Limitations

  • Sugar concentrations were tested one at a time rather than simultaneously
    Limitation: Environmental conditions (like room temperature) could change between tests, affecting results.
    Fix: Test all sugar concentrations at the same time using identical setups.

  • Timing between adding sugar and starting the timer may not have been consistent
    Limitation: Delays could let fermentation start before the timer, giving inaccurate results.
    Fix: Have a second person start the timer the instant sugar is added and the balloon is placed.

  • Water temperature was only adjusted approximately (to ~30°C)
    Limitation: Slight temperature differences affect yeast fermentation.
    Fix: Use a thermometer to measure precisely and use a water bath or incubator to maintain a stable temperature.

  • Stirring may have varied in speed or force
    Limitation: Uneven mixing could result in different sugar availability.
    Fix: Use a mechanical stirrer to standardise stirring.

  • Measuring balloon circumference with tape and a ruler introduces human error
    Limitation: The tape might not be placed at the widest point consistently, leading to inaccurate readings.
    Fix: Use a flexible seamstress tape measure and mark a specific point on each balloon for measurement.

  • Differences in balloon elasticity could affect inflation
    Limitation: Balloons may stretch differently even if the gas volume is the same.
    Fix: Pre-stretch balloons or use syringes or gas syringes to measure gas volume directly.

  • Risk of small air leaks where the balloon was fitted
    Limitation: Escaping gas would make the balloon seem less inflated.
    Fix: Secure the balloon with a rubber band or clamp to ensure an airtight seal.

  • Actual amount of yeast could vary if some stuck in the funnel
    Limitation: Unequal yeast amounts could cause uneven fermentation rates.
    Fix: Add yeast directly to the flask or rinse the funnel with water into the flask to ensure all yeast enters.

  • Washing and drying flasks between trials could leave residue or moisture
    Limitation: Leftover residue or moisture could alter the concentration of the mixture.
    Fix: Rinse thoroughly with distilled water and allow flasks to dry completely, or use separate flasks for each trial.

  • The 15-minute duration may have been too short for lower sugar concentrations
    Limitation: The yeast may not have produced measurable gas, making results hard to compare.
    Fix: Extend the fermentation time (e.g., 30 minutes or longer) or measure gas production over multiple time points.