Topic 9

The Origin of Species

Two Types of Evolutionary Change

  • Selection acting within a species causes changes in that species.

Types of Evolutionary Change

  • Anagenesis: The gradual evolution of a species without branching.

  • Cladogenesis: Branching evolution, where one ancestral species evolves into two or more species.

Anagenesis and Biodiversity

  • Anagenesis alone does not produce biodiversity.

Speciation

  • Speciation (Cladogenesis): One ancestral species evolves into two reproductively isolated descendant species.

The Biological Species Concept

  • Definition of a Species: A group of organisms that commonly interbreed in the wild and do not interbreed with other similar species.

Reproductive Isolation
  • Importance of Reproductive Isolation: Critical for maintaining species integrity and allowing independent evolution.

  • Types of Reproductive Isolation:

    • Pre-zygotic (before fertilization occurs):

    • Examples include:

      • Different mating displays (e.g., jumping spiders).

      • Different habitats (e.g., aquatic vs terrestrial garter snakes).

    • Post-zygotic (after fertilization occurs):

    • Hybrid inviability (e.g., North American frogs).

    • Hybrid sterility (e.g., mules).

Mechanisms of Divergence

  • Gene Flow: The amount of divergence between populations relies on the balance between selection and gene flow.

  • In the absence of gene flow, populations may diverge more dramatically.

Limitations of Biological Species Concept

  • Only Applicable to Sexual Organisms: The concept primarily applies to those that reproduce sexually.

  • Challenges in Demonstration: Requires substantial work to prove reproductive isolation.

  • Not Always Effective:

    • Example of the Herring Gull and Lesser Black-backed Gull: No interbreeding in the UK, but occasional interbreeding on the continent.

Alternative Species Concepts

  • Physiological, Morphological, and Ecological Species Concepts: These concepts provide different perspectives on what constitutes a species.

  • Phylogenetic Species Concept: Focuses on the evolutionary history and relationships among species.

Case Study: New Species of Elephant

  • Genetic studies on various elephants reveal differences:

    • Asian Elephants and African Forest Elephants.

    • African Savannah Elephants.

  • Genetic divergence indicated (e.g., 0.001 changes noted).

Imperfections in Species Concepts

  • No Single Species Concept is Perfect: Each concept has limitations and applicability issues.

Evolution of Reproductive Isolation

  • Reproductive isolation evolves mainly through geographic isolation in the Allopatric Model of Speciation. (a theory that proposes new species arise when a single species is split into two or more geographically isolated populations)

  • Steps in Allopatric Speciation:

    • Step 1: Initial population in a single habitat.

    • Step 2: Geographic barrier splits the population.

    • Step 3: Divergence occurs in isolation due to lack of gene flow.

    • Step 4: Populations may meet but are now reproductively isolated.

Example of Allopatric Speciation: Galapagos Islands Finches

  • Various finch species demonstrate adaptations and morphological differences within geographic isolation facilitated by environmental pressures.

    • Small insectivorous finch, large insectivorous finch, vegetarian tree finch, woodpecker finch, and more, each adapted to different ecological niches.

Sympatric Speciation

  • Speciation can also occur without geographic isolation, known as sympatric speciation.

  • Typically more difficult due to ongoing gene flow.

  • Example: Rhagoletis fruit flies, which adapted by invading new habitats (hawthorn to apple) leading to temporal isolation in mating.

Conclusion on Speciation Mechanisms

  • Periods of geographic isolation can facilitate the evolution of reproductive isolation.

  • Allopatric speciation is likely the main mechanism of speciation in animals, while sympatric speciation, though common in plants (e.g., polyploidy), is rare in animals.

  • Sympatric speciation may occur under unusual ecological conditions, but proving it remains challenging.