Chapter 3- Valuation and Market Analysis Flashcards
Valuation and Market Analysis: Introduction and Learning Objectives
/
/
The Valuation and Market Analysis section constitutes approximately of the Salesperson Exam, typically involving or more questions.
Key Learning Objectives include: - Defining appraisal and the factors influencing appraisal value. - Understanding the three primary appraisal approaches to value. - Recognizing the requirements for appraiser licensing and the delivery of appraisal reports. - Differentiating between a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) and a formal appraisal. - Identifying essential items for a listing presentation.
The Fundamentals of Appraisals
Definition of Appraisal: An appraisal is a formal, written opinion of value assigned to a property by a licensed appraiser.
Basis of Appraisal: Appraisals must be based on supportable evidence as of a specific date. They must be conducted in strict accordance with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP).
Distinction Between Appraisal and Assessment: - Real Estate Appraisal: An estimate of current property value primarily used by lenders to evaluate collateral. - Real Estate Assessment: An estimate of value used specifically by local municipalities to calculate property taxes.
Role of the Appraiser: Appraisers estimate the value of buildings or land. They often specialize in either residential or commercial property. Appraisals are typically required before a property is sold, mortgaged, or taxed.
Lender Requirements: Mortgage lenders use formal valuation to ensure the property value is sufficient to support the loan amount. Lenders or appraisal management companies usually hire the appraiser, although the buyer typically pays the fee.
The Appraisal Process (USPAP Standards)
Appraisers follow a standardized process to ensure accuracy and professionalism: - State the Problem: Identify the specific property, the legal rights associated with it, the purpose of the appraisal, and the specific type of value to be estimated. - Identify Data Needed: Gather and analyze general data (city, neighborhood, demographics) and property-specific data. - Determine Highest and Best Use: Assess what the most profitable use of the property would be if the land were vacant. This is critical for commercial properties but also impacts residential properties in mixed-use areas. - Estimate Land Value: Value the land as if it were vacant, using one of the three valuation approaches (sales comparison, cost, or income). - Reconcile Values: Determine the final appraised value. This is not a simple average. Reconciliation (also known as correlation) depends on how well comparable properties match the subject property and the reliability of the methods used. - Deliver the Report: Finalize and provide the formal appraisal report.
Example of Reconciliation: If three comps suggest values of , , and , the appraiser will weigh the comp most similar to the subject property more heavily rather than just averaging the three.
Legal and Regulatory Requirements for Appraisers
FIRREA (1989): The Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act requires that appraisals for federally related transactions be completed by state-certified or licensed appraisers.
Federally Related Transactions: These are transactions involving a federal financial regulatory agency that are not FHA insured, VA guaranteed, or sold to Government Sponsored Enterprises (GSEs) like Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac.
Exemptions: Residential properties valued at or less are exempt from federal appraisal requirements.
FHA Loans: Must be appraised by a state-licensed appraiser approved by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).
VA Loans: Must be appraised by a VA-certified, state-licensed appraiser.
Appraiser Independence Requirements (AIR): Implemented in 2010 by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the FHFA to ensure unbiased values. AIR requires appraisers to be: - Licensed or certified in the state where the property is located. - Knowledgeable about the local market. - Qualified for that specific property type.
Prohibitions: AIR prohibits lenders from coercing or influencing an appraiser's opinion. Lenders may select appraisers from an approved list if the selectors are not involved in loan approval.
Economic Principles of Value
Plottage: An increase in value gained by combining adjacent parcels into one larger parcel. The process of combining them is called Assemblage. The value of the resulting single parcel is often greater than the sum of the individual costs. - Example: Three parcels costing each (total ) are combined. Due to new "highest and best use" options, the total value becomes , a increase.
Progression: The increase in a property's value due to the presence of higher-valued properties in the surrounding area.
Regression: The decline in property value caused by the presence of lower-valued or declining neighboring properties.
Externalities: Factors outside the property that influence value, such as zoning, school districts, commercial development, natural disasters, and interest rates.
Substitution: The principle that a buyer will not pay more for a property than the cost of acquiring an equally desirable substitute. This provides balance to market pricing.
Supply and Demand: Interaction between property availability and buyer desire. Real estate value is driven by location, scarcity, and desire. - Buyer's Market: High supply and/or low demand leads to decreased prices. - Seller's Market: Low supply and/or high demand leads to increased prices.
The Sales/Market Comparison Approach
This approach is based on the Principle of Substitution. It uses the prices of recently sold similar properties (Comps) to estimate the value of the Subject Property.
Usage: Most common method for single-family homes. Appraisers typically select to comps.
Adjustments: Since no two properties are identical, appraisers adjust the sales prices of comps to match the subject property's features, location, condition, and sale timing. - Example: A subject property has 4 bedrooms. A comp with 3 bedrooms sold for . If an extra bedroom adds in value, the subject is estimated at .
Bracketing: Using inferior, similar, and superior properties to determine a probable value range.
Elements of Comparison: Applied in this specific order: 1. Financing terms and cash equivalency. 2. Conditions of sale. 3. Market conditions at the time of contract and closing. 4. Location. 5. Physical characteristics.
Cash Equivalency: Adjusting comp prices based on financing differences. - Example: A house sold for , but the seller paid in buyer closing costs. The equivalent value is .
The Cost Approach
Based on the concept that a property is worth the land value plus the cost of improvements.
Formula:
Usage: Unique properties (hospitals, churches, schools, movie theaters) and new construction with no comps.
Direct vs. Indirect Costs: Direct costs include labor and materials. Indirect costs include permits, architectural fees, and builder's profit.
Cost Methods: - Replacement Cost: Cost to build a functionally equivalent property using modern materials and standards. - Reproduction Cost: Cost to build an exact replica using the original design and materials (used for historical structures). - Square Footage Method: . (Ex: ). - Unit-in-place Method: Sums the cost of individual components (e.g., for installed hardwood). - Quantity Survey Method: Breaks down the unit-in-place further into raw materials and labor (nails, wood, man-hours). - Index Method: Adjusts original construction cost using a national index. - Formula: - Example: . \200,000 \times 1.2 = \.
Depreciation in Valuation
Depreciation is the loss in value for any reason. There are three primary types: - Economic Obsolescence: Caused by external factors (e.g., a new airport runway nearby causing noise). This is typically incurable. - Functional Obsolescence: Caused by design defects or outdated features (e.g., an old floor plan or being overbuilt for the area). - Physical Deterioration: Resulting from wear and tear or poor maintenance (e.g., a rotting deck).
Curable vs. Incurable: - Curable: Repair cost is less than the resulting value increase. (Ex: deck repair adds value). - Incurable: Repair cost exceeds the value increase. (Ex: layout change adds only value).
Straight-Line Method: Assumes an equal annual rate of depreciation. - Example: reproduction cost with a -year economic life and an effective age of years. - -
The Income Analysis Approach
Uses property-generated income to estimate fair market value. Essential for investment properties (apartments, retail, office).
Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM): Used for residential rentals of to units. Based on Monthly income. - Formula: - Subject Value: - Example: Comps average to GRM. Subject rent is . Estimated value = .
Gross Income Multiplier (GIM): Used for or more units or commercial properties. Based on Annual income. - Formula: - Example: GIM annual income = value.
1031 Exchange: Based on IRC Section 1031, allowing deferral of capital gains tax when selling and buying "like-kind" investment real estate.
Clarification on Terms: In the industry, GRM and GIM are often used interchangeably. Standard annual GIMs range from to , which equates to a monthly GRM range of to ( to ).
Adjusting Comparable Properties and Price per Square Foot
To value a subject property, adjust the known sales price of the comp: - Comp Inferior to Subject: Adjust price upward. - Comp Superior to Subject: Adjust price downward.
Calculation Example (Inferior): Comp sold for but has one less garage bay (worth ) and is smaller (at ). - \$450,000 + \$10,000 + (\50 \times 200) = \.
Calculation Example (Superior): Comp sold for but has a pool (worth ) and is larger (at ). - \$515,000 - \$25,000 - (\50 \times 300) = \.
Livable Square Footage: Conditioned areas (heated/cooled). Does not include unfinished basements, attics, or garages.
Price Per Square Foot Formula: .
Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) Checklist
Real estate agents use CMAs to suggest listing prices using the following steps: - Data Gathering: Location, total livable square footage, number of beds/baths, lot size, year built, current taxes, renovations, and notable features. - Comp Selection: Choose at least similar homes nearby that sold within the last to months (or months in a slow market). - Arm's Length Transactions: Use homes sold on the open market (MLS). - Seller Concessions: Account for closing costs paid by the seller. - Pending and Active Listings: Review pending (under contract) and active listings to gauge current competition and time on market (DOM). - Expired Listings: Review listings that didn't sell to identify overpricing trends. - Micro-Market Trends: Consider neighborhood-specific factors like school districts.
Real Estate Market Dynamics and Purchasing Power
Buyer’s Market: Supply > Demand ( months of inventory). Prices trend down; buyers have leverage; sellers pay concessions.
Seller’s Market: Demand > Supply ( months or less of inventory). Prices rise; sellers have leverage; bidding wars and escalation clauses are common.
Balanced Market: Supply is nearly equal to the number of buyers.
Housing Inventory: Measured by "months' supply." If months of inventory exists, it would take months for all current homes to sell if no new ones were listed.
Buying/Purchasing Power: The total funds a buyer has, including down payment and mortgage eligibility.
Uncontrollable Factors (Decreasing Power): Higher taxes, higher interest rates, higher home prices, inflation.
Controllable Factors (Increasing Power): High credit score, low debt, more savings.
Strategies for Buyers and Sellers
In a Buyer's Market: - Buyers: Take time with research; analyze comps for negotiation; target homes with high days on market (DOM). - Sellers: Make necessary repairs; ensure a great first impression (clean, declutter, landscape, depersonalize); use professional marketing (drone photos, stagers); price competitively.
In a Seller's Market: - Sellers: Price fairly to encourage bidding wars; evaluate the financial strength of offers (cash vs. financing); ensure buyers are preapproved (verified income/credit) rather than just prequalified (estimated). - Buyers: Act fast; understand that contingencies and concessions are often omitted; practice patience and avoid a "scarcity mindset" to prevent overpaying for a suboptimal home.