IL

General Principles

  • Nature and Scope

    • Traditional Concept: A body of rules and principles of actions which are binding upon civilized states in their relations with one another.

    • Modern Concept: International law is a body of legal rules between sovereign states and entities with international personality (Schwarzenberger).

    • Jeremy Bentham: Coined the term "International Law" in 1870, interchangeable with the Laws of Nations.

    • Hugo Grotius: Dutch statesman and the "Father of International Law", author of "The Law of War and Peace" (1625).

Divisions of International Law

  • Grand Divisions:

    • Laws of Peace

    • Laws of War

    • Laws of Neutrality

Distinctions and Relation to Other Law

  • Municipal Law: Issued by a political superior for observance by those under its authority.

  • International Law: Not imposed, but adopted by states as common rules among them; derived from international custom, conventions, and general principles of law.

  • Scope of Law:

    • Municipal law regulates individual relations; international law regulates relations between states and other international persons.

  • Compliance and Violation Resolution:

    • Municipal law violations are addressed locally; international law disputes are resolved through state interactions, including negotiation, arbitration, and sometimes war.

    • Responsibility:

      • Breaches of municipal law entail individual responsibility.

      • Breaches of international law typically entail collective responsibility (directly attaching to states).

Theories of Adoption of International Law

  • Doctrine of Incorporation: International laws are incorporated into municipal law through constitutional recognition.

  • Doctrine of Transformation: International laws must be legislatively enacted to be binding at the state level.

Basis of International Law

  • Naturalist School: Advocates for universal principles of right and wrong that can be recognized through reason (Law of Nature).

  • Positivists: Assert that the binding force of international law comes from the agreement of sovereign states (Consent of States).

  • Eclectics or Grotians: Integrate both natural law and state consent as bases of international law.

Sanctions and Enforcement

  • UN Security Council: Enforce international law under Chapter VII, determining threats to peace and imposing sanctions:

    • Economic: Trade embargoes

    • Diplomatic: Severing diplomatic relations

    • Military: Armed force for peace and security maintenance.

Functions of International Law

  • Objectives:

    • Establish peace and order in the international community.

    • Prevent employment of force (everything from war to minor conflicts).

    • Promote international friendship, aiming to break down barriers of color, creed, or nationality.

    • Encourage cooperation on political, economic, cultural, or humanitarian issues.

    • Manage orderly relations between states based on agreed substantive rules.

Sources of International Law

  • Primary/Direct Sources:

    • Treaties/Conventions: Establishing recognized rules.

    • International Customs: Practices accepted as binding through persistent usage.

    • General Principles of Law: Recognized as just by civilized nations.

  • Secondary/Indirect Sources:

    • Decisions of Courts: Including national and international courts (Art. 38, ICJ Statute).

    • Publicists: Scholarly writings representing international law fairly and accurately.

The International Community

  • Definition: A body of juridical entities governed by international law.

  • Modern Concept: Comprises states and other international persons.

Subject and Object Distinguished

  • Subject of International Law: Entities with rights and responsibilities (international personality).

  • Object of International Law: The person or thing associated with rights and obligations held by the subject.

States

  • Common Definition: Community of persons occupying a defined territory, under their own government, independent of external control.

  • International Law Definition: Group of people in a territory with an independent government, capable of engaging in international relations.

Elements of a State

  • Permanent Population: Human beings residing within territory.

  • Defined Territory: Fixed land area occupied by the population.

  • Government: The agency executing state will and policies.

  • Sovereignty/Independence: Power to manage external affairs without external interference.

Classification of States

  • Independent States: Not subject to external dictation.

    • Simple States: Single centralized government managing internal and external affairs.

    • Composite States: Merged states with separate governments under a central authority.

      • Real union: Merging of states as one entity.

      • Federal union: A new state created from union without retaining independent status.

      • Confederation: States retaining internal sovereignty for limited purposes.

      • Personal union: Multiple states under a single monarch without combined representation.

      • Incorporate union: Central authority managing both internal and external affairs.

  • Dependent States: Entities with limited independence regarding external affairs.

    • Protectorate: Established for protection of weaker states.

    • Suzerainty: Former colonies retaining some powers from the former sovereign.

The United Nations

  • Vatican City:

    • Population: 496 (July 2024).

    • Defined Territory: 0.44 km².

    • Government: The Holy See (church government), led by the Pope.

    • Sovereignty/Independence: Became an independent state on February 11, 1929, by the Lateran Treaty.

Colonies and Dependencies

  • Defined as parts of a parent state with no independent legal standing in international relations; occasionally participate in international undertakings.

Mandates and Trust Territories

  • League of Nations Mandate: Legal status for territories transferred post-World War I.

  • United Nations Trust Territories: Successors to mandates, established in 1946 following the League's cessation.

Belligerent Communities

  • Not sovereign states but with governing capabilities under international law.

International Administrative Bodies

  • Established among states, obtaining international personality if primarily non-political and autonomous.

Individuals

  • Traditional view: States as subjects, individuals as objects.

  • Contemporary view: Individuals recognized as subjects with international rights.