P&O 7
Understanding Culture
Definition of Culture: The shared values, beliefs, and social forms provide standards of behavior within institutions and societies; represents the "character" or "essence" of a social group (e.g., organization, nation).
Challenges in Understanding Culture
Recognizing and understanding one's own culture can be particularly challenging due to ingrained perspectives and biases.
Levels of Culture
National Culture: This includes the overarching cultural elements associated with a specific nation.
Industry Culture: The culture that is common within a particular industry sector.
Organizational Culture: The specific culture that develops within an organization, influenced by its unique values, practices, and environment.
Organizational Subcultures: Smaller, distinct cultures that may exist within a larger organizational culture, influenced by department or team dynamics.
Cultural Reflection: Singapore vs. France / Home Country
Personal Reflection Questions:
What cultural differences stood out between Singapore and France or your home country?
What did you find novel, strange, or different?
What behaviors or feelings did you adopt as a result of these cultural differences?
What behaviors or feelings became inappropriate or were discarded?
Dimensions of National Culture
Power Distance: The societal acceptance of inequality in power and influence. Countries with high power distance emphasize differences in rank and hierarchy, while those with low power distance promote equality among individuals.
Power Distance Index: An index measuring the power distance prevalent in various countries, categorized as follows:
1-20: Very Low Power Distance
21-40: Low Power Distance
41-60: Moderate Power Distance
61-80: High Power Distance
81-100: Very High Power Distance
Interpretation of Power Distance:
Low Power Distance Characteristics:
Subordinates are comfortable questioning superiors.
Interactions are more equal and democratic.
Decentralized institutions.
High Power Distance Characteristics:
Power holders often face little challenge or questioning.
Clear social strata exist with limited upward mobility.
Power is centralized.
Individualism vs. Collectivism
Individualism: Focuses on personal independence and defines the self primarily by internal attributes (Markus & Kitayama, 1991).
Key Characteristics:
Individual unique identity.
Emphasizes autonomy and self-influence.
Collectivism: Focuses on interdependence and defines the self mainly by relationships and roles (Markus & Kitayama, 1991).
Key Characteristics:
Relational identity.
Adjusts self based on social connections.
High Individualism vs. High Collectivism
High Individualism Characteristics:
Emphasizes personal rights, goals, and freedom.
Self-identity is internally driven.
Encourages personal accountability for success and failure.
High Collectivism Characteristics:
Emphasizes group interests, harmony, and stability.
Identity is relationally driven, based on group memberships.
Shared responsibility for group outcomes.
Blame Attribution in Cultural Contexts
Independent Cultures:
People attribute behavior to individual traits; blame is placed on “bad apples.”
Interdependent Cultures:
People attribute behavior to situational context; blame is placed on “bad barrels.”
Communication Styles: High Context vs. Low Context
High Context Communication:
Indirect, subtle, and relies heavily on non-verbal cues.
Implicit messages often conveyed through relationships or shared understanding.
Uses metaphorical language and storytelling.
Low Context Communication:
Direct and explicit communication style; clear and straightforward.
Minimal reliance on non-verbal cues.
Intended to be understood regardless of cultural background.
Examples of High vs. Low Context Communication
High Context Expressions:
“That could be difficult.” (implying complexity)
“It’s quite chilly in here today.” (indirect request to change temperature)
Low Context Expressions:
“That is not possible.” (clear refusal)
“I require assistance with this task.” (direct request)
Avoiding Miscommunication Strategies
For Low Context Communicators in High Context Cultures:
Avoid frustration due to indirect communication; observe non-verbal hints.
Employ open-ended questions rather than demanding yes/no answers.
For High Context Communicators in Low Context Cultures:
Avoid intimidation from straightforward communication; state impossibilities clearly to avoid misinterpretation.
Confirm understanding through direct questioning and written communication.
The Role of Culture in Organizations
Functions of Culture in Organizations:
Acts as the social glue that maintains internal coherence through shared values.
Provides a framework through which management influences employees’ behavior, thoughts, and emotions.
Emphasizes the slow, deliberate effort required to cultivate or change organizational culture.
Dissecting the Structure of Culture
Three Layers of Culture:
Artifacts: Visible and tangible elements observable by outsiders, e.g., physical layout, dress code, logos.
Espoused Values: Written and verbal declarations that reflect what an organization stands for, including its priorities and goals.
Assumptions: Core, unspoken beliefs or attitudes that drive and justify visible artifacts and espoused values.
Cultural Interpretation and Misunderstanding
Culture shapes how individuals interpret behaviors and events; often an unconscious influence.
Misunderstandings can occur due to varying underlying values and assumptions between different cultures.
The Importance of Consistency Across Cultures
Independent Perspective:
Consistency between spoken words and actions is crucial; inconsistency breeds mistrust.
Interdependent Perspective:
Context matters; inconsistency might serve a relational purpose, preserving harmony.
Strong Culture Dynamics
Elements of a Strong Culture:
Consensus: Do people agree on the values?
Intensity: Do people care deeply about those values?
Advantages:
Strong cultures lead to improved performance, coordination, and employee commitment.
A robust culture can predict consistent performance but may struggle to adapt in changing circumstances.
Coordinating Through Strong Culture
Strong cultures can lead to reduced coordination losses as employees share common values and direction.
Quote from Brian Chesky (CEO of Airbnb): "The stronger the culture, the less corporate process a company needs. When the culture is strong, you can trust everyone to do the right thing."
Ethical Dilemmas in Strong Cultures
Example of a strong culture leading to unethical practices; employees might manipulate sales targets in violation of ethical standards due to pressure from corporate culture.
Conclusion on Culture's Role in Organizational Fit
Person-Organization Fit (P-O Fit): Alignment between a person's values and those of the organization leads to greater job satisfaction, enhanced commitment, and lowered turnover rates.