Week 9: Imperialism 2 (Imperialism Today)
Key Language and Concepts
Imports and Exports: Movement of goods into (imports) and out of (exports) a country.
Trade Deals: Agreements between countries to facilitate trade, often involving specific terms and conditions.
Free Trade: An economic policy where the government does not interfere with international trade, allowing goods and services to be traded with minimal barriers.
Globalisation: The process by which businesses, cultures, and economies become interconnected on an international scale.
Commercialism: An economic system in which trade and commercial interests are prioritized or commercialized.
Neo-colonialism: Modern forms of colonial practices in which powerful countries exert indirect control over weaker nations through economic, political, or cultural influence.
Debt and Aid Dependency: A condition whereby countries rely heavily on foreign aid and financial borrowings, resulting in a cycle of dependency.
Reflective Questions
What do you understand by the term ‘neo-colonialism’? How do the examples in the texts exemplify this concept?
What links does Alan Jay Spector make between globalisation and imperialism?
What do you think Glen Segell means when he writes that Iran and Turkey have “compromised the governance of African states” through neo-colonialism?
Leila Ahmed writes about how the nineteenth-century British colonisers criticised Islam in Egypt, particularly the wearing of the veil by Muslim women. How can such narratives impact today’s world?
What role has culture played in Imperialism? To what extent does this align with Said’s theory of Orientalism? What examples can you find to support your answer?
Text 1: Alan Jay Spector (2007) - Globalisation or Imperialism?
Author Background: Alan Jay Spector is a Professor Emeritus at Purdue University Northwest with a focus on race, ethnic diversity, introductory sociology, social problems, and international change.
Globalisation and Imperialism
Nature of Globalisation: Portrayed as an expansion of 'freedom' allowing for investment and trade across borders without interference.
Capital Movement: Agencies support the unrestricted flow of capital, goods, and sometimes labour.
Narrative of Equality: Advanced and less-developed countries are said to benefit equally in the “free market.”
Reality of Competition: The idea of 'competition' in unregulated economies’ allows stronger entities to dictate terms, perpetuating and intensifying inequality.
Loans from Financial Institutions: Less-developed countries must open their markets and surrender local businesses to foreign investors to secure loans from the World Bank and IMF.
Example: The US may sell surplus corn at low prices, undermining local agricultural profits in developing countries.
Case Studies:
Ethiopia: Identified as the poorest large nation, suffering economically despite its cheap labour.
Ghana: Its textile industry is being undermined by Chinese competitors who replicate local designs.
Economic Reforms and Consequences
Economic Liberalisation: Demand to privatise and deregulate economies leads to adverse effects, including:
Loss of publicly-owned resources.
Increased costs for essential services, such as water, that were previously free.
Worsening economic inefficiency as governments are left with less productive sectors.
Societal implications include wage reductions and cuts to public-sector jobs, leading to mass migration from rural to urban areas.
Labor Market Impacts
Global Labour Auction: Workers in developed nations face wage declines due to competition with labour in less-developed countries.
Political Implications: The changing labour dynamics can affect political stability and class structures in wealthier nations.
Text 2: Glen Segell (2019) - Neo-Colonialism in Africa
Author Information: Glen Segell is a Visiting Professor with research focuses in political studies and governance, particularly regarding neo-colonial practices.
Neo-Colonialism Defined
Core Arguments:
Neo-colonialism is exhibited through states like Turkey and Iran, which exploit Africa similarly to historical colonial powers.
Key Motivations:
Turkey: Engages in economic exploitation (for gold).
Iran: Undertakes religious influence, asserting ideological control (for g-d).
Benefits and Asymmetry:
Colonial-like practices do not yield sustainable development for Africa, resulting in dependency without mutual benefit.
Consequences of Neo-Colonial Relationships
Compromised Governance: African leaders become reliant on Iranian and Turkish agendas, establishing a one-sided dependency.
Historical Continuity: The exploitation of average citizens resides at the heart of these modern neo-colonial practices.
Text 3: Leila Ahmed (2021) - Women and Gender in Islam
Author Background: Leila Ahmed studies women's roles in Arab Muslim societies and has made significant contributions to discussions of gender in Islam.
British Colonial Influence
Colonial Economic Direction: British occupation (1882) intended to reshape Egypt’s economy to serve British industrial needs.
Cultural Contestation: The colonial agenda heavily criticised Islamic practices concerning women, focusing specifically on the veil as a symbol.
Evolving Narratives on Women in Islamexplain this with evidence form the pdf:
Colonialism and Women: European narratives framed Islam as inherently oppressive to women, using these perspectives to justify colonial dominance.
Victorian Feminism: The appropriation of feminist rhetoric by colonial powers served to legitimise their dominance over 'Other' cultures, particularly Islam.
Lord Cromer’s Views: Highlighted Islam's perceived oppression of women as an obstacle to modernisation. His policies often restricted education and advancement for women, even as he criticised their condition.
Glossary of Key Terms
Asymmetrical: Unequal or unbalanced relationships.
Dependency: A state of reliance on another for resources or support.
Destabilization: Creating instability in political or social contexts.
Epitomized: Perfectly representing something.
Fraught: Filled with tension or problems.
Globalization: Interconnection of businesses and cultures worldwide.
Immutably: Permanently unchangeable.
Intrinsic: Essential or natural to something.
Liberalizing: Reducing strictness of laws or systems.
Modernization: Adoption of modern practices and technologies.
Neo-colonialism: Indirect control by powerful nations over weaker ones.
Paradigm: A typical example or framework.
Paternalistic: Making decisions for others under the guise of their welfare.
Periphery: Less important or poorer regions in contrast to wealthier core areas.
Privatise: To transfer ownership from public to private sectors.
Quintessential: The most perfect example.
Rhetoric: Language intended to influence or persuade, often seen as lacking genuine intent.
Substantiated: Supported with evidence.
Surreptitiously: Conducted secretly.
Transnational: Operating across national borders.