Chapter 7: Variable Costing and Segment Reporting: Tools for Management

Chapter 7 Lecture: Variable Costing and Segment Reporting - Tools for Management

Learning Objectives

  • Objective 1: Explain differences between variable costing and absorption costing; compute unit product costs for each method.

  • Objective 2: Prepare income statements using both costing methods.

  • Objective 3: Reconcile net operating income from both methods and clarify their differences.

  • Objective 4: Create segmented income statements separating traceable fixed costs from common fixed costs for decision-making.

  • Objective 5: Compute company-wide and segment break-even points considering traceable fixed costs.

Key Assumptions

  • Actual Costing: Uses actual direct materials (DM), direct labor (DL), and overhead (OH) costs; relevant only for producing costs, as discussed in Chapter 2.

  • Constant Variable Costs: Assumes a constant amount of variable manufacturing costs per unit and total fixed manufacturing costs per period throughout the analysis.

Two Costing Methods

Variable Costing
  • Product costs include:

    • Direct Materials (DM)

    • Direct Labor (DL)

    • Variable Overhead (VOH)

  • Period costs include:

    • Fixed Overhead (FOH) - treated as a period expense rather than a product cost.

    • Variable Selling Administration (VSA) Expenses

    • Fixed Selling Administration (FSA) Expenses

  • Usage: Primarily for internal decision-making processes.

Absorption Costing
  • Definition: Also known as the traditional costing method.

  • Product costs include:

    • Direct Materials (DM)

    • Direct Labor (DL)

    • Variable Overhead (VOH)

    • Fixed Overhead (FOH) - absorbed into the product cost.

  • Period costs include:

    • Variable Selling Administration (VSA) Expenses

    • Fixed Selling Administration (FSA) Expenses

  • Usage: Used for external reporting; helps determine values for ending inventory and cost of goods sold (COGS).

Difference Between the Costing Methods
  • Key Distinction: Absorption costing includes FOH as part of the product costs, which results in higher inventory values compared to variable costing, impacting decision-making on product pricing and discontinuation.

Example: Harvey Company’s Costing

  • Production Information:

    • Number of units produced annually: 25,000

    • Variable costs:

    • Direct materials, direct labor, and variable manufacturing overhead: $10/unit

    • Selling & administrative expenses: $3/unit

    • Fixed costs:

    • Manufacturing overhead: $150,000/year

    • Selling & administrative expenses: $100,000/year

  • Calculating Per Unit Costs:

    • Fixed OH per unit: rac{150,000}{25,000} = 6

    • Unit product cost under Variable Costing: 10 (DM, DL, VOH) = $10

    • Unit product cost under Absorption Costing: 10 + 6 (FOH) = $16

    • Conclusion: Absorption costing results in a higher unit product cost.

Absorption vs. Variable Costing Income Statements

Scenario: Units Made = Units Sold
  • Absorption Costing Income Statement includes all traditional product costs as part of COGS, with all other costs accounted as period expenses.

  • Variable Costing Income Statement consists of variable expenses including:

    • Variable COGS (variable product costs)

    • Variable selling/admin expenses (variable period expenses)

    • Fixed expenses treated as period expenses; fixed overhead is accounted in the period produced.

Example 1: Boomer Company
  • Data: 500 computers produced and sold.

  • Absorption Costing Calculation:

    • Cost per computer: 100 + 50 + 25 + 75 = 250

    • Income Statement Performance:

    • Sales: 750\cdot500=375,000

    • COGS: 500\cdot500=250,000 (for Absorption costing)

    • Net operating income: 232,500

Scenario Adjustments:
  • Units Made < Units Sold:

    • Results in lower absorption costing income due to previously absorbed fixed costs being considered as current period expenses.

  • Units Made > Units Sold:

    • Results in higher absorption costing income due to costs being absorbed by unsold inventory.

Segment Reporting

  • Definition of Segment: Any part of an organization for which managers require cost and revenue data (e.g., Sales Territories, Individual Stores).

  • Contribution Format: A necessary approach in segmented income statements to distinguish fixed from variable costs, facilitating the calculation of contribution margins.

  • Traceable Fixed Costs: Costs directly associated with a segment that would cease if the segment were discontinued.

    • Example: Salary of a product manager for a specific product.

  • Common Fixed Costs: Costs related to overall operations that do not disappear with the elimination of a segment.

    • Example: Salary of a company-wide CEO.

Segment Margin Calculation: Segment Performance
  • Contribution Margin: Calculated as sales minus variable costs.

  • **Income Statement Example for Television Division: **

    • Sales: $300,000

    • Variable costs: $120,000

    • Contribution margin: $180,000

    • Traceable fixed expenses: $90,000

    • Division margin: $60,000

Total Company Example
  • Company Breakdown: Sales of both Television and Computer Divisions alongside contribution margins and traceable fixed expenses.

    • Example Total Sales: $500,000

    • Common expenses deducted for net operating income calculation.

Break-even Analysis

  • Company-wide Break-even Sales Formula: Break-even = Total Fixed Costs / Contribution Margin Ratio

  • Segment Break-even Sales: Assessing traceable fixed costs against contribution margins to determine segment efficiency.

    • Example: CM Ratio = rac{ ext{Contribution Margin}}{ ext{Sales}}

Additional Examples and Calculations:
  • Present segmented statements including percentages and calculations for east and west divisions for Paisley Corporation, summarizing break-even points efficiently.