiders including LGBTQ+ individuals.

    • Closure of many LGBTQ+ venues, organizations, and publications.

    • Specific notable example: the Eldorado nightclub transformed into a Nazi headquarters.

Institute for Sexual Science Targeted

  • Event: May 1933, a Nazi student group vandalizes the Institute.

    • Confiscation of library contents and destruction in public book burnings.

  • Cultural Consolidation: Destruction of what Nazis deemed degenerate or deviant.

Changes in Laws Targeting LGBTQ+ Individuals

  • Existing laws prior to Nazi rule targeted same-sex relationships among men and were expanded upon in the Nazi regime.

    • Post-1935: Men could be arrested for mere physical contact or eye contact with another man.

    • Estimated 100,000 men arrested under these laws during this period.

  • Exemption for Women:

    • Absence of a specific law against women, yet lesbian women faced discrimination and persecution.

    • Increase in visibility led to heightened danger for non-conforming individuals.

Case Study: Margot Holzmann

  • Background: Born to a Jewish family in Poland, trained as a ballet dancer, performing in Berlin.

  • Relationship: Margot and her partner Marta Halusa, who identified as Peter.

    • Unique performance duo identity—professional name used was traditionally masculine.

    • Margot faced multiple police encounters due to her Jewish identity and same-sex relationships.

  • Escalation of Danger:

    • Margot's father deported in 1938, increasing both Margot and Peter's awareness of their vulnerable positions.

    • Initiation of protective marriage to Chi Lan-Liu, a Chinese national, to gain citizenship benefits.

Consequences of Nazi Policy on LGBTQ+ Lives

  • Final Arrest: 1945 arrest during a political birthday party.

  • Charges of treason; however, they managed to hide and ultimately were liberated by the Red Army.

  • Post-war life, emigrated to England, but faced lasting health issues due to trauma experienced during the Nazi regime.

Case Study: Nelly Mousset-Vos and Nadine Huang

  • Background:

    • Nelly: Born in Brussels, had a prior marriage and two daughters, was a professional singer.

    • Nadine: Born in Spain, daughter of a Chinese diplomat, moved to Paris and socialized in creative circles.

  • Meeting: Both imprisoned at Ravensbrück Concentration Camp—one of the largest camps for women.

  • Conditions: Poor sanitation, limited food, forced labor contributing to a high mortality rate (estimate 132,000 women imprisoned).

Arrest Reasons and Survival

  • Neither Nelly nor Nadine were Jewish; Nelly was a political prisoner for being a spy in the French Resistance.

  • Their imprisonment on Christmas 1944, building a supportive relationship amid severe hardships.

  • Nelly transferred to Mauthausen following their meeting, a notoriously brutal camp.

Reuniting After the War

  • Both women liberated in April 1945, faced the chaotic post-war landscape.

  • Nadine and Nelly eventually sent letters and postcards to reconnect.