Chapter 22

The Great Migration

During the Great Depression, most Americans who lost their jobs were white men, but racial and ethnic minorities suffered disproportionate hardship because they already faced economic and political discrimination.

Economic discrimination: low wages, fewer job opportunities, and difficulty finding or keeping jobs.

Political discrimination: voting restrictions and exclusion from political participation.

The Great Depression worsened existing inequalities rather than creating all of them. As jobs became scarce, white workers competed for jobs previously held by minorities, making it even harder for discriminated groups to maintain their incomes.

Scottsboro Nine

The Scottsboro Nine were nine young Black men, ranging from 12 to 19 years old, accused of raping two white women in Alabama during the Great Depression. They were quickly convicted by an all-white jury despite having inadequate legal representation. The case showed how racial discrimination in the South denied African Americans fair trials and equal protection under the law, especially through the exclusion of Black people from juries.

estion 1: Why do you think they mention their ages?

They mention their ages to emphasize that they were very young, including two defendants who were only fourteen and one who was thirteen according to the letter. They wanted readers to understand the severity of sentencing such young people to death.

What tactics did Alabama officials use on the prisoners? What was their purpose?

The prisoners were quickly convicted by an all-white jury after receiving inadequate legal representation. They also described a hostile crowd shouting racist threats and officials allowing them to witness other Black people being executed. These circumstances intimidated the prisoners and reflected the racial prejudice surrounding their case.


Hoover Faces the Depression

1. Hoover’s Economic Beliefs

When Republican Herbert Hoover became president in March 1929, American prosperity was at its peak. He believed that government and businesses should cooperate voluntarily to achieve common goals.

  • Voluntarism: Hoover believed that businesses, workers, and communities should cooperate voluntarily to solve economic problems.

  • Limited government intervention: The federal government should encourage and persuade businesses to act responsibly without controlling the private sector.

  • Local relief and private charity: Local communities, state and municipal governments, religious groups, and private charities should provide assistance to people in need.

Hoover hoped businesses and workers would maintain stable prices and wages. However, the Great Depression tested these beliefs because the economic crisis was too severe for voluntary cooperation and local assistance to solve.

2. Why Hoover’s Initial Approach Failed

Businesses initially responded positively to Hoover’s requests, but they lost confidence when the economy did not recover. Local governments and private charities lacked sufficient resources to help everyone affected by mass unemployment.

By 1933, approximately 1,300 municipalities had gone bankrupt as tax revenues declined. Charities and religious organizations could help with short-term problems but could not manage the widespread, ongoing crisis.

Hoover introduced additional federal measures, although his response remained limited by his economic beliefs.

  • Public works: He persuaded Congress to allocate an unprecedented $423 million for federal public works projects.

  • Agricultural Marketing Act (1929): Aimed to increase agricultural prices and help struggling farmers.

  • Tax increases (1932): Hoover initially supported lowering income tax rates, but in 1932 he joined Congress in increasing income, estate, and corporate taxes on the wealthy. According to the text, these increases slowed investment and new production, causing further job losses.

  • Hawley-Smoot Act (1930): Increased tariffs on imported agricultural and industrial goods to protect American farmers and businesses and raise government. Other countries retaliated by raising their tariffs, reducing demand for American exports and worsening economic conditions.

  • Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC): Hoover persuaded Congress to establish the RFC to provide loans to troubled banks, railroads, and insurance companies. In 1932, Congress gave the RFC a budget of $1.5 billion to support lending and public works.

Why the RFC Failed

Hoover hoped that helping major financial institutions and businesses would allow prosperity to spread from the top of the economy to ordinary workers. This was the idea of trickle-down economics.

However, the RFC distributed its funds too cautiously and mainly helped institutions that could repay their loans, overlooking businesses in the greatest difficulty. As a result, wealth did not trickle down as Hoover expected.

4. Hoover’s Opposition to Direct Relief

Although Hoover was not indifferent to people’s suffering, he struggled to move beyond his economic beliefs.

* Direct relief: He refused to support federal spending to provide basic necessities directly to people in need.

* Work relief: He hesitated to expand government assistance through employment programs because he believed it could weaken individual initiative and character.

* Deficits: He feared government budget deficits more than unemployment, which limited his willingness to increase federal spending.

during the Great Depression. President Hoover failed to contain the crisis, while President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal later introduced initiatives intended to reduce unemployment.

Main Idea

Hoover relied on voluntary cooperation, local relief, and limited federal intervention. As the Great Depression worsened, he introduced measures such as public works and the RFC, but his fear of deficits and direct government assistance limited his response. His policies failed to restore economic stability.

What was the result of the Hawley-Smoot Tariff that Congress passed in 1930?

American businesses sold more products overall.

European countries imported more American goods.

European countries refused to import American goods.

-American exports fell when European countries raised their own tariffs.


Farmers’ Protests

Farmers had experienced economic hardship longer than other groups. Even before 1929, agricultural prices had been falling. In the early 1930s, agricultural income fell by 60 percent, and one-third of farmers lost their land.

In the summer of 1932, Milo Reno, an Iowa farmer, created the Farm Holiday Association to organize farmers to withhold their produce from the market to reduce supply and raise prices.

Farmers blocked roads, intimidated farmers who refused to participate by smashing truck windshields and headlights and slashing tires, and tried to prevent foreclosures. When authorities arrested 55 demonstrators in Council Bluffs, thousands of farmers marched on the jail and forced their release. Farmers also deliberately destroyed large quantities of produce.

Result: Despite these radical actions, the Farm Holiday Association failed to achieve its goal of raising agricultural prices.

Urban Protests and the Communist Party

How did the Communist Party respond to the Great Depression?

Although the Communist Party was small, it organized unemployed people and workers to demand jobs, food, and better working conditions. It supported rent strikes by African American tenants in Harlem, defended the Scottsboro Nine, nine young Black men accused of raping two white women, and organized steelworkers and sharecroppers in the South. It also organized seamen and waterfront workers into unions and led strikes.

Ford Factory Protest, 1932: Henry Ford had initially promised to maintain employee wages, but as the Depression worsened after 1930, he reduced them. On March 7, 1932, approximately 3,000 autoworkers, led by Communists, marched to Ford’s River Rouge plant to protest wage cuts. Police killed four protesters, causing widespread outrage.

Bonus Army, 1932: The Bonus Army consisted of World War I veterans who demanded early payment of a bonus promised for their military service. The veterans were scheduled to receive $1,000 in 1945, but many were unemployed and needed the money during the Depression. About 20,000 World War I veterans marched to Washington, D.C., demanding early payment of their $1,000 bonus promised for 1945 because many were unemployed.

Hoover’s Response to the Bonus Army: President Hoover ordered the protesters removed. General Douglas MacArthur used excessive force, and George S. Patton’s troops burned their tents. The event damaged Hoover’s public image.

How did President Hoover respond to the problems and challenges created by the Great Depression?

Hoover initially relied on voluntary cooperation, local governments, and private charities. Although he introduced federal measures, his response remained limited. His decision to remove the Bonus Army through military force further damaged his public image.

2. How did different segments of the American population experience the Depression?

Farmers lost income and land; urban residents faced unemployment and housing difficulties; industrial workers experienced wage cuts and violent responses to protests; and unemployed World War I veterans demanded early payment of their military bonuses.


Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal

When Franklin D. Roosevelt became president in March 1933, he acted quickly to stop the banking panic caused by bank failures and the loss of people’s savings.

Banking Reform and Restoring Public Confidence

  • Bank Holiday (March 1933): Roosevelt temporarily closed banks for several days to stop the panic caused by bank failures and the loss of people’s savings.

  • Emergency Banking Act (1933): Required banks to undergo Treasury Department inspections before reopening, reorganized the banking system, and provided federal funds to rescue banks in danger of closing. Only financially sound banks were allowed to reopen, helping restore public confidence.

  • Glass-Steagall Act (June 1933): Created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), which insured personal savings accounts up to $5,000, protecting depositors if their banks failed. It also separated commercial banks, which handled deposits and loans, from investment banks to limit risky speculation.

  • Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC, 1934): Regulated the stock market and required corporations to provide investors with accurate financial information, helping reduce misleading practices and restore confidence in financial markets.

Significance: These measures expanded federal supervision of the banking system and stock market. Their main goals were to restore public confidence, protect people’s savings, and reduce financial risks.

2. Balancing the Budget and Ending Prohibition

Although Roosevelt regulated banks and the stock market, he was not antibusiness. He still believed in a balanced budget and tried to avoid a $1 billion deficit.

* He cut government workers’ salaries and reduced veterans’ pensions to control federal spending.

* He sought to end Prohibition so the government could collect taxes on alcohol sales and eliminate the cost of enforcing the ban.

* The Twenty-first Amendment (1933) ended the more than decade-long experiment with Prohibition.


Which New Deal agency recruited unmarried men between the ages of eighteen and twenty-five for a two-year stint, putting them to work planting forests; cleaning up beaches, rivers, and parks; and building bridges and dams?

The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA)

-The Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC)

The Security and Exchange Commission (SEC)

The Civil Works Administration (CWA)


A Half Deal for Racial Minorities

1. African Americans and the New Deal

  • Black Cabinet: Informal group of African American advisers who advised Roosevelt on racial issues.

  • Eleanor Roosevelt: Supported African Americans. In 1939, she left the Daughters of the American Revolution after it refused to let Marian Anderson perform at Constitution Hall. Anderson then sang at the Lincoln Memorial.

  • National Negro Congress (NNC): was created in 1935 to fight for racial and economic justice for African Americans. It included civil rights activists, Black intellectuals and religious leaders, labor organizers, Communists, and opponents of fascism. Its president, A. Philip Randolph, was a socialist and leader of the Brotherhood of Pullman Car Porters, was a labor union that fought for better wages, working conditions, and labor rights for Black railroad porters. He resigned NNC in 1940 because he was concerned about the growing influence of Communists.

  • Southern Negro Youth Congress (SNYC), 1937: This interracial organization of young Southerners fought discrimination by organizing boycotts, voter registration drives in Black communities, and labor unions. Its acceptance of Communists led to opposition from the NAACP and other anti-Communist civil rights organizations.

  • 1936 election: Many African American voters switched from the Republican Party to the Democratic Party.

The New Deal offered some opportunities to African Americans, but many programs maintained existing racial discrimination.


3. Native Americans and the Indian New Deal

The Indian Reorganization Act (IRA) of 1934 ended the Dawes Act policy of 1887, which promoted assimilation and contributed to the loss of Native American cultural identity and economic livelihoods. The IRA allowed Native American tribes to govern themselves on reservations, expanded tribal landholdings, and supported Native customs and languages. However, the government still imposed rules that did not always respect tribal traditions. For example, the IRA required majority rule, meaning decisions were made according to what most people wanted, even though some tribes traditionally made decisions by reaching an agreement through consensus.

Main idea: The Indian New Deal shifted federal policy away from assimilation toward Native American self-government and cultural preservation, but it did not solve every problem.

Roosevelt's New Deal faced criticism

from both the right and the left because the Great Depression continued, and unemployment remained around 20% between 1933 and 1935. Some people believed the government was doing too much, while others believed it was not doing enough to help poor Americans.

1. Critics from the Right (Conservatives)

Conservatives opposed the New Deal because they believed it increased government power and spending and threatened capitalism and free enterprise.

2. Critics from the Left

Left-wing critics believed Roosevelt had not done enough to reduce poverty, challenge wealthy business leaders, and improve conditions for struggling Americans.

What was the difference between Roosevelt's critics on the left and right?

Critics on the left thought the president was too close to big business while those on the right thought the president had expanded the government's scope too much.

Francis Townsend — Old-Age Pensions

Francis Townsend — Old-Age Pensions

In 1934, Francis Townsend proposed that the government pay $200 per month to Americans over age 60 if they retired and spent the entire pension each month. He believed that older people retiring would open jobs for younger workers, while spending the pension money would increase demand for goods and help the economy recover. He proposed funding the plan through a 2% transaction or sales tax.

Charles E. Coughlin — Radio Critic

Charles E. Coughlin originally supported Roosevelt but turned against the New Deal in 1934. He founded the National Union for Social Justice and accused Roosevelt of helping greedy bankers instead of ordinary people. Coughlin also spread antisemitic conspiracy theories, using the term “international bankers” as coded language referring to Jews and falsely blaming them for supposedly controlling international finance.


In 1934, Huey P. Long created the Share Our Wealth movement to redistribute wealth from rich Americans to ordinary families. He proposed giving families a $5,000 homestead and a guaranteed annual income of $2,000. To finance the plan, he wanted to impose heavy income and inheritance taxes on wealthy Americans. His movement attracted about seven million members and appealed to farmers, industrial workers, and African Americans, despite being a Southern politician.

Source 22.2 — Mildred Isbell, January 1, 1936

Who was she? A 15-year-old high school student from Alabama living in poverty.

What happened to her?

  • The family was poor, and Mildred feared she would have to leave school because she lacked clothes.

  • She explained that her family was not receiving government relief.

  • She asked Eleanor Roosevelt for old clothes, shoes, coats, and other items so she could continue her education and stay warm.

How did Mildred explain poverty?

She described poverty as a consequence of difficult personal and family circumstances. Her father's departure, her mother's limited resources, and the family's inability to afford necessities prevented her from having the opportunities she wanted.

  • Minnie Hardin: Poverty was partly caused by laziness and people's unwillingness to work. She believed government relief encouraged dependency and was unfair to people who worked hard.

Question 2: If Minnie Hardin were answering Mildred Isbell's letter, what would she say to her?

Minnie would probably argue that people who are able to work should support themselves rather than depend on charity. She might question why Mildred's family needed assistance and argue that everyone should work for what they receive.

6. Put It in Context — How did the New Deal tackle poverty?

The New Deal attempted to reduce poverty and unemployment through relief, recovery, and reform.

  • Relief: Provided immediate assistance to people suffering from the Depression, including jobs and financial support.

  • Recovery: Tried to restart the economy by creating jobs, supporting farmers, and encouraging business activity.

  • Reform: Introduced changes intended to prevent future economic crises and provide greater economic security.

However, the New Deal did not eliminate poverty or unemployment. By 1935, unemployment remained around 20%, which helped fuel criticism from both conservatives and progressives.

What steps did Roosevelt take to stimulate economic recovery and provide relief during his first term?

Roosevelt created New Deal programs to provide jobs and financial assistance, support agriculture, encourage industrial recovery, improve rural electricity access, and reform the banking and financial systems. These programs aimed to help struggling Americans and restore economic activity.


: Congress passed the National Labor Relations Act (Wagner Act)-1935. This law created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), an agency that protected workers’ right to organize labor unions without interference from employers. Union membership increased from fewer than 4 million to more than 10 million workers during the 1930s.

Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO),1935: The AFL consisted mainly of craft unions, which organized workers with specific skills or trades. After the AFL rejected a proposal to organize industrial workers, John L. Lewis and representatives of seven other unions formed the CIO, which recruited workers regardless of race, gender, or region. Many African American workers joined the CIO, although racial discrimination continued.

The AFL preferred to negotiate better wages and working conditions for its members rather than organize all workers in an industry.

Fair Labor Standards Act (1938)

  • Established a minimum wage of 40 cents per hour.

  • Set maximum working hours at 40 hours per week.

Main idea

By the end of the 1930s, labor unions had become a major force in American politics and an important supporter of the New Deal.


Social Security was essentially a promise that the federal government would take care of American citizens who needed help.


The NRA attempted to bring labor and business together to regulate production, wages, prices, and working hours in order to lower unemployment, boost demand, and stimulate industrial production, which would produce economic growth


What was the purpose of the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) created by Herbert Hoover?

To help businesses and boost the economy by extending needed credit


What did the Social Security Act of 1935 provide?

signed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt provided retirement payments for eligible workers beginning at age 65. These payments were funded by payroll taxes paid by employees and employers.

What other benefits did Social Security provide?

  • Unemployment insurance: Financial assistance for people temporarily laid off from work.

  • Aid to the disabled: Assistance for people permanently unable to work.

  • Welfare payments: Financial assistance for dependent children of single parents who lived in poverty.

What were the limitations of Social Security?

  • Excluded workers: Farm, domestic, and laundry workers were excluded. Many were African Americans.

  • Regressive payroll tax: Lower-income workers paid the same percentage of their income as higher-income workers, making the tax proportionally harder on people with less money.

  • Unpaid women's labor: The program did not account for women who stayed home to care for their children without pay.

Why did the law exclude some workers?

The exclusions were largely political. Roosevelt needed support from Southern Democrats, many of whom opposed providing these benefits to Black workers.

5. Why was Social Security important despite its limitations?

It created a lasting relationship between the federal government and American workers. Workers expected the government to protect their retirement benefits and maintain the program.

Roosevelt also believed that collecting payroll taxes would make people feel entitled to their benefits and make it harder for future politicians to eliminate Social Security.


The Dust Bowl was caused by droughts and poor farming practices. Farmers focused on growing wheat and neglected planting trees and grasses, which caused soil erosion. Strong winds carried the dry soil, destroying crops and forcing many farmers to leave their homes and migrate to California in search of jobs.


What did Roosevelt mean when he said "the only thing we have to fear is fear itself"?

Americans needed courage to try new ideas.

He argued that fear of trying new programs was the only impediment to progress.


To what end was the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) created in 1933?

To insure personal savings accounts in U.S. banks

Created by the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933, the FDIC insured and continues to insure personal savings accounts in U.S. banks. In 1933, the limit was $5,000, though that number has increased over time.

https://e-reader-frontend.macmillanlearning.com/?ro=macmillanlearning.com?rid=59742b1e-8fba-4b8c-8874-47aba1e18b8e?req_id=20b275c0-97b7-4179-b017-5290f2dd66e5?custom_cfi=6/386?custom_start=4/2[nan_9781319409746_khZOr0EdFl]?custom_stop=4/2[nan_9781319409746_khZOr0EdFl]/12[nan_9781?custom_vbid=9781319410476?user_id=b779ff80-9e3a-11f1-af7e-8d7270db0f96?rc=a:p?irqa=true?accountType=HE