Chirnside v Fay Notes
Chirnside v Fay: Supreme Court of New Zealand [2006] NZSC 68
Equity and Fiduciary Relationships
- Fiduciary Relationship: Exists when one party can repose trust and confidence in another. This can arise independently of formal agreements or express undertakings.
- Joint Venture: Arises when parties depend on each other to progress toward a common objective and share profits, acting in the interests of all involved.
- A formal agreement or express undertaking isn't required to create a fiduciary relationship.
- Mutual intention to formalize an agreement doesn't prevent an existing fiduciary relationship.
- A fiduciary relationship exists when one party is entitled to repose trust and confidence in the other.
- Joint venture arises when parties depend on each other to progress toward a common objective and to share the profits derived.
- Each party acts in the interests of all parties involved unless there's a reason for no fiduciary relationship to arise.
- An appropriate remedy for breach of fiduciary duty is an account of profits, not what the plaintiff lost, but what the defendant gained.
- The errant fiduciary has the onus to persuade the Court that an allowance should be made.
- Accounting for profits shouldn't lead to unjust enrichment of the plaintiff.
- Work done before the breach, when interests weren't in conflict, reduces the rationale for a sparing approach.
Facts of the Case
- Chirnside and Fay had a prior joint venture in property development.
- They became interested in developing a site; Chirnside took primary responsibility.
- Fay was expected to raise capital.
- Chirnside negotiated and advanced the project but then excluded Fay, developing the site on his own account.
- Chirnside acted as trustee for a company yet to be formed and developed the site through a company he was associated with.
- Chirnside didn't fully explain the position to Fay and falsely claimed he had sold the site.
- Fay requested an account as a partner, then took legal action claiming breach of fiduciary duty and an account of profits.
- The High Court ruled in favor of Fay but allowed Chirnside for disproportionate time spent.
- Valuation issues were disputed, and the High Court awarded Fay less than he believed he was entitled to.
- The Court of Appeal assessed the award due to Fay on the basis of his loss of a chance.
- Both parties appealed to the Supreme Court.
- Chirnside didn't challenge the joint venture finding but appealed against owing fiduciary duties.
- Both parties appealed against the compensation awarded in the Court of Appeal.
Supreme Court Holding
- The parties had embarked on a joint enterprise and had a duty not to act against their joint interest in the project.
- The measure was not what the plaintiff had lost but what the defendant had gained, whether or not that had been realised in monetary terms.
Elias CJ (Dissenting)
- On fiduciary duties of loyalty and disgorgement of profits.
- Differed on the allowance to a defaulting fiduciary who profited from breach of duties.
- The parties owed each other fiduciary duties within the scope of the joint venture.
- The Speights site venture was like a single transaction partnership.
- Not every breach of duty by a fiduciary is a breach of a fiduciary duty; the obligation of a fiduciary is the obligation of loyalty.
- Consistently with it, neither was permitted to place himself in conflict of interest with the venture.
- An account for the profit obtained by the fiduciary was the appropriate remedy.
Account of Profits
- While compensatory damages are measured by what the plaintiff has lost, an account of profits is measured by what the defendant has gained.
- It's not necessary for a profit to have been realised; a monetary award can be ordered to reflect the profit obtained.
- Parker LJ said in Murad v Al-Saraj of the “no-conflict” rule that it is “neither compensatory nor restitutionary”.
- Equity reinforces the duty of fidelity owed by a trustee or fiduciary by requiring him to account for any profits he derives from his office or position.
- The allowance made in the High Court and Court of Appeal for Mr Chirnside’s contribution before July 2000. Was seen as a problem. Because the amount isn't substantiated and seeking to put the parties in the position they would have been in had Mr Chirnside scrupulously discharged his fiduciary obligations, effectively on a quantum meruit basis. The starting point, rather, should have been the rule that fiduciaries may not take unauthorised profit and whether, in conformity with principle, it should be tempered in the circumstances by an allowance to Mr Chirnside.
Allowance to Chirnside
- Recompense for skill and work if the profit is properly attributable to his efforts, as Boardman v Phipps established.
- An allowance is claim on a quantum meruit basis, seeking the very recompense he might have achieved by agreement if he had faithfully discharged his fiduciary responsibilities
Gault J.
- The term “joint venture” can cover many forms of arrangement, not all of which necessarily will give rise to fiduciary obligations.
- The parties antecedent profit-sharing arrangements are relevant.
Tipping J.
*The points of the case:
- The nature of the relationship.
- Did the relationship give rise to fiduciary duties?
- General observations on joint ventures.
- The loss of a chance issues.
- The allowance issues.
- The vacant space issue.
- The capitalisation rate.
- Revised calculations.
- Formal orders.
- Costs.
Relationship of Fiduciary Kind
- A relationship of a fiduciary kind, or a fiduciary relationship, is speaking of a relationship which gives rise to fiduciary obligations, irrespective of what may be the principal nature of the relationship or what other obligations may also arise from it.
Situations That give Rise to Fiduciary Duties
- The relationship is of a kind which, by its very nature, is recognised as being inherently fiduciary . Relations include the relationships of solicitor and client, trustee and beneficiary, principal and agent, and doctor and patient.
- The traditional categories, the implied acceptance rationale may be apposite and in others, of the particular kind, the imposition rationale may be preferable.
The loss of a Chance Issue
- Key difference between the way in which the High Court approached the question of monetary relief and the method adopted by the Court of Appeal can be stated quite simply: It is the difference between damages based on a notional disgorgement of profits made, but not realised, on the one hand, and compensation for being deprived of the chance of participating in a profitable venture, on the other.
The Allowance Issue
- In this area of the case William Young J relied on the decision of the High Court in Estate Realties and that of the High Court of Australia in Warman International.
- The principle which has developed from Boardman v Phipps and subsequent cases; is that there is a presumptive requirement that the errant fiduciary disgorge all profits made by dint of the breach. There is room, however, for the Court to exercise its discretion to allow the errant fiduciary some measure of allowance or recompense for effort, skill and enterprise in making those profits, if it would be unjust not to do so. All the relevant circumstances must be taken into account. The more reprehensible the fiduciary’s conduct, the less inclined the Court may be to make any allowance or to be liberal in the amount awarded. The essence of the exercise is to define fairly the profit for which the fiduciary is required to account.
- There is a presumptive requirement that the errant fiduciary disgorge all profits made by dint of the breach.
- The Court can allow the errant fiduciary some recompense for effort, skill, and enterprise if it would be unjust not to do so.
- All relevant circumstances must be considered.
- There can be allowances have been made in circumstances where the defaulting fiduciary has not been as blameless. The Court will “look at the whole situation in the round”