Differing Views and Tensions within Anarchism
Human Nature
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
Empathetic and Sociable: Mankind is naturally empathetic and sociable.
Social Animals: Human society resembles the animal kingdom, living in social groups (Kropotkin).
Anti-Competition: Humans are not competitive (anti-Darwinism).
Collective Goals: People are social animals who prefer to achieve goals collectively. With the state removed, empathy and caring nature will emerge.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
Similar to other collectivist anarchists, humans are social creatures.
Emphasizes mankind’s potential for social solidarity, especially within similar occupations.
Labor and creativity are fundamental to human nature. Work should express creativity.
Removing the state makes work fulfilling and an expression of personality.
Egoism
No true altruism exists; people only do things that benefit themselves.
The ego drives behavior and choices, focusing on self-autonomy.
Rejects religious ideas, state, and moral codes to promote self-autonomy.
People are rational and self-interested. Selfishness is logical and reasonable.
Anarcho-Capitalism
Private property and the ability to trade are critical (Murray Rothbard).
People are rational and self-interested, prioritizing their own needs.
Individuals managing their own affairs will make the state irrelevant.
The State
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
People can live in peace and harmony without a state.
Decisions reached collectively through natural democratic processes.
Smaller, natural communities control common ownership of production.
The state suppresses individual liberty and exploits producers and consumers.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
Socialists want a workers' state; anarchists want cooperative, self-governing workers' federations.
Solidarity can destroy capitalism and the state.
Work becomes an expression of creativity without the oppressive state.
The state should be removed, ideally through revolution.
Egoism
No need for a state; collectivism doesn't work as power dynamics develop.
Liberation of the ego from oppressive forces and state control.
Anarcho-Capitalism
No need for a state; collectivism fails due to inevitable power dynamics.
Hates state intervention in any affairs (Murray Rothbard).
State creates monopolies, hindering efficiency and growth.
State should not exist as it hinders free-market capitalism.
Society
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
People will naturally help each other, ensuring solidarity and progress.
Grouping based on occupation enhances collective consciousness and solidarity.
Society should involve cooperative communities free from coercion.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
Encourages strikes, mass demonstrations, and acts of violence.
Workers in similar occupations group together to resist capitalism.
Workers should regain control of their labor and workplaces.
Egoism
Collaboration to further individual interests.
Rejection of religious ideas, state, and moral codes for self-autonomy.
People should not be forced into social groupings, maintaining individual sovereignty.
Anarcho-Capitalism
People may form connections but should not be forced into groups.
Individuals maximize benefits in a free-market society without state restrictions.
Economy
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
Capitalism pits people against each other in a competitive struggle.
Replace capitalism with common ownership of production, distribution, and exchange.
Economic organization in communes should be voluntary.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
New social order based on self-governing federations of workers (syndicates).
Workers' groups exchange labor and goods for mutual benefit.
These groups will resist capitalism and form the basis of economic organization after its overthrow.
Egoism
Free individuals will find ways to trade beneficially.
Individuals focus on self-realization and personal benefit.
Anarcho-Capitalism
All services should be created and provided by the free market.
Sales should occur between private individuals without state interference.
Competition creates better services, even for private policing and courts.
State monopolies hinder economic growth; capitalism must flourish free from state interference.
Human Nature
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
Empathetic and Sociable: Mankind is naturally empathetic and sociable.
Social Animals: Human society resembles the animal kingdom, living in social groups (Kropotkin).
Anti-Competition: Humans are not competitive (anti-Darwinism).
Collective Goals: People are social animals who prefer to achieve goals collectively. With the state removed, empathy and caring nature will emerge.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
Similar to other collectivist anarchists, humans are social creatures.
Emphasizes mankind’s potential for social solidarity, especially within similar occupations.
Labor and creativity are fundamental to human nature. Work should express creativity.
Removing the state makes work fulfilling and an expression of personality.
Egoism
No true altruism exists; people only do things that benefit themselves.
The ego drives behavior and choices, focusing on self-autonomy.
Rejects religious ideas, state, and moral codes to promote self-autonomy.
People are rational and self-interested. Selfishness is logical and reasonable.
Anarcho-Capitalism
Private property and the ability to trade are critical (Murray Rothbard).
People are rational and self-interested, prioritizing their own needs.
Individuals managing their own affairs will make the state irrelevant.
The State
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
People can live in peace and harmony without a state.
Decisions reached collectively through natural democratic processes.
Smaller, natural communities control common ownership of production.
The state suppresses individual liberty and exploits producers and consumers.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
Socialists want a workers' state; anarchists want cooperative, self-governing workers' federations.
Solidarity can destroy capitalism and the state.
Work becomes an expression of creativity without the oppressive state.
The state should be removed, ideally through revolution.
Egoism
No need for a state; collectivism doesn't work as power dynamics develop.
Liberation of the ego from oppressive forces and state control.
Anarcho-Capitalism
No need for a state; collectivism fails due to inevitable power dynamics.
Hates state intervention in any affairs (Murray Rothbard).
State creates monopolies, hindering efficiency and growth.
State should not exist as it hinders free-market capitalism.
Society
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
People will naturally help each other, ensuring solidarity and progress.
Grouping based on occupation enhances collective consciousness and solidarity.
Society should involve cooperative communities free from coercion.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
Encourages strikes, mass demonstrations, and acts of violence.
Workers in similar occupations group together to resist capitalism.
Workers should regain control of their labor and workplaces.
Egoism
Collaboration to further individual interests.
Rejection of religious ideas, state, and moral codes for self-autonomy.
People should not be forced into social groupings, maintaining individual sovereignty.
Anarcho-Capitalism
People may form connections but should not be forced into groups.
Individuals maximize benefits in a free-market society without state restrictions.
Economy
Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism
Capitalism pits people against each other in a competitive struggle.
Replace capitalism with common ownership of production, distribution, and exchange.
Economic organization in communes should be voluntary.
Anarcho-Syndicalism
New social order based on self-governing federations of workers (syndicates).
Workers' groups exchange labor and goods for mutual benefit.
These groups will resist capitalism and form the basis of economic organization after its overthrow.
Egoism
Free individuals will find ways to trade beneficially.
Individuals focus on self-realization and personal benefit.
Anarcho-Capitalism
All services should be created and provided by the free market.
Sales should occur between private individuals without state interference.
Competition creates better services, even for private policing and courts.
State monopolies hinder economic growth; capitalism must flourish free from state interference.