IL
General Principles
Nature and Scope
Traditional Concept: A body of rules and principles of actions which are binding upon civilized states in their relations with one another.
Modern Concept: International law is a body of legal rules between sovereign states and entities with international personality (Schwarzenberger).
Jeremy Bentham: Coined the term "International Law" in 1870, interchangeable with the Laws of Nations.
Hugo Grotius: Dutch statesman and the "Father of International Law", author of "The Law of War and Peace" (1625).
Divisions of International Law
Grand Divisions:
Laws of Peace
Laws of War
Laws of Neutrality
Distinctions and Relation to Other Law
Municipal Law: Issued by a political superior for observance by those under its authority.
International Law: Not imposed, but adopted by states as common rules among them; derived from international custom, conventions, and general principles of law.
Scope of Law:
Municipal law regulates individual relations; international law regulates relations between states and other international persons.
Compliance and Violation Resolution:
Municipal law violations are addressed locally; international law disputes are resolved through state interactions, including negotiation, arbitration, and sometimes war.
Responsibility:
Breaches of municipal law entail individual responsibility.
Breaches of international law typically entail collective responsibility (directly attaching to states).
Theories of Adoption of International Law
Doctrine of Incorporation: International laws are incorporated into municipal law through constitutional recognition.
Doctrine of Transformation: International laws must be legislatively enacted to be binding at the state level.
Basis of International Law
Naturalist School: Advocates for universal principles of right and wrong that can be recognized through reason (Law of Nature).
Positivists: Assert that the binding force of international law comes from the agreement of sovereign states (Consent of States).
Eclectics or Grotians: Integrate both natural law and state consent as bases of international law.
Sanctions and Enforcement
UN Security Council: Enforce international law under Chapter VII, determining threats to peace and imposing sanctions:
Economic: Trade embargoes
Diplomatic: Severing diplomatic relations
Military: Armed force for peace and security maintenance.
Functions of International Law
Objectives:
Establish peace and order in the international community.
Prevent employment of force (everything from war to minor conflicts).
Promote international friendship, aiming to break down barriers of color, creed, or nationality.
Encourage cooperation on political, economic, cultural, or humanitarian issues.
Manage orderly relations between states based on agreed substantive rules.
Sources of International Law
Primary/Direct Sources:
Treaties/Conventions: Establishing recognized rules.
International Customs: Practices accepted as binding through persistent usage.
General Principles of Law: Recognized as just by civilized nations.
Secondary/Indirect Sources:
Decisions of Courts: Including national and international courts (Art. 38, ICJ Statute).
Publicists: Scholarly writings representing international law fairly and accurately.
The International Community
Definition: A body of juridical entities governed by international law.
Modern Concept: Comprises states and other international persons.
Subject and Object Distinguished
Subject of International Law: Entities with rights and responsibilities (international personality).
Object of International Law: The person or thing associated with rights and obligations held by the subject.
States
Common Definition: Community of persons occupying a defined territory, under their own government, independent of external control.
International Law Definition: Group of people in a territory with an independent government, capable of engaging in international relations.
Elements of a State
Permanent Population: Human beings residing within territory.
Defined Territory: Fixed land area occupied by the population.
Government: The agency executing state will and policies.
Sovereignty/Independence: Power to manage external affairs without external interference.
Classification of States
Independent States: Not subject to external dictation.
Simple States: Single centralized government managing internal and external affairs.
Composite States: Merged states with separate governments under a central authority.
Real union: Merging of states as one entity.
Federal union: A new state created from union without retaining independent status.
Confederation: States retaining internal sovereignty for limited purposes.
Personal union: Multiple states under a single monarch without combined representation.
Incorporate union: Central authority managing both internal and external affairs.
Dependent States: Entities with limited independence regarding external affairs.
Protectorate: Established for protection of weaker states.
Suzerainty: Former colonies retaining some powers from the former sovereign.
The United Nations
Vatican City:
Population: 496 (July 2024).
Defined Territory: 0.44 km².
Government: The Holy See (church government), led by the Pope.
Sovereignty/Independence: Became an independent state on February 11, 1929, by the Lateran Treaty.
Colonies and Dependencies
Defined as parts of a parent state with no independent legal standing in international relations; occasionally participate in international undertakings.
Mandates and Trust Territories
League of Nations Mandate: Legal status for territories transferred post-World War I.
United Nations Trust Territories: Successors to mandates, established in 1946 following the League's cessation.
Belligerent Communities
Not sovereign states but with governing capabilities under international law.
International Administrative Bodies
Established among states, obtaining international personality if primarily non-political and autonomous.
Individuals
Traditional view: States as subjects, individuals as objects.
Contemporary view: Individuals recognized as subjects with international rights.