MAOR212: Intro to Economic Development 2

Economic Development Overview

  • Transition into the economic development lecture.

  • Importance of historical context in understanding contemporary Maori Economic issues, especially for assignments.

Case Study: Naitahu

  • Discussed as a case study for settlement claims and iwi structure.

  • Reflection on who is responsible for addressing Maori development issues today:

    • Key players include the Crown, iwi, hapu, community groups, and individuals.

Lecture Focus: Historical Context of Maori Economic Development

  • Discussion of five distinct phases in Maori economic history:

    1. Pre-settler and early contact periods

    2. Land loss and resource alienation

    3. Urbanization

    4. Hui Taumata (decade of Maori development)

    5. Present economic conditions

Pre-Contact Economy

  • Brief overview of main products cultivated/traded by Maori:

    • Mahingakai: Traditional food gathering practices (includes seafood, titi).

    • Marakai: Garden-grown food (kai).

  • Producers and distributors were typically whanau (extended family) or hapu (sub-tribe).

  • Mention of pounamu (greenstone) as a traded item.

  • Maori exercised tino rangatiratanga (self-determination) during this time.

Early Contact Economy

  • Arrival of whalers, sealers, early traders, and missionaries.

  • Main products during this time included food, tools, and resources.

  • New trade opportunities emerged; whanau and hapu remained key producers and distributors.

  • Example products: flax and potatoes.

Early Treaty Era Economy

  • Discussion of the period post-Treaty signing in 1840 leading to land wars in the 1860s.

  • Key economic activities included fishing and milling.

  • Urban centers like Auckland and Nelson emerged as significant markets for Maori products.

  • Continued emphasis on exercising tino rangatiratanga in trade.

  • Quote from 2015: Historians highlight the challenges of indigenous economies under capitalism.

    • Maori adapted to capitalism while maintaining cooperative elements.

Asset Register Example

  • Example of an asset register from Matatua in 1857, including:

    • 5,000 pigs, thousands of crops, 43 vessels, 900 canoes, water mills, and horses.

  • Summary of Maori economy complexity by 1857.

Capitalism vs Maori Systems

  • Duane Champagne's points on indigenous reinterpretation of capitalism.

  • Hazel Petrie's argument about Maori becoming highly commercialized during the settler era.

  • Discussion on the false narratives of Maori being unproductive.

Characteristics of Maori Economy

  • Description of a Maori economy based on collective capitalism:

    • Pooling labor and resources, tribal ownership, and collective decision-making.

  • Observations of progressive growth in assets and trading success.

Land Loss and Resource Alienation

  • Discussion on rapid land-loss images from 1860 to 1939:

    • Consequences on the Maori economy and culture.

  • Shift from Maori providing goods to needing to rely on European economies.

  • Crown's preemption policy (1840-1865) inhibiting Maori land sales.

  • Outlined repercussions of land wars and legislation for Maori land acquisition.

  • By 1939, Maori retained only 1% of the South Island and 9% of the North Island.

Urban Migration (Urban Drift)

  • Definition of urban migration: Movement of Maori from rural to urban areas.

  • Post-World War II context:

    • Government incentives for migration into urban areas for work.

    • Rise of Maori urban population from 10% to 60% between 1940-1963.

  • Employment in unskilled labor sectors in urban areas, implications for Maori traditions and structures.

  • Government policies encouraging rural to urban migration for economic recovery post-war.

  • Education and training schemes facilitated this migration.

  • Establishment of Maori ball stores to help urban Maori integrate.

Economic Context of Urbanization

  • Characteristics of jobs held by urban Maori:

    • Low wage, minimal career progression, physically demanding labor.

  • Discussion of structural inequities affecting Maori in urban environments:

    • Need for stable employment, financial security, and housing.

Government Policy Considerations

  • Government framework based on the principle of "one nation, one people" aimed at assimilation:

    • Risks of erasing Maori culture and identity.

  • Introduction of policy on pepper potting to encourage integration of Maori families across urban areas.

Effects of Urban Migration

  • Examination of benefits and challenges:

    • Some Maori thrived in the city, maintained cultural links, while others suffered loss of cultural identity.

  • Development of urban marae as cultural centers for pan-Maori community interaction.

  • Disparities and economic inequalities became increasingly evident in urban settings, particularly in poverty-
    specific areas.

HUN Report

  • 1961 report commissioned by the Labour Party on Maori disparities:

    • Suggested remedies based on increased assimilation into Eurocentric societal standards.

    • Categorization of Maori populations into three groups with implicit biases:

    1. Detribalized minority

    2. Main body adapted cultural integration

    3. Minority living in primitive conditions.

  • Critique of the report reflecting the systemic neglect of issues.

Final Thoughts and Reflections

  • Importance of addressing economic disparities and fostering positive pathways for future generations.

  • Students encouraged to reflect on main takeaways.

  • Look forward to upcoming lectures on contemporary Maori economic development and broader social developments.

  • Reminder on online quiz details and final session with Maya.