Oh, Grow Up! Generational Grumbling and the New Life Stage of Emerging Adulthood

Introduction

  • The article addresses the negative perception of young people today.
  • It questions whether this perception is based on evidence or is a myth.
  • Trzesniewski and Donnellan's (2010) research indicates that claims of a decline in young people are exaggerated.
  • High school seniors in the early 21st century are similar to those in the late 1970s across various measures.
  • The author aims to provide an additional explanation for the negative perception of young people.

Emerging Adulthood as a New Life Stage

  • The period beyond high school has changed significantly.
  • Young people now enter adult roles later, typically in their late 20s.
  • A new life stage called emerging adulthood has emerged, spanning from the late teens to the mid-20s.
  • This new life stage is a key reason for the negative perception of young people.

Reasons for Negative Views of Emerging Adults

  • The delayed entry into adult roles is misinterpreted as selfishness.
  • Identity explorations are misinterpreted as widespread suffering.
  • The search for identity-based work is seen as being uninterested in "real" work.
  • High hopes for the future are misinterpreted as grandiosity.

Selfish or Self-Focused?

  • The timing of entering adult roles has changed rapidly over the past three decades.
  • In 1976, the median marriage age in the United States was between 22 and 23 years old.
  • By 2006, the median marriage age had risen to nearly 27.
  • College participation has also increased, especially for women.
  • From 1976 to 2006, the number of young women entering college after high school doubled.
  • By 2006 two thirds of women entered college after high school and 57% of American undergraduates were female
  • These changes have led to the emergence of emerging adulthood.
  • Older generations may apply outdated norms to emerging adults, leading to misinterpretations.
  • Emerging adulthood is a self-focused age with minimal social control and greater independence.
  • Emerging adults are less egocentric than adolescents and better at understanding others' perspectives.
  • They realize that the self-directed action is temporary.
  • The majority enter long-term work, marriage, or parenthood by age 30.

Suffering or Identity Explorations?

  • Identity explorations are now more prominent during emerging adulthood than adolescence.
  • Exploring options in love and work can be exciting but also disorienting.
  • These identity challenges can be misinterpreted as suffering.
  • The "quarterlife crisis" idea reflects this perception.
  • Studies show that well-being, self-esteem, and life satisfaction generally increase during emerging adulthood.
  • Serious psychopathology is rare, and most experience identity challenges positively.

Slackers or Seekers of Identity-Based Work?

  • Emerging adults have high expectations for work and seek identity-based jobs.
  • They want work to be enjoyable and align with their talents and interests.
  • Older adults may view this as unrealistic or selfish.
  • Emerging adults may change jobs frequently if they are not satisfied.
  • This could be seen as asserting employee interests.

Grandiosity or Youthful Optimism?

  • Emerging adults have high hopes for the future, which may be labeled as "narcissism."
  • They generally believe that life will be kind to them.
  • They may face job changes, love upheavals, and financial difficulties, but remain optimistic.
  • They aspire to find the right job, love partner, and financial stability.
  • Expectations for educational attainment have increased, reflecting economic changes.
  • It is realistic to recognize the increasing economic reward for postsecondary education.
  • Emerging adults adjust their dreams as they approach 30, adapting to reality.

Conclusion

  • Negative portrayals of young Americans are not based on evidence that they are worse than previous generations.
  • The rise of emerging adulthood has caused a mismatch in expectations.
  • Emerging adulthood may become a valued life stage for identity explorations.
  • It is likely to be a permanent addition to the life course in industrialized and developing countries.
  • Trends such as widespread postsecondary education and delayed marriage are expected to continue.
  • Emerging adulthood is here to stay.