Rethinking Innocence Projects in England and Wales: Study Notes

Foundations and Global Context of Innocence Projects

  • Definition and Core Functions:

    • An innocence project is a pro bono scheme situated within a university higher education institution (predominantly law schools, but also journalism and criminology departments).

    • Primary objectives comprise: investigating potential miscarriages of justice on behalf of convicted individuals maintaining innocence, educating students in criminal law and procedure, and conducting research to drive systemic criminal justice reform.

  • US Origins and Global Expansion:

    • The first innocence project was established in 19921992 by Peter Neufeld and Barry Scheck at the Benjamin Cardozo Law School at Yeshiva University in New York (The Innocence Project New York). This was predated by Centurion Ministries, founded in 19831983 as a non-university organization dedicated to assisting the wrongly convicted.

    • In 20042004, the Innocence Network was formed in the United States to represent an affiliation of organizations dedicated to providing free legal and investigative services to individuals seeking to prove factual innocence, redressing root causes of wrongful convictions, and supporting exonerated individuals post-release.

    • By December 20202020, post-conviction DNA testing alone had achieved 375375 exonerations in the US. The National Registry of Exonerations recorded 2,7082,708 total exonerations between 19891989 and January 20212021.

    • The movement expanded internationally to countries including Australia, Canada, China, New Zealand, Argentina, South Africa, Ireland, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Italy, and France.

    • The Innocence Network encompasses approximately 6767 member projects worldwide. Regional networks have also formed, including RedInocente in Latin America and the European Innocence Network.

The Rise of Innocence Projects in England and Wales

  • Establishment of Innocence Network UK (INUK):

    • Innocence projects were introduced to the UK following the establishment of Innocence Network UK (INUK) in 20042004 by Dr Michael Naughton, an academic in the School of Law at the University of Bristol.

    • UK innocence projects were predated by the Northumbria Law Clinic, which conducted appeal work resulting in the quashing of Alex Allan's conviction in 20012001.

    • INUK operated as a central umbrella and membership organization. It assisted universities in establishing projects, hosted student and staff training, provided standardized operational protocols, and distributed case files from a centralized database.

    • Between 20042004 and 20142014, INUK facilitated the setup of 3636 innocence projects across the UK (3535 based in university law, journalism, or criminology departments, and 11 established within the law firm White & Case LLP).

  • Theoretical Rationale Behind INUK:

    • INUK was established on the premise that post-conviction remedies were failing factually innocent victims.

    • Public and political assumptions that miscarriages of justice were resolved following the Royal Commission on Criminal Justice (19931993) and the establishment of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) under the Criminal Appeal Act 19951995 were viewed as premature.

    • The Court of Appeal Criminal Division (CACD) enforces strict admissibility rules under Section 2323 of the Criminal Justice Act 19681968, excluding evidence that was available at trial unless a reasonable explanation is provided for failing to adduce it previously.

    • The CCRC's statutory test under Section 1313 of the Criminal Appeal Act 19951995 restricts referrals to cases where there is a "real possibility" that the CACD will not uphold the conviction. This requirement was criticized for making the CCRC a "gatekeeper" to the CACD, forcing it to second-guess judicial outcomes rather than independently investigating factual innocence.

  • Tripartite Objectives of UK Innocence Projects:

    • Education: Providing law students with practical insight into criminal law, procedure, and evidence; fostering critical thinking, ethics, and a pro bono commitment.

    • Research: Collating case data to analyze structural causes of wrongful convictions and advocating for corrective legal reform.

    • Casework: Investigating claims of wrongful conviction for applicants who maintain innocence and have exhausted their statutory appeal rights.

  • INUK Casework Methodology and Case Screening:

    • INUK mandated an exclusive focus on factual innocence (the applicant did not commit the crime) as distinct from legal safety (procedural irregularities or errors of law during trial).

    • INUK screened applicants via a comprehensive questionnaire designed to exclude:

      • Applicants seeking appeal solely on procedural or legal technicalities.

      • Applicants who did not realize their behavior constituted a criminal offense.

      • Applicants who disagreed with the law defining their conduct as criminal.

      • Applicants maintaining innocence to protect loved ones.

    • INUK instructed student caseworkers to operate outside existing legal parameters, directing them to suspend searching for legal grounds for appeal and focus strictly on determining whether the client was telling the truth.

  • Drivers of Expansion (20042004\text{--}20142014):

    • Growth coincided with an institutional turn toward clinical legal education in UK universities during the early 2000s2000\text{s}.

    • Innocence projects allowed law departments to offer criminal law clinical experience, complementing existing civil law clinics.

    • Projects expanded to fill a growing gap in post-conviction legal assistance resulting from progressive legal aid restrictions.

Post-Conviction Legal Framework and Systemic Constraints

  • Systemic Crisis in the Criminal Justice System:

    • Underinvestment and legal aid cuts following the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 20122012 (LASPO) weakened defense representation and heightened wrongful conviction risks.

    • Contributing systemic factors include statutory curtailments of suspects' rights, the privatization and outsourcing of forensic science services, and widespread prosecution disclosure failures (exemplified by the trial collapse and acquittal of Liam Allan in 20172017).

  • Direct Appeal Framework to the CACD:

    • A convicted individual has 2828 days from trial conviction in the Crown Court to apply for leave to appeal to the CACD.

    • Appellants must demonstrate an error in law/procedure or fresh evidence rendering the conviction "unsafe" under Section 2(1)(a)2(1)(a) of the Criminal Appeal Act 19951995.

    • Leave applications are judged by a Single Judge. If refused, applicants can renew the application to a full court of three judges.

    • Risk: If a renewed application is deemed unmeritorious, the CACD can issue a loss of time order (R v. Gray & Ors [20142014] EWCA Crim 23722372), ordering that time served pending the appeal will not count toward the sentence.

  • The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC):

    • Established in 19951995 following recommendations of the 19911991 Royal Commission on Criminal Justice.

    • Acts as an independent body reviewing alleged miscarriages of justice. Under Section 1313 of the Criminal Appeal Act 19951995, it can only refer a conviction to the CACD if there is a "real possibility" the CACD will quash the conviction.

    • While legal representation is not mandatory to apply to the CCRC, empirical studies demonstrate that represented applicants have a significantly higher probability of receiving a full review and obtaining a referral (Hodgson and Horne 20092009).

Empirical Research Methodology and Case Sample

  • Research Design:

    • Conducted by Holly Greenwood between 20122012 and 20172017 (data predominantly collected between 20132013 and 20152015).

    • First empirical study examining innocence projects across England and Wales using a comparative, multiple-case study design.

    • Of 2525 projects contacted, 1313 agreed to participate (11 refused, 33 cancelled/failed to arrange, 77 failed to respond). All participating projects were located in England and Wales.

    • Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 1616 individuals across the 1313 participating projects.

  • Summary Breakdown of Sampled Projects:

    • Project A (IPL1): Law department; INUK member up to 20142014; interviewed pre-fold; active at interview.

    • Project B (IPL2): Journalism department; left INUK prior to 20142014; interviewed pre-fold; active at interview.

    • Project C (IPL3): Law department; left INUK prior to 20142014; interviewed pre-fold; active at interview.

    • Project D (IPL4): Journalism department; non-INUK member; interviewed pre-fold; closed at interview.

    • Project E (IPL5): Law department; operated completely independently; interviewed pre-fold; active under new directorship.

    • Project F (IPL6): Law department; INUK member up to 20142014; interviewed pre-fold; active at interview.

    • Project G (IPL7 & IPL8 co-directors): Law department; left INUK prior to 20142014; interviewed pre-fold; active at interview.

    • Project H (IPL9 former director & IPL10 current director): Law department; left INUK prior to 20142014; interviewed pre-fold; active at interview.

    • Project I (IPL11 & IPL12 co-directors): Law department; left INUK prior to 20142014; interviewed post-fold; active at interview.

    • Project J (IPL13): Law department; INUK member up to 20142014; interviewed post-fold; active at interview.

    • Project K (IPL14): Law department; INUK member up to 20142014; interviewed post-fold; closed at interview.

    • Project L (IPL15): Law department; INUK member up to 20142014; interviewed post-fold; suspended at interview.

    • Project M (IPL16): Law department; INUK member up to 20142014; interviewed post-fold; active at interview.

  • Leadership Backgrounds across Sample:

    • 33 projects directed by legal academics with former criminal practice experience.

    • 88 projects directed by legal academics without criminal practice experience (two co-directed with former campaigners).

    • 22 projects directed by journalism academics.

Internal Tensions and the Fall of UK Innocence Projects

  • Network Dissolution and Interpersonal Conflicts:

    • In the summer of 20142014, INUK announced it would fold as a national membership organization. The flagship office at Bristol University closed in July 20152015

    • INUK cited funding shortages, member project non-compliance with protocols, declining staff/student engagement, and a diminishing pool of eligible cases.

    • Empirical data revealed deep governance conflicts prior to the fold: member projects described INUK as undemocratic, autocratic, and hostile.

    • Interviewees criticized INUK's combative approach toward statutory bodies, including personal attacks on CCRC staff, and noted that INUK members were banned from attending CCRC-hosted events.

  • Methodological Friction in Casework:

    • Factual Innocence vs Legal Safety: Demoting legal grounds for appeal hindered projects from advancing cases through the statutory requirements of the CCRC and CACD.

    • Last-Resort Case Characteristics: Projects received complex cases that had already passed through multiple levels of appeal and professional legal review, making it difficult to uncover new evidence.

    • Screening and Recycling Issues: Projects reported receiving unviable cases from the INUK database that had already been rejected by the CCRC multiple times or had been recycled after failed investigations by other projects.

    • Case Closure Policy: INUK discouraged projects from closing unviable cases, creating backlogs and paralysis.

  • Structural Conflicts within University Systems:

    • Timeline Mismatches: Miscarriage casework takes years, conflicting with university clinical structures designed for quick, term-based client turnarounds.

    • Calendar Gaps: Projects lost 55 to 66 months of active operational time annually due to student holidays and exam periods.

    • Student Turnover: Annual graduation cycles required continuous re-recruitment and basic training, creating operational delays.

    • Academic Workload and Career Impact: Supervising projects was often uncompensated in academic workload allocations. Running an innocence project was difficult to align with Research Excellence Framework (REF) publication expectations and was described by one director (IPL5) as "suicidal" for an academic career.

External Constraints and Systemic Appellate Barriers

  • Quantitative Casework Success Rates:

    • Between 20042004 and 20202020, innocence projects across the UK contributed to only 33 CCRC referrals to the CACD:

      1. R v. Hall [20112011] EWCA Crim 44 (conviction upheld).

      2. R v. Beck [20132013] HCJAC 5151 (conviction upheld).

      3. R v. George [20142014] EWCA Crim 25072507 (conviction quashed in December 20142014).

    • Direct appeals to the CACD yielded 11 quashed conviction (R v. Jones [20182018] EWCA Crim 28162816).

    • Direct applications for leave to appeal were refused in 22 cases (R v. Conaghan (and others) [20172017] EWCA Crim 597597).

    • Cardiff University Innocence Project Statistics: Submitted 2020 applications to the CCRC (1616 rejected, 11 referred and quashed [George], 33 pending) and 22 direct applications to the CACD (11 quashed [Jones], 11 rejected on 3030 January 20192019). Overall output: 1717 rejections out of 2222 total statutory submissions.

    • 20152015 CCRC Freedom of Information data indicated that approximately 2525 submissions had been received from 1010 innocence projects, resulting in only 33 referrals.

  • Restrictive Trends in Appellate Courts:

    • CACD Quash Rates: CACD Annual Reports show that successful appeals against conviction fell from an average of 12%12\% (20092009\text{--}20102010 review) to 6.7%6.7\% (20182018\text{--}20192019 review).

    • CCRC Referral Rates: The CCRC's historic referral rate averaged 3.3%3.3\%. This dropped to 0.77%0.77\% in 20162016\text{--}20172017, 1.24%1.24\% in 20172017\text{--}20182018, 0.9%0.9\% in 20182018\text{--}20192019, and rose to 2%2\% (2929 referrals) in 20192019\text{--}20202020, reducing the long-term average referral rate to approximately 2.75%2.75\%.

    • CCRC Referral Quash Rates: The proportion of CCRC-referred conviction appeals quashed by the CACD fell from a long-term average of 66%66\% to 58.8%58.8\% in 20192019\text{--}20202020

    • Fresh Evidence Admissibility: Roberts (20172017) documented that the CACD admitted fresh evidence in 19%19\% of cases in 20162016 (down from 61%61\% in 19901990), with fresh evidence appeal success rates dropping to 2%2\% in 20162016 (down from 17%17\% in 19901990).

  • Post-Conviction Disclosure Barriers:

    • The legal test governing post-conviction disclosure of police exhibits presents a significant barrier. Under Nunn v. Chief Constable of Suffolk Police [20152015] AC 225225, applicants have no automatic right to post-conviction disclosure unless they demonstrate a "real prospect" that further investigation will reveal material affecting conviction safety.

  • Failed Reform Efforts:

    • INUK hosted a CCRC Reform Symposium in 20122012, publishing a report calling for CCRC statutory independence, redrafting of the Section 1313 "real possibility" test, expanded fresh evidence definitions, and field-based CCRC investigations.

    • INUK filed an intervention in Nunn v. Chief Constable of Suffolk Police [20152015] AC 225225.

    • Innocence project directors provided evidence to the 20142014\text{--}20152015 House of Commons Justice Select Committee inquiry into the CCRC. Despite committee recommendations that the CCRC be less cautious and the CACD quash convictions where there is "serious doubt", Lord Chancellor Michael Gove MP formally rejected CACD reform recommendations in October 20152015

Comparative Analysis: UK versus US Innocence Movements

  • Social Movement Theory and DNA (Norris 20172017):

    • The US innocence movement leveraged post-conviction DNA technology as an unassailable proof of innocence, producing a dataset of undeniable wrongful convictions that forced legislative change.

    • This led to statutory reforms including the federal Innocence Protection Act 20042004, the Wrongful Convictions Tax Relief Act 20152015, and compensation statutes in 3030 US states.

    • In England and Wales, DNA profiling was integrated into criminal investigations long before innocence projects emerged in 20042004, leaving UK projects with fewer opportunities to utilize post-conviction DNA testing as definitive proof of innocence.

  • Jurisdictional and Systemic Differences (Quirk 20072007, 20212021):

    • Directly transplanting the US model ignored pre-existing UK protections, including statutory detention controls under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 19841984 (PACE), legal aid schemes, and the CCRC.

    • High-Profile Credibility Blow: In August 20132013, Simon Hall—a client in INUK's flagship case featured in media campaigns and television documentaries—confessed to the 20012001 murder of Joan Albert after maintaining innocence for 1212 years, severely undermining INUK's reform narrative.

  • Empirical Comparison via Krieger (20112011) US Study:

    • Funding: Krieger found a direct correlation between project budgets and exonerations in the US; no project with an annual budget of $200,000\$200,000 or less achieved more than 55 exonerations. UK projects operate with basic departmental running budgets.

    • Prison Population: The US prison population (~2,300,0002,300,000) generates a vast case pool compared to England and Wales (78,72278,722 as of December 20202020).

    • Request Ratios: US innocence projects average 1,7501,750 assistance requests per single exoneration. Taking this ratio into account, INUK reviewing over 1,0001,000 cases and achieving 11 exoneration (R v. George) is proportionally consistent with US outcomes.

Re-Evaluating the Future Role of University Miscarriage of Justice Projects

  • Addressing Unmet Post-Conviction Legal Need:

    • Trial legal aid covers written appeal advice post-conviction within a strict 2828-day window. Once a trial barrister advises there are no arguable appeal grounds (or leave is refused by a Single Judge), legal aid terminates.

    • Subsequent Legal Aid Advice and Assistance requires proving a "new matter". Combined with fee cuts, criminal solicitors have increasingly withdrawn from post-conviction work.

    • The proportion of unrepresented applicants submitting cases to the CCRC has risen to approximately 90%90\% (compared to a historical average of 70%70\%).

    • Recent empirical data shows that of 183183 unrepresented applicants rejected by the CCRC for failing to exhaust direct appeal rights, only 11.5%11.5\% went on to lodge an appeal with the CACD (Hodgson, Horne and Soubise 20182018).

    • Effectively operating university projects can help fill this gap by conducting preliminary investigations, helping clients access pro bono counsel, and assisting unrepresented individuals in structuring CCRC applications.

  • Clinical Methodological Shifts:

    • Surviving projects (often rebranded as Miscarriage of Justice Projects) have largely moved away from a strict focus on factual innocence.

    • Incorporating procedural irregularities and legal errors into casework aligns clinical work with the statutory "unsafety" standard applied by the CACD and helps preserve trial due process rights.

  • Alternative Success Metrics:

    • Success in university clinical projects extends beyond quashed convictions to include providing unrepresented prisoners with thorough case evaluations and explanations.

    • Academic projects contribute to policy research, such as providing evidence to the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Miscarriages of Justice / Westminster Commission on Miscarriages of Justice (20212021 report In the Interests of Justice).

    • Educational benefits remain significant: training future legal practitioners to critically evaluate evidence, maintain ethical standards, and preserve a commitment to criminal legal aid and pro bono work.