wk 11 emotional, social and communicative brain III

Self-Referential Processing

  • Definition of self-referential processing: The cognitive process of evaluating traits that relate to oneself.

  • Findings: Participants show superior recall of self-related traits, termed the "self-referential effect."

  • fMRI shows activation (increased BOLD signal) in the medial prefrontal cortex, indicating self-referential processing.

  • Medial prefrontal cortex: Increased signal during self-referential tasks compared to third-person judgments and control tasks.

Core Self and Egocentric Reference Frame

  • Theory by Antonio DiMarzio: Core self is a stable, self-aware sense of identity compared to the environment. (Conceptualisation of the self in comparison to the environment is the  “core self”

  • Medial regions: such as the right inferior parietal cortex, contribute to an egocentric reference frame representing the body in space.

Neuroanatomy of the Social Brain

  • Medial prefrontal cortex.

  • Cingulate cortex: Discussed in relation to emotions.

  • Medial and lateral aspects of parietal cortex.

  • Orbitofrontal cortex and ventrolateral prefrontal cortex included.

  • Newer regions: Temporoparietal junction (TPJ) and superior temporal sulcus relevant for social cognition.

Default Mode Network (DMN)

  • Self-referential processing may be the brain's default state when at rest.

  • Definition of the DMN: Network of brain regions more active during rest than during task performance.

  • Hypothesis: DMN performs self-referential processing in the absence of explicit tasks.

Theory of Mind (ToM)

  • Definition: The ability to attribute mental states, beliefs, intents, and knowledge to others, often referred to as "mind reading."

  • theory of mind develops at age four to five and continues to mature as children grow older, impacting their social interactions and empathy.

Brain Studies in Theory of Mind

  • Two methods to study ToM:

    • False belief stories, like the Sally-Anne task. (marble task) where children must determine where a character would look for a hidden object, revealing their understanding of others' beliefs.

    • False photograph task (apple falling from a tree): Similar narrative without mental state inference, serves as a control task.

  • Brain study results: Right TPJ activated during processing of false belief stories, indicating its role in ToM.

Expanded Network for Theory of Mind

  • Beyond TPJ, other brain regions are involved in processing mental states:

    • Posterior superior temporal sulcus (PSTS): Involved in action perception and biological motion.

    • Medial prefrontal cortex: Involved in understanding stable preferences and personality traits.

    • Temporoparietal junction: thinking about beliefs

Biological Motion Recognition

  • Definition of biological motion: Motion patterns that human brains easily recognise (e.g., walking, dancing).

  • Point light walker demonstration: Recognising an agent through patterns of movement despite lacking physical form.

  • Activation of the superior temporal sulcus during observation of biological motion.

Eye Gaze as a Social Signal

  • Importance of eye gaze in social interactions:

    • Expected (congruent) vs. unexpected (incongruent) eye gaze influences interpretation of social cues.

  • Activation differences in PSTS in response to gaze congruence.

  • Implication for autism spectrum disorder (ASD): ASD is often characterised by abnormal gaze behaviour and difficulties in understanding mental states.

  • Altered fixation patterns in ASD compared to neurotypical individuals, particularly in eye-gaze regions.

Framework for Understanding the Social Brain

  • Conceptual framework proposed by Rith and Frith (2010) based on social survival scenarios (e.g., stranded on an alien planet).

  • Questions about the intention and nature of encountered entities.

  • Biological motion as a key signal for distinguishing agents in social perceptions

Inference of Intentions and Agency

  • Once entities are identified as agents, questions arise regarding their intentions and actions.

  • Prediction of movements based on agency can be helpful; the brain uses an internal model to anticipate actions.

  • The role of prediction errors: Updating predictions based on observed actions and refining understanding of other agency.

  • detecting and differentiating different types of biological motion: relevant for identifying predators and conspecifics, helps in adapting social behaviour and enhancing communication strategies.

  • moving agents are interpreted as having goals and achieving these in a rational way to cause events

  • contingent actions of two agents are perceived as one causing the other (even for inanimate objects)

Layering Understandings of Intent and Knowledge

  • The role of ToM in inferring beliefs and knowledge about other agents.

  • Enhanced abilities for predicting behaviour when combining observations of biological motion with mental state inferences.

  • Brain regions involved in these processes: TPJ and medial prefrontal cortex in particular.

Summary of Key Points

  • The social brain distinguishes between self and others through action, space (bodily reference frame), and evaluative judgements

  • Important regions: Medial prefrontal cortex, medial parietal cortex, right inferior parietal cortex, and posterior superior temporal sulcus.

  • Biological motion and eye gaze recognition are critical components in social interactions.

  • Understanding and inferring intentions from movements and mental states are essential aspects of social cognition.

  • Mentalising network includes the temporal parietal junction and medial prefrontal cortex

Reflection Quiz notes:

  • The cingulate cortex shows increased activation for one’s own as well as another’s pain

  • False photograph stories reflect mental state inferences component of Theory of Mind

  • The term mentalising refers to drawing inferences with respect to the mental states of others

  • A mirror neuron fires during self-referential processing (observing ones self in the mirror)

  • The social brain and mirror system are linked to empathy via covert imitation of actions and emotions of others

  • Self-referential processing is associated with the medial prefrontal cortex, a region that overlaps anatomically with the default mode network

  • Activation in the temporo-parietal junction is mostly associated with theory of mind