Study Notes on Ted Hughes' Bayonet Charge
Bayonet Charge: Ted Hughes
Brief Summary
- Ted Hughes depicts a soldier for a few seconds, desperately charging into battle.
Synopsis
- A soldier is thrown into a battle completely unprepared.
- He is clumsy and confused.
- He pauses on the battlefield to consider his role in war.
- A hare gets thrown in front of him from the fighting.
- The hare is dying and suffering in front of him, which jolts him back to consciousness.
- He realizes the danger he is in.
- Reverts to his instincts and runs towards the battle in fear.
Context
Ted Hughes (1930-1998)
- Ted Hughes was a famous war poet.
- He never fought or saw war firsthand, having been a child during WWII and living in the post-war era.
- His rural upbringing in Yorkshire is evident in his poetry, which often focuses on animals.
- Hughes studied mythology and anthropology, influencing the imagery and themes in his work.
- The poem is from the collection "The Hawk in the Rain," dedicated to his wife Sylvia Plath, and emphasizes real and symbolic lives of animals.
- "Bayonet Charge" was published in 1957 but is set during WW1.
- The poem serves as a means for Hughes to process the events of war, heavily influenced by the trauma of his father, who was one of seventeen Lancaster Fusiliers to survive the Gallipoli campaign.
- The poem aims to highlight the brutality of trench warfare as a tribute to his father’s suffering and a warning to future generations.
- Hughes was inspired by Wilfred Owen, who also depicted the grim realities of war without having firsthand experience.
Analysis of Bayonet Charge
- The poem thrusts the listener into the action, relating to the idea of waking up.
- The metaphor of waking up emphasizes the physical impact of the soldier's fear.
- "Suddenly he awoke and was running – raw"
- “In raw-seamed hot khaki, his sweat heavy.”
- "Stumbling across a field of clods towards a green hedge / That dazzled with rifle fire, hearing / Bullets smacking the belly out of the air –"
- “He lugged a rifle numb as a smashed arm.”
- “The patriotic tear that had brimmed in his eye / Sweating like molten iron from the centre of his chest.”
Confusion and Reflection
- In bewilderment, he almost stops, questioning his role:
- “In what cold clockwork of the stars and the nations / Was he the hand pointing that second?”
- This illustrates the soldier’s existential terror.
- He runs "like a man who has jumped up in the dark and runs" trying to understand his actions.
- The imagery of a "yellow hare" rolling like a flame introduces visceral, chaotic violence into the poem.
- The description of the hare conveys helplessness, mirroring the soldier’s fears and complexities of warfare.
Themes of War and Isolation
- The poem is written in the third person singular, emphasizing individual experiences of war.
- This perspective allows readers to grasp the horrific reality of a singular soldier's experience, despite broader national motivations for war.
- The isolation is underscored; the only human present is the soldier, enhancing the intensity of his suffering.
- Hughes illustrates that even in an army, soldiers are fundamentally alone, primarily focused on self-preservation.
Chaotic Structure
- Hughes employs a chaotic structure to depict the disorder of war.
- Enjambment: Accelerates pace and reflects war's unyielding nature.
- The first stanza is primarily one sentence, mirroring the abruptness of battle.
- Caesura: Creates pauses, slowing down the reader and forcing contemplation on the horrors of war.
- The contrast between fast-paced enjambment and slow-paced caesura emphasizes deeper philosophical questions surrounding conflict.
Literary Techniques
- Repetition: Use of the word “raw” highlights the soldier’s suffering, underscoring emotional and mental breakdown.
- Imagery and Metaphor: Visuals of the chaos of war are evident in lines like:
- “The patriotic tear… Sweating like molten iron.”
- The dehumanizing imagery blurs the lines between man and violence, adding gravity to suffering.
- The rifle is described as “numb as a smashed arm,” reinforcing the soldier’s disconnection from his role.
Nature as a Victim
- The hare symbolizes the broader suffering of soldiers caught in war.
- The explicit violence against the hare highlights the soldier's emotional numbness, jolting him into action.
- Personification of Nature: The air is described in human terms, capturing the robbery of peace by war.
- Hughes paints a stark juxtaposition against peaceful pastoral images that have transformed into battlegrounds.
Comparisons with Other War Poetry
Connections with Wilfred Owen
- Both Hughes and Owen convey the harsh realities and psychological horrors of war, though Hughes borrowed elements from Owen’s expressions:
- Common themes, structures, and imagery.
- Use of dactylic rhythms, metaphors, and similes portraying the raw experience of soldiers.
Comparative Analysis with Other Poems
- Charge of the Light Brigade: Critique on war leadership and soldiers' obedience.
- Hughes challenges the concept of honor unlike Tennyson, who glorifies it.
- Exposure by Owen: Similar themes of patriotism concealing war's true nature.
- Both poems emphasize soldiers’ mental struggles during war.
- Remains by Simon Armitage: Focuses on psychological impacts post-war, while Hughes centers on the immediate chaos of the battlefield.
Conclusion
- "Bayonet Charge" serves not only as a reflection of war but also as an exploration of personal struggles against broader existential themes influenced by historical antecedents, nature, and individual remorse.
- Hughes’ use of vivid imagery, chaotic structure, and emotional resonance makes this poem a powerful critique and remembrance of war.