knowt logo

Differing Views and Tensions within Anarchism

Human Nature

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • Empathetic and Sociable: Mankind is naturally empathetic and sociable.

  • Social Animals: Human society resembles the animal kingdom, living in social groups (Kropotkin).

  • Anti-Competition: Humans are not competitive (anti-Darwinism).

  • Collective Goals: People are social animals who prefer to achieve goals collectively. With the state removed, empathy and caring nature will emerge.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • Similar to other collectivist anarchists, humans are social creatures.

  • Emphasizes mankind’s potential for social solidarity, especially within similar occupations.

  • Labor and creativity are fundamental to human nature. Work should express creativity.

  • Removing the state makes work fulfilling and an expression of personality.

Egoism

  • No true altruism exists; people only do things that benefit themselves.

  • The ego drives behavior and choices, focusing on self-autonomy.

  • Rejects religious ideas, state, and moral codes to promote self-autonomy.

  • People are rational and self-interested. Selfishness is logical and reasonable.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • Private property and the ability to trade are critical (Murray Rothbard).

  • People are rational and self-interested, prioritizing their own needs.

  • Individuals managing their own affairs will make the state irrelevant.

The State

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • People can live in peace and harmony without a state.

  • Decisions reached collectively through natural democratic processes.

  • Smaller, natural communities control common ownership of production.

  • The state suppresses individual liberty and exploits producers and consumers.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • Socialists want a workers' state; anarchists want cooperative, self-governing workers' federations.

  • Solidarity can destroy capitalism and the state.

  • Work becomes an expression of creativity without the oppressive state.

  • The state should be removed, ideally through revolution.

Egoism

  • No need for a state; collectivism doesn't work as power dynamics develop.

  • Liberation of the ego from oppressive forces and state control.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • No need for a state; collectivism fails due to inevitable power dynamics.

  • Hates state intervention in any affairs (Murray Rothbard).

  • State creates monopolies, hindering efficiency and growth.

  • State should not exist as it hinders free-market capitalism.

Society

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • People will naturally help each other, ensuring solidarity and progress.

  • Grouping based on occupation enhances collective consciousness and solidarity.

  • Society should involve cooperative communities free from coercion.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • Encourages strikes, mass demonstrations, and acts of violence.

  • Workers in similar occupations group together to resist capitalism.

  • Workers should regain control of their labor and workplaces.

Egoism

  • Collaboration to further individual interests.

  • Rejection of religious ideas, state, and moral codes for self-autonomy.

  • People should not be forced into social groupings, maintaining individual sovereignty.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • People may form connections but should not be forced into groups.

  • Individuals maximize benefits in a free-market society without state restrictions.

Economy

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • Capitalism pits people against each other in a competitive struggle.

  • Replace capitalism with common ownership of production, distribution, and exchange.

  • Economic organization in communes should be voluntary.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • New social order based on self-governing federations of workers (syndicates).

  • Workers' groups exchange labor and goods for mutual benefit.

  • These groups will resist capitalism and form the basis of economic organization after its overthrow.

Egoism

  • Free individuals will find ways to trade beneficially.

  • Individuals focus on self-realization and personal benefit.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • All services should be created and provided by the free market.

  • Sales should occur between private individuals without state interference.

  • Competition creates better services, even for private policing and courts.

  • State monopolies hinder economic growth; capitalism must flourish free from state interference.

N

Differing Views and Tensions within Anarchism

Human Nature

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • Empathetic and Sociable: Mankind is naturally empathetic and sociable.

  • Social Animals: Human society resembles the animal kingdom, living in social groups (Kropotkin).

  • Anti-Competition: Humans are not competitive (anti-Darwinism).

  • Collective Goals: People are social animals who prefer to achieve goals collectively. With the state removed, empathy and caring nature will emerge.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • Similar to other collectivist anarchists, humans are social creatures.

  • Emphasizes mankind’s potential for social solidarity, especially within similar occupations.

  • Labor and creativity are fundamental to human nature. Work should express creativity.

  • Removing the state makes work fulfilling and an expression of personality.

Egoism

  • No true altruism exists; people only do things that benefit themselves.

  • The ego drives behavior and choices, focusing on self-autonomy.

  • Rejects religious ideas, state, and moral codes to promote self-autonomy.

  • People are rational and self-interested. Selfishness is logical and reasonable.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • Private property and the ability to trade are critical (Murray Rothbard).

  • People are rational and self-interested, prioritizing their own needs.

  • Individuals managing their own affairs will make the state irrelevant.

The State

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • People can live in peace and harmony without a state.

  • Decisions reached collectively through natural democratic processes.

  • Smaller, natural communities control common ownership of production.

  • The state suppresses individual liberty and exploits producers and consumers.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • Socialists want a workers' state; anarchists want cooperative, self-governing workers' federations.

  • Solidarity can destroy capitalism and the state.

  • Work becomes an expression of creativity without the oppressive state.

  • The state should be removed, ideally through revolution.

Egoism

  • No need for a state; collectivism doesn't work as power dynamics develop.

  • Liberation of the ego from oppressive forces and state control.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • No need for a state; collectivism fails due to inevitable power dynamics.

  • Hates state intervention in any affairs (Murray Rothbard).

  • State creates monopolies, hindering efficiency and growth.

  • State should not exist as it hinders free-market capitalism.

Society

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • People will naturally help each other, ensuring solidarity and progress.

  • Grouping based on occupation enhances collective consciousness and solidarity.

  • Society should involve cooperative communities free from coercion.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • Encourages strikes, mass demonstrations, and acts of violence.

  • Workers in similar occupations group together to resist capitalism.

  • Workers should regain control of their labor and workplaces.

Egoism

  • Collaboration to further individual interests.

  • Rejection of religious ideas, state, and moral codes for self-autonomy.

  • People should not be forced into social groupings, maintaining individual sovereignty.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • People may form connections but should not be forced into groups.

  • Individuals maximize benefits in a free-market society without state restrictions.

Economy

Anarcho-Communism and Mutualism

  • Capitalism pits people against each other in a competitive struggle.

  • Replace capitalism with common ownership of production, distribution, and exchange.

  • Economic organization in communes should be voluntary.

Anarcho-Syndicalism

  • New social order based on self-governing federations of workers (syndicates).

  • Workers' groups exchange labor and goods for mutual benefit.

  • These groups will resist capitalism and form the basis of economic organization after its overthrow.

Egoism

  • Free individuals will find ways to trade beneficially.

  • Individuals focus on self-realization and personal benefit.

Anarcho-Capitalism

  • All services should be created and provided by the free market.

  • Sales should occur between private individuals without state interference.

  • Competition creates better services, even for private policing and courts.

  • State monopolies hinder economic growth; capitalism must flourish free from state interference.