Identifying Natural Thermodynamic Potentials

Independent Variables and Natural Thermodynamic Potentials

  • System Property Specification Rule:

    • For a single-component, single-phase system, specifying two intensive properties plus one extensive property fixes the values of all other thermodynamic properties of the system.
    • A system of this nature allows for the independent variation of only two intensive properties and one extensive property.
  • Selection of Independent Variables:

    • Three properties are typically selected as independent variables, and all other thermodynamic properties are expressed as mathematical functions of these variables.
    • The choice of independent variables is entirely arbitrary, provided that at least one selected variable explicitly specifies the physical size (extensivity) of the system.
    • Examples of expressing internal energy EE as a function of different sets of independent variables include:
    • E=E(T,V,N)E = E(T, V, N)
    • E=E(S,V,N)E = E(S, V, N)
    • E=E(T,p,N)E = E(T, p, N)
  • Conjugate Variables and Natural Dependence:

    • Although the choice of independent variables is arbitrary, specific thermodynamic potential functions exhibit a "natural" mathematical dependence on particular combinations of conjugate variable pairs:
    • Temperature and Entropy: (T,S)(T, S)
    • Pressure and Volume: (p,V)(p, V)
    • Chemical Potential and Particle Number: (\text{\mu}, N)
    • Natural potentials originate mathematically from performing Legendre transformations on the fundamental differential equation combining the First and Second Laws of Thermodynamics:     dE = T\,dS - p\,dV + \text{\mu}\,dN

Mathematical Foundation of Legendre Transformations

  • Definition of a Legendre Transform:

    • Given a multivariable function of two independent variables, f=f(x,y)f = f(x, y), a Legendre transformation alters f(x,y)f(x, y) into a new function g(x,w)g(x, w), where ww represents the conjugate variable of yy
    • The total differential of the original function f(x,y)f(x, y) is defined as:     df=u dx+w dydf = u\,dx + w\,dy     where the partial derivatives are:     u=(∂f∂x)yu = \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x}\right)_yw=(∂f∂y)xw = \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial y}\right)_x
  • Derivation of the Transformed Differential Expression:

    • Consider the differential product rule expression:     d(wy)=w dy+y dwd(wy) = w\,dy + y\,dw
    • Subtracting d(wy)d(wy) from the total differential dfdf yields:     df−d(wy)=u dx+w dy−w dy−y dwdf - d(wy) = u\,dx + w\,dy - w\,dy - y\,dw
    • Simplifying the equation produces:     d(f−wy)=u dx−y dwd(f - wy) = u\,dx - y\,dw
  • Identities of the Legendre Transform:

    • The new function gg and its differential dgdg are established as:     g=f−wyg = f - wydg=u dx−y dwdg = u\,dx - y\,dw
    • Performing a transformation to replace both independent variables with their conjugate variables yields a new function k(u,w)k(u, w), defined by:     k=f−ux−wyk = f - ux - wydk=−x du−y dwdk = -x\,du - y\,dw
  • Permutations of Legendre Transforms:

    • For a function consisting of 22 independent variables, there are exactly 33 possible Legendre transforms.
    • For a function consisting of 33 independent variables, there are exactly 77 possible Legendre transforms.

Derivation of Gibbs Free Energy via Legendre Transformation

  • Problem Formulation:

    • Objective: Determine the natural thermodynamic potential for a single-component system maintained at constant (T,p,N)(T, p, N).
    • Base differential equation (combined 1st and 2nd Laws):     dE = T\,dS - p\,dV + \text{\mu}\,dN
    • In this base state, (S,V,N)(S, V, N) serve as the independent variables, making EE the natural potential for the variable set (S,V,N)(S, V, N).
  • Transformation to Independent Variables (T,p,N)(T, p, N):

    • To shift independent variables from (S,V,N)(S, V, N) to (T,p,N)(T, p, N), apply a Legendre transformation simultaneously to the conjugate variable pairs (T,S)(T, S) and (p,V)(p, V).
    • Performing the transformation yields the differential:     d(E - T\,S + p\,V) = -S\,dT + V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN
  • Identification of the Natural Potential:

    • The natural thermodynamic potential for a system held at constant (T,p,N)(T, p, N) is defined by the quantity E−T S+p VE - T\,S + p\,V
    • This fundamental thermodynamic quantity is known as the Gibbs free energy GG:     G=E−T S+p VG = E - T\,S + p\,V

Euler's Theorem in Thermodynamics

  • Homogeneous Functions:

    • A multivariable function f(x1,x2,…,xm)f(x_1, x_2, \dots, x_m) is defined as homogeneous of order nn if it satisfies the condition:     f(λx1,λx2,…,λxm)=λnf(x1,x2,…,xm)f(\lambda x_1, \lambda x_2, \dots, \lambda x_m) = \lambda^n f(x_1, x_2, \dots, x_m)     where λ\lambda is an arbitrary constant scalar.
    • Extensive thermodynamic properties exhibit first-order (n=1n = 1) homogeneous mathematical dependencies on other extensive properties.
    • Example: Doubling the volume (VV) doubles the total energy (EE) of the system, provided all intensive parameters of the system remain unchanged.
  • Mathematical Statement of Euler's Theorem:

    • If a function ff is homogeneous of order nn, then:     nf=(∂f∂x1)x1+(∂f∂x2)x2+⋯+(∂f∂xm)xmn f = \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_1}\right) x_1 + \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_2}\right) x_2 + \dots + \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_m}\right) x_m
    • The partial derivatives in Euler's relation are identical to those appearing in the total differential of ff:     df=(∂f∂x1)dx1+(∂f∂x2)dx2+⋯+(∂f∂xm)dxmdf = \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_1}\right) dx_1 + \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_2}\right) dx_2 + \dots + \left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial x_m}\right) dx_m
  • Thermodynamic Application of Euler's Theorem:

    • Internal energy EE is first-order homogeneous (n=1n = 1) in the extensive independent variables (S,V,N)(S, V, N).
    • Given dE = T\,dS - p\,dV + \text{\mu}\,dN, applying Euler's theorem yields the integrated energy expression:     E = T\,S - p\,V + \text{\mu}\,N

Alternative Method for Identifying Natural Thermodynamic Potentials

  • Differential Evaluation of the Integrated Energy Equation:

    • An alternate method to determine natural thermodynamic potentials involves differentiating the integrated Euler form E = T\,S - p\,V + \text{\mu}\,N
    • Expanding the differential using the product rule gives:     d(T\,S - p\,V + \text{\mu}\,N) = T\,dS + S\,dT - p\,dV - V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN + N\,d\text{\mu}
    • Equating this expansion to dEdE:     dE = T\,dS + S\,dT - p\,dV - V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN + N\,d\text{\mu}
  • Algebraic Rearrangement for Target Independent Variables (T,p,N)(T, p, N):

    • Rearrange the equation so that the differential terms of the target independent variables (T,p,N)(T, p, N) are isolated on one side:     dE - (T\,dS - p\,dV + N\,d\text{\mu}) = S\,dT - V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN
    • Substitute the fundamental relationship dE = T\,dS - p\,dV + \text{\mu}\,dN into the left side of the equation:     T\,dS - p\,dV + \text{\mu}\,dN - (T\,dS - p\,dV + N\,d\text{\mu}) = S\,dT - V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN
    • Simplifying the left-hand terms:     \text{\mu}\,dN - N\,d\text{\mu} = S\,dT - V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN
    • Expressing as a total differential yields:     d(\text{\mu}\,N) = -S\,dT + V\,dp + \text{\mu}\,dN
  • Equivalence to Gibbs Free Energy:

    • From this derivation, the natural thermodynamic potential for independent variables (T,p,N)(T, p, N) is identified as \text{\mu}\,N
    • By applying Euler's theorem (E = T\,S - p\,V + \text{\mu}\,N) and rearranging terms:     \text{\mu}\,N = E - T\,S + p\,V
    • This confirms that \text{\mu}\,N is identical to the Gibbs free energy GG.