Intellectual Property Notes

Intellectual Property (IP) or Intellectual Property Rights (IPR)

  • The government helps enforce property rights but doesn't seek out violations.
  • You must initiate legal action and pay for attorneys and suits to protect your IP.
  • Damages can be sought to cover legal costs if infringement is proven.
  • Protecting IP is like protecting a house; the government assists after a violation, but you're responsible for initial security measures.
  • Intellectual property is an increasingly vital intangible resource for company value.
  • Brand names can be valued in the billions of dollars.

Using Intellectual Property Rights

  • IP rights can prevent competitors from competing effectively.
  • You can sell or license your IP.
  • IP assures value and creates a distinctive competency.
  • Patents codify knowledge, which can attract investors.
  • You can cash out by selling your intellectual property entirely.

Common Forms of Intellectual Property Rights

  • Trademark/Service Mark: Protects logos, brand names, and images.
  • Copyright: Protects created works such as art, documents, and photos in a physical form.
  • Trade Secret: A secret that gives a business a competitive edge.
  • Patents:
    • Design patents: Protect the physical design of something.
    • Utility patents: Protect how something is used.

Trademarks and Service Marks

  • A word, name, or symbol that identifies a company.
  • Goal: Create a memorable brand image evoking positive associations.
  • Lifespan: Potentially forever if continuously used and renewed.
  • Internationally, trademark rules vary by country.
  • Tips for trademarks:
    • Easy to remember.
    • Unique.
    • Recognizable.
    • File for trademark protection ASAP.
Trademark Protection
  • Use the "TM" superscript to indicate intent to trademark, providing some state-level protection.
  • Actual trademark requires doing business and filing with the USPTO (US Patent and Trademark Office).
  • Filing is relatively inexpensive (a few hundred dollars).
  • Applications are reviewed to ensure it's a real business with evidence like a website and customer base.
  • The paperwork lasts for ten years and must be renewed.
  • Monitor expiration dates to avoid losing trademarks which others may then claim.
  • International trademarks require filing in each country.
  • Obtain domain names and social media accounts quickly to protect your brand.
Trademark Violation
  • Violation occurs if a customer confuses another brand/logo with yours.

Copyrights

  • Protects tangible or intangible works that can be perceived, reproduced, or communicated.
  • Lifespan:
    • Businesses: 120 years from creation.
    • Individuals: 70 years after death of the copyright holder.
  • Protection begins immediately by adding a ©, your name, and the date to your work.
  • Copyright protects the physical form of the work, not the ideas or information within it.
  • The story about Mickey Mouse showed how Disney lobbied to extend copyright laws.

Trade Secrets

  • A secret that gives a company a competitive edge.
  • Companies must actively protect their trade secrets by:
    • Not telling anyone the secret.
    • Requiring those who must know it to sign confidentiality agreements.
    • Marking documents as proprietary trade secrets.
  • Trade secrets are immune from reverse engineering.
  • Trade secrets can be incredibly valuable because if stolen, you can shut down another company that uses it.
  • Trade secrets are different from non-compete agreements.
  • Knowing what does not work can be a trade secret.
Maintaining Trade Secrets
  • Confidentiality.
  • Restricted access.
  • Nondisclosure agreements.
  • Marking documentation.
  • Sharing only with those who absolutely must know.

Patents

  • Patents are expensive and require enforcement.
  • Budget around $10,000 for a good patent attorney.
  • Rejection on the first try is common, necessitating responses and further costs.
  • Lifespan:
    • Utility patents: 20 years.
    • Design patents: 14 years.
  • In exceptional cases, patents might be extended (e.g., pharmaceuticals).
  • Patents disclose everything, allowing competitors to copy after expiration.
  • Anything made by man can be patented if it is non-obvious and novel, but laws of nature cannot be patented.
  • Patents are now awarded to whoever files first, not the original inventor.
  • File in foreign countries within a year to secure international protection.
Joint Patents
  • Multiple patent holders are possible, such as universities.
  • Consult a patent attorney.
  • If you can enforce it, you can shut a competitor down who violates your patent.
  • Licenses and sales generate revenue.
  • Investors look for IP.
Drawbacks of Patents
  • Disclosure of information.
  • Costly.
  • Require defense.
  • This is the the option for doing what the company does.
Strategic Use of Patents
  1. Concentrate on core business activities.
  2. Create a broad patent portfolio to sue or license.
  3. Use patents to block competitors.
  • Companies like Apple and Samsung engage in patent wars.
  • Patent trolls buy patents to sue others.
Learning More About Patents
  • Stopfakes.gov (potentially broken link, but has a comprehensive PDF).
  • uspto.gov (search trademarks, patents).
  • IP attorneys (typically bill around $500/hour).