9-15 English notes
Rhetorical Appeals and Persuasion in Public Discourse
Persuasion is about convincing people, which works differently than explaining facts logically. People are often persuaded by emotions rather than reason. Media uses tools like dramatic music, visuals, edited video, and emotional facial expressions to sway an audience instead of presenting plain facts.
Aristotle divided persuasion into four core appeals:
Ethos: An appeal to credibility or authority. For instance, during debates on Artificial Intelligence (AI), computer scientists urged caution, while political figures like Donald Trump called concerns a hoax. Deciding who to trust depends on whether a person respects political authority or technical expertise.
Pathos: An appeal to emotions, mood, and feelings using music, tone, or strong speech.
Logos: An appeal to logic, evidence, and reasoning. Logic works as long as the facts stay true. For example, people once logically believed the Earth was flat based on what they could see, but they changed their mind when new evidence proved the Earth is round. Similarly, school mask rules changed as scientists learned more about virus transmission.
Kairos: The context, timing, or situational background of a message. For example, Neil deGrasse Tyson's video Science in America was made about to \,years ago (before the pandemic). While Tyson is an expert in astrophysics, his arguments about history or social science should be looked at more carefully since they are outside his main domain.
Scientific Method, Emergent Truth, and Democratic Governance
America's growth into a global power was driven by scientific innovation. However, public debate today shows a growing struggle to tell the difference between verified scientific consensus and baseless claims.
When non-experts reject science in government, it harms democracy. Examples of scientific denial include:
Demanding that public schools present evolution as just an unverified opinion rather than established fact.
Public skepticism toward routine childhood vaccines.
Government or military bans on Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs).
Dismissing human-caused climate change.
The scientific method is a step-by-step process used to discover objective facts:
A scientist creates a hypothesis to explain an observation.
The hypothesis is tested through experiments.
Initial findings are published.
Independent research teams review the methods and run their own experiments.
When independent experiments get matching results, an emergent truth is formed.
An emergent scientific truth is a fact that exists regardless of personal belief or opinion. Physical equations like mass-energy equivalence:
remain true no matter what anyone thinks. Once a scientific truth is proven—like global warming—public debate can move from denying facts to creating policy solutions, such as carbon credits, tariffs, or technology subsidies.
Biological Complexity, Physical Laws, and Ecological Systems
Physical sciences study non-living matter that follows unchanging physical laws everywhere in the universe. Fundamental elements like elemental oxygen () behave the exact same way anywhere in space.
In contrast, biological systems are dynamic, complex, and interrelated:
Snapping Turtles (Chelydra serpentina): Aquatic reptiles that change as they grow. Cute baby turtles develop into large predators with long tails, living in places like the Hudson River.
Cellar Spiders: Micro-adapted spiders that live in enclosed, dark places like basements and trash cans.
Coral Reefs and Sponges: Living structures made of millions of small organisms working together like a complex city.
All multicellular organisms depend on microscopic organisms working together:
Human Gut Microbiome: Millions of gut bacteria break down nutrients and keep humans alive.
Neurological Axis: Microbe populations across the body directly affect brain chemistry and thinking.
Commensal Ectoparasites: Microscopic mites (like Demodex facial mites) live in human hair follicles and eyebrows as part of the natural microbiome.
Social Truth, Epistemological Frameworks, and Philosophical History
Social truth deals with human relationships, society, and cultural values. Unlike physical facts, social truths change over time and depend on culture. Ideas like freedom mean different things depending on a person's country, wealth, or status.
Philosophers provide tools to evaluate social truth:
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844–1900)
Friedrich Nietzsche was a German philosopher who suffered from severe migraines and wrote about individual thought:
Linguistic Deception: Nietzsche argued that words are arbitrary human metaphors that flatten real experience into artificial labels.
Skepticism of Social Truth: Institutions use words to create comfortable illusions because most people cannot handle raw reality.
The Übermensch (Superman): Only strong individuals can look past societal illusions to confront unvarnished truth.
The Will to Power: Nietzsche believed all human actions and systems of thought are driven by a desire to assert influence and power.
Subjective Experience: Direct personal experience is the most reliable guide for an individual.
Friedrich Engels (1820–1895)
Friedrich Engels co-wrote The Communist Manifesto with Karl Marx. He studied factory conditions in Manchester, showing how workplace environments caused higher disease rates and physical disabilities among workers.
In Truth: Relative and Absolute, Engels divided truth into two categories:
Absolute Truth: Fixed facts established with near-total certainty, mostly found in hard sciences like physics.
Relative Truth: Ideas about human society that change over time as economies and social structures evolve.
Temporal Context: Earth is very old, roughly:
Human history makes up only a tiny fraction of that time, so social theories must adapt as material conditions change.
Pseudoscience, Social Sciences, and Contemporary Case Studies
Methodological tools help tell the difference between real science and fake claims.
Identifying Pseudoscience
Pseudoscience refers to practices or claims presented as scientific that lack real evidence and testing:
Phrenology: An old practice claiming that measuring bumps on the human skull could predict personality traits or criminal behavior.
Scientific Racism: Fraudulent claims used in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries to justify oppression and genocide.
Pseudosocial Science: Using scientific terms to make fake sociological or psychological claims without peer-reviewed research.
Contemporary Social Science Case Studies
Social Media and Youth Mental Health: Meta (parent company of Facebook and Instagram) faced major legal cases resulting in a settlement valued at:
These cases studied how algorithms are designed to capture attention and cause digital addiction in young users.
Biological Embedding of Socioeconomic Factors: Research in early childhood brain development shows how stress, sleep issues, and poverty during early years (ages to ) physically alter brain structure, embedding social inequality into human biology.
Psychology of Conspiracy Theories: Researcher Karen Douglas showed that people adopt conspiracy theories not because they lack intelligence, but to satisfy psychological needs for certainty, safety, and control in an unpredictable world.