Lecture Notes on Social Relations, Rights, the State, and Historical Materialism
Social Relations vs. Human Nature
Social relations are more fundamental than human nature.
The society you live in shapes the person you become.
The productive technologies of a society determine the kinds of social relations that exist.
Rights and Duties
Rights and duties are not natural but are generated by the social relations within a society.
They are part of the legal and political superstructure.
Rights and duties serve a function for the social relations and are not absolute limits on society's interference.
Role of the State
There is no fixed role for the state.
The state is part of the legal and political infrastructure.
The state's form and role depend on the particular social relations of a society.
The state often maintains and stabilizes social relations, creating a feedback relationship.
Example: Current state actions regarding Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) can be seen as an attempt to change social relations, possibly reflecting the desires of the ruling class based on material forces of production.
Counter-Example: The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the US Constitution, which require equal treatment under the law, institutionalize equality and govern social relations, potentially operating in opposite directions to policies undoing equality.
Philosophical Basis: Historical Materialism
The philosophical basis connecting technical development and social change.
There is no fixed human nature; historical development and change depend on technical development.
This forms the basis for assessing social relations, politics, and law.
This is known as historical materialism, a theory of history.
Connection to Previous Lectures
Previous lectures focused on "high cinema dramas of princes and states," while Marx emphasizes understanding the real basis for social relations that govern the economy (civil society).
Marx transformed political thought into a social science by focusing on history and the economy.
Marx's Scheme
Productive technologies are basic.
Social relations follow from productive technologies.
Law and politics are products of social relations.
The way people think is a product of these factors.
Influence of Karl Marx
Karl Marx is one of the most influential political thinkers in history.
Many countries were inspired by his ideas, even though they may not have become truly Marxist.
Transition to the 20th and 21st Centuries
Important issues of the 20th and 21st centuries include the civil rights movement, feminism, and social movements related to sexuality.
Redrawing the Diagram
The diagram of society has been redrawn to reflect changes in the 20th and 21st centuries.
The original diagram showed arrows going from material forces of production to social relations, then to law and politics, and finally to forms of consciousness.
The revised diagram has arrows running in every possible direction, indicating reciprocal influence among these factors.
Social relations are now the foundation, but law, politics, and forms of consciousness have a shaping influence on social relations.
New forms of social consciousness can shape social relations and provide a basis for rewriting law and politics.
Example: The civil rights movement aimed to change the law based on ideas about how to achieve a better law.
Laws can shape social relations (e.g., tax laws in Germany).
The relationship between culture and politics has become very important.
Charles Mills and the Racial Contract
Charles Mills (1951-2021) studied the political consequences and cultural and social consequences of colonialism.
Mills's work is related to Marx and Engels, remodeling their picture of society.
He examined how colonialism affects the way people think, the forms of law, the forms of politics, and social relations.
Labor Contract
Structural positions in the economy are defined by property rights.
The labor contract brings together the roles of laborer and capitalist.
This relationship is mediated by contractual agreements that dictate the terms of employment, wages, and working conditions. These contracts not only reflect the power dynamics between the two parties but also shape the broader socio-economic environment, influencing class relations and the distribution of wealth. The implications of these contracts extend beyond individual workplaces, affecting global labor markets and contributing to the ongoing discourse on workers' rights and social justice. As such, understanding the nuances of labor contracts is crucial for analyzing the mechanisms of exploitation and resistance within various economic systems.
Social Contract
People start in the state of nature and form an agreement to establish an association based on their natural freedom.
The social contract endows people with the equal status of citizens
.
Racial Contract
The racial contract is a set of formal or informal agreements that set the limits of the contract's validity between members of one subset of humans, designated as white, and full persons to categorize the remaining subset of humans as non-white with a different and inferior moral status, as sub-persons.
The general purpose of the contract is the differential privileging of whites, the exploitation of non-white bodies, land, and resources, and the denial of equal socioeconomic opportunities to non-whites.
Whites are beneficiaries of the contract, though some whites are not signatories to it.
The racial contract generates racial designations by agreement, generating the status of "white."
It creates a status of lesser moral status for non-whites.
The racial contract partitions humanity by agreement among some, classifying themselves as white and others as non-white.
The racial contract can be viewed as a form of thought or ideology that inflects social relations.
Differences from Social Contract
Mills argues that the racial contract is based on actual documents and agreements, unlike the social contract, which may be just a thought experiment.
Scope of the Racial Contract
Mills focuses on Europe in relation to the rest of the world.
The racial contract may apply to other situations, such as Japanese colonization of Asia.
It could be applied to other demographics like economic classes or sex and gender.
Force or superior weaponry may be required for the racial contract to be effective.
Historical Transformations
Mills thinks there was a pre-racial state of human society, and human societies were racialized through actual contracts leading to historical transforations.
Development of Racial Contract
Mills identifies two phases of the racial contract:
De jure white supremacy (legally institutionalized white supremacy)
Expropriation contract (taking property)
Social contract in which racial hierarchies are established and perpetuated through both legal systems and economic exploitation. In this framework, Mills argues that these contracts not only deny rights to marginalized groups but also fundamentally shape societal structures and relations, reinforcing systemic inequalities across generations.
Example: Christopher Columbus claiming land for the Spanish crown in the New World, displacing native peoples, can be an example of the expropriation contract.
Example: US government's invasion of Mexico to seize territory.
Example: The act for the government and protection of Indians that moved Native Americans to reservations, seizing their land.
Example: Treaty of Temecula with Native tribes to cede their Land.
Example: European colonization of Africa and exploitation of resources there.
Colonial Contract
: The agreement established between colonial powers and local populations, often resulting in the loss of sovereignty and self-determination for Indigenous peoples. This contract frequently entailed unequal power dynamics, where Indigenous populations were coerced into accepting terms that favored the interests of colonial powers, leading to long-term socio-economic and cultural consequences.
Settling colonies and administrating land by a European Country.
Example: Plymouth Colony where pilgrims settled along the coast of Massachusetts cohabiting with native people.
Example: Mission San Juan Capistrano, founded by Spain to extend their rule, as a colonial contract.
Example: Opium Wars, Ceding Hong Kong to the British Government.