Postcolonialism Summary
Colonialism
Colonialism is defined as “the conquest, domination, subjugation, and exploitation of primarily non-western people and lands by European powers” (Shampa Biswas, “Postcolonialism” in Tim Dunne et al, International Relations Theories. 4th ed. OUP: 2016).
By the early 20th century, major European powers, especially Britain, had vast empires.
The territories seized were known as colonies in Africa, Asia, and elsewhere.
Examples include British colonies like India, Kenya, and Nigeria; the French colony of Algeria; and the Portuguese colony of Mozambique.
Decolonisation
After World War II, most colonies gained independence, becoming post-colonial states.
Postcolonialism addresses how these states aimed to construct an identity and counter derogatory Western views of their history and culture.
It emphasizes the colonial experience as the root of current global inequalities.
Post-Colonialism
It aims to rectify the “Eurocentric bias” in International Relations (IR) theory.
It challenges the idea that the “West” is the “primary subject of world history.”
It questions the association of the West solely with values of freedom and equality.
Postcolonialism highlights the extensive violence used by Europeans in their colonies, often downplayed in official narratives.
It emphasizes the role of illiberal ideologies in the West, such as fascism, Nazism, white supremacism, and nationalist populism.
legacy- artificial borders, ethnic conflicts, civil war
cultural superiority of west- erasing identity
IMF- loans , structural adjusment programs (SAP)- means states have to open up/adopt westeren style economy , privitaization -which means foerign investors strip assests from these nations
dominance of the US dollar (linked to hegemony) weaken african currencies
reperation
Edward Said
In his book Orientalism, Edward Said examined Western attitudes toward the Orient.
Western discourse represented the Orient as backward, traditional, and despotic, while Western societies were seen as advanced, modernized, and democratic.
The cultural superiority of the West is deeply ingrained (e.g., Niall Ferguson’s claim in The West and the Rest that “West is best”).
This view legitimized Western dominance over the Orient to lead it to modernity.
The Western perspective of the Orient justified the exercise of Western power.
The “Third World”
The term “Third World,” coined by French scholar Alfred Sauvy in 1952, is now less commonly used.
The “First World” included developed capitalist countries in Western Europe, North America, and Australasia.
The “Second World” referred to the USSR and its allies in Eastern Europe.
“Third World” countries were typically former colonies located in Asia, Africa, and Latin America, and were less economically developed.
The term “Third World” implies a hierarchy, suggesting it is third in importance and peripheral to the main course of world history, which originates and bears a European imprint.
The Cold War
The “Cold War” refers to the superpower confrontation between the USSR and USA that did not result in direct military conflict.
US conservative historian John Lewis Gaddis described the Cold War as “The Long Peace,” a Western perspective.
The Cold War was not “cold” in many parts of the “Third World,” such as Vietnam, Indonesia, Nicaragua, and Angola.
The bipolar balance of power during the Cold War is viewed as having produced global “stability,” but much of the “Third World” experienced instability during this period.
The Democratic Peace Theory
The democratic peace theory asserts that liberal democracies do not engage in war with each other due to economic interdependence and shared values.
However, liberal democracies are fairly violent toward the “Third World,” even in the 21st century, as seen in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Syria.
Naïve attempts to “export democracy” to these countries by force have comprehensively failed at significant cost.
Western images of the third world
The “Third World” is portrayed in the Western imagination:
As “failed states,” the origin of terrorism, genocide, ethnic cleansing, etc.
As passive recipients of charity from self-congratulatory Western benefactors, such as UN agencies and INGOs, seen as heirs of Christian missionaries.
As committed to backward and illiberal practices, including political corruption, misogyny, torture, and human rights abuses.
Occasionally, as countries commended for economic development by following the Western example.
Ukraine
The current conflict in Ukraine reveals that Ukrainian refugees, being white and European, are treated differently from refugees from Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq, etc.
Shampa Biswas refers to the “differential distribution of human valuations,” indicating that some lives are valued less.
Focus
Postcolonialism is not a theory of International Relations but a different focus and perspective.
It involves viewing issues without prioritizing Western perspectives and according value to the traditions and culture of postcolonial societies.
It involves recovering lost or neglected histories.
For example, Caroline Elkins’s book Britain’s Gulag recounts the British colonial regime’s repression in Kenya, and Mike Davis’s book Late Victorian Holocausts examines the growth of capitalism and global climate patterns, describing the Indian famines under colonial rule as “genocide.”
Pluralising IR
The main thrust of postcolonialism has been to pluralize the study of IR.
It opens up new perspectives.
It shifts the perspective towards questions of Third World inequality and racial justice.
According to Shampa Biswas, we need to “…enhance the story-telling opportunities for those whose voices have not counted so far.”