CH 10

WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS

  • The Correctional Service of Canada (CSC)
      - Supervises a significant number of offenders.
      - Approximately two-thirds are in institutions; the remainder lives in communities.
      - Average stay in a provincial correctional centre: about one month.
      - Federal prisoners are sentenced to two years or longer; half are sentenced to five years or longer (Public Safety Canada, 2022).

CHALLENGES ENCOUNTERED BY INMATES

  • Difficulties in helping inmates survive lengthy prison terms due to various deprivations:
      - Limited contact with family and friends.
      - Restrictions on accessing desirable goods/services (e.g., internet, home-cooked meals).
      - Constant threat of violence.
      - Forced celibacy.
      - Lack of self-determination; daily activities directed by correctional personnel (Sykes, 1998).
  • Harsh conditions of confinement in federal prisons:
      - Many share cells originally designed for one person.
      - Longer sentences provide opportunities for rehabilitation.
      - Success of ex-prisoners on parole suggests CSC can safely reintegrate offenders into society.

MEDIA REPRESENTATIONS OF PRISON LIFE

  • Popular culture (e.g., movies and TV shows like "Orange is the New Black") often portrays exaggerated and violent aspects of prison life.
  • Limitations of entertainment-based knowledge:
      - Most depictions highlight prison misconduct but overlook boredom, despair, and loneliness.
      - Canadian federal prisons face these issues, despite spending more per inmate than many other nations.

PRISON MISCONDUCT

  • Defined as violations of correction facility rules.
      - Classifications:
        - Major misconduct (e.g., assault).
        - Minor misconduct (e.g., being in unauthorized areas, possessing contraband).

COMMON GOALS OF CORRECTIONAL FACILITIES

  • Provide a safe and secure environment.
  • Challenges in achieving safety due to inmates typically having:
      - Long-term addiction problems.
      - Mental and physical health disorders.
      - Unemployment history.
      - Lack of stability in their lives.
      - Unhealthy family relationships.
  • Research indicates success in overcoming these obstacles through correctional interventions that reduce recidivism and misconduct (Bonta & Andrews, 2007).
  • Focused on addressing unmet psychological needs to mitigate risks posed by inmates.

HISTORICAL OVERVIEW OF CANADIAN PENITENTIARIES

  • Canadian penitentiaries have existed for less than two centuries, with the first established in the 1830s.
  • Shift from physical punishments to emphasis on rehabilitation as attitudes toward human life evolved.
      - Example: Eastern State Penitentiary (ESP) founded in 1829 as the first penitentiary.
      - ESP’s design:
        - Wheel structure with cells along hallways.
        - Silent system where inmates were in solitary confinement and forbidden to speak.
        - High mental health problems due to isolation.

THE DEVELOPMENT OF CANADA’S PRISON SYSTEM

  • Prior to Confederation (1867), provincial responsibility for corrections.
      - Kingston Penitentiary modeled on the ESP design.
      - Reported prisoner abuse led to inquiry in 1892 exposing extreme brutality.
  • Population growth and crime rates increased need for federal prisons:
      - By 1888, the Penitentiary Act transferred oversight to federal authorities.
      - Established several federal prisons, often in rural areas, operating as closed systems.

CHANGES IN CORRECTIONAL PRACTICES

  • Corrections and Conditional Release Act (1992) emphasized humane treatment:
      - Established minimum conditions for confinement.
      - Introduced parole (began in 1899) with community reintegration objectives.
      - Frequent inquiries and oversight have aimed to reform the penal system, particularly highlighted by the Archambault Commission.

CHARACTERISTICS OF THE PRISON POPULATION

  • CSC supervises approximately 23,000 federal offenders; two-thirds in prisons.
  • Demographics of inmate population include racial and gender factors, with particular attention to:
      - Indigenous offenders (one-quarter of the population).
      - Women offenders (higher health and psychological care needs).
      - Aging prisoners increasingly require specialized care.

SPECIAL NEEDS INMATES

  • Chief concerns for certain populations:
      - Indigenous offenders require culturally responsive interventions.
      - Pregnant inmates face challenges; mother-child programs have been developed.
      - Radicalization has been a noted issue with non-violent offenders led to extremist views.
      - Mental health issues prevalent among inmates need targeted support.

CORRECTIONAL PROGRAMS AND EFFICIENCIES

  • Prison programs focused on reducing recidivism through education, vocational training, and psychological therapy.
  • CORCAN agency established to provide job training in industries to enhance employability.
  • Various treatment programs address needs like anger management, substance abuse, and rehabilitation for specific offender types.

VIOLENCE AND SAFETY IN PRISONS

  • Canadian prisons report higher incidents of violence compared to others.
      - System struggles to balance safety and rehabilitation.
  • Use of segregation correlates with increased violence rates; mental health issues exacerbated by isolation.

ADVOCACY AND REFORM IN PRISONS

  • Community organizations and federal oversight play pivotal roles in advocating for prisoner rights and welfare.
  • The role of the Correctional Investigator as an independent reviewer of complaints and practices:
      - Involvement in monitoring serious incidents and recommending changes.

PAROLE SYSTEM OVERVIEW

  • The parole system aims for successful community reintegration, closely monitored by parole officers.
  • Key aspects of parole include:
      - Distinction between parole and statutory release.
      - Success rates higher in parole than statutory releases due to structured community support.

CIRCLES OF SUPPORT AND ACCOUNTABILITY

  • COSA program assists high-risk sexual offenders transitioning to the community, showing effective recidivism reduction through community support.

BARREIERS TO RE-INTEGRATION

  • Significant challenges include poor job prospects and housing, collateral consequences of criminal records, and stigma.
  • Record suspensions can help improve employment opportunities for individuals with criminal records.

SUMMARY

  • The evolution of corrections showcases a balance of safety, rehabilitation, and addressing the needs of various inmate populations has progressed despite ongoing challenges.