Presidential Reconstruction Study Notes

Post-Civil War Southern Life and the Destitution of Freedpeople

  • Impact of Emancipation on Freed African Americans:

    • Approximately 4,000,0004,000,000 emancipated slaves found themselves without money or homes at the end of the Civil War.

    • Former slave Parke Johnston recalled the abrupt transition to freedom: "It came so sudden on 'em… Just think of whole droves of people, that had always been kept so close, and hardly ever left the plantation before, turned loose all at once, with nothing in the world, but what they had on their backs."

    • Despite facing overwhelming obstacles, most freedpeople looked eagerly to the future and yearned to enjoy their "rights in common with other men," as expressed by former slave Henry Turner.

    • Freedpeople prioritized forming their own churches and schools, legalizing their marriages, and choosing their own livelihoods rather than working as servants or field hands for others.

    • A central goal was reuniting with family members who had been sold away during slavery. For example, former slave Hawkins Wilson sent a letter to his sister Jane (address unknown): "Dear Sister Jane, Your little brother Hawkins is trying to find out where you are and where his poor old mother is-Let me know and I will come to see you-I shall never forget the bag of biscuits you made for me…. Please send me some of Julia's hair whom I left a baby in the cradle when I was torn away from you."

    • Commemorative artwork, such as a family record titled "FAMILY RECORD BEFORE THE WAR AND SINCE" showing a prosperous African American family, was produced by publishers like The Granger Collection in New York and marketed to former slaves after the war.

  • Land Ownership Aspirations and "40 Acres and a Mule":

    • Access to land was seen by freedpeople as essential to supporting themselves, securing economic independence, and protecting their freedom.

    • Free black Garrison Frazier stated that African Americans hoped "to have land, and turn it and till it by our own labor."

    • Former slave Bayley Wyat asserted a moral and historical right to land: "Our wives, our children, our husbands, has been sold over and over again to purchase the lands we now locates upon; we have a divine right to the land."

    • In January 1865, General William T. Sherman encouraged land ownership expectations by ordering part of South Carolina to be divided into 40-acre40\text{-acre} parcels and given to freedmen.

    • Persistent rumors spread throughout the region that the federal government would give each freedman "40 acres40\text{ acres} and a mule."

    • Newly freed slaves were documented working on agricultural projects, such as planting sweet potatoes on plantations at Hilton Head, South Carolina.

  • Physical Devastation and White Despair in the South:

    • The Union army laid waste to vast areas of the South by destroying railroad lines, blowing up bridges and wells, and stripping Confederate homes, barns, and gardens.

    • Major southern cities lay in ruins, including Richmond, Virginia (photographed in 1865 showing destroyed districts) and Columbia, South Carolina (described by a visitor as "a wilderness of crumbling walls, naked chimneys, and trees killed by flames").

    • Planters still owned land, but found their world "literally kicked to pieces." Mary Boykin Chesnut, the wife of a Confederate officer, described the despair felt by white southerners: "We are shut in here-turned with our faces to a dead wall. No mails. A letter is sometimes brought by a man on horseback, traveling through the wilderness made by Sherman…. We are cut off from the world-to eat out our own hearts."

    • Disease, hunger, and bad sanitation swept across the South. Illness ravaged cities where families lived in makeshift shelters, and thousands died in the year after the war.

International Perspectives on Emancipation

  • Czar Alexander II's Criticism of American Emancipation:

    • In 1861, two years before President Abraham Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, Czar Alexander II of Russia promised freedom and land to more than 20,000,00020,000,000 Russian serfs.

    • Although the czar's own land policies eventually failed, in 1879 Alexander II criticized Lincoln's decree for sidestepping the issue of land reform.

    • Czar Alexander II stated in 1879: "did more for the Russian serf in giving him land as well as personal liberty, than America did for the Negro slave set free by the Proclamation of President Lincoln. I am at a loss to understand how you Americans could have been so blind as to leave the Negro slave without tools to work out his salvation…. Without property of any kind he cannot educate himself and his children. I believe the time must come when many will question the manner of American emancipation of the Negro slaves in 1863."

Lincoln's Reconstruction Plan and Opposition

  • President Lincoln's Vision and the 10 Percent Plan:

    • President Abraham Lincoln sought to preserve the Union and rebuild the former Confederate states rather than destroy the South.

    • On December 8, 1863, Lincoln issued the Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction, offering amnesty (a full pardon) to all southerners (except high-ranking Confederate leaders and a few others) who swore allegiance to the U.S. Constitution and accepted federal laws on slavery.

    • Under Lincoln's "10%10\% Plan," a state could rejoin the Union when 10%10\% of the state's residents who had voted in 1860 swore a loyalty oath to the United States.

    • Lincoln favored a flexible and lenient policy toward former Confederates.

  • Congressional Opposition and the Wade-Davis Bill:

    • Members of Congress objected to the 10%10\% Plan because they did not trust former rebels to become loyal citizens or protect the rights of former slaves, and believed Congress should shape Reconstruction policy.

    • In July 1864, Congress passed the Wade-Davis Bill, which set stricter readmission requirements:

    • Former Confederate states were required to abolish slavery.

    • A majority (>50%>50\%) of each state's white male population had to take a loyalty oath.

    • Lincoln vetoed the Wade-Davis Bill because he was not ready to "be inflexibly committed to any single plan of restoration."

  • Second Inaugural Address and Lincoln's Assassination:

    • On March 4, 1865, photographer Mathew Brady captured Lincoln delivering his Second Inaugural Address, where Lincoln outlined his goal for Reconstruction: "With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on… to bind up the nation's wounds… to do all which may achieve and cherish a just and lasting peace."

    • On April 14, 1865, just days after General Robert E. Lee's surrender, John Wilkes Booth, a half-crazed Confederate sympathizer, shot Lincoln as he watched a play at Washington's Ford Theatre.

    • Lincoln died early the following morning, April 15, 1865.

    • Following the assassination, the War Department offered a reward of $100,000\$100,000 ($50,000\$50,000 offered directly by the War Department alongside other offers) for the capture of John Wilkes Booth, distributing posters showing Booth's image and the pistol used in the murder.

    • Thousands of Americans stood beside railroad tracks as Lincoln's funeral train traveled from Washington to his burial site in Illinois.

Presidential Reconstruction Under Andrew Johnson

  • Andrew Johnson's Background and Character:

    • Following Lincoln's death, Vice President Andrew Johnson became president (1865–18691865\text{--}1869).

    • Johnson (1808–18751808\text{--}1875) was a Democrat, a former slaveholder, and a former U.S. senator from Tennessee who served as Tennessee's military governor during the war.

    • He had been selected as Lincoln's vice presidential candidate on the 1864 Republican/Union campaign poster ticket to appeal to northern Democrats and southern Unionists.

    • Johnson was a self-made man whose father died when he was 33 years old. Apprenticed to a tailor, he ran away to Tennessee. He never attended school; his wife later taught him to write and perform simple arithmetic.

    • Johnson succeeded as a tailor, bought property, but aligned himself with small farmers and artisans rather than the planter class ("Andy Johnson never went back on his raisin'"). He made his own clothes until moving to Washington and visited tailor shops while president.

    • Johnson suffered from "almost unconquerable prejudices against the African race," lacked Lincoln's tact and political skill, and refused to compromise.

  • Johnson's Reconstruction Policy:

    • Initially, Johnson pleased Republicans by denouncing treason and suggesting Jefferson Davis and high-ranking Confederates be hanged. Senator Ben Wade of Ohio stated: "Johnson, we have faith in you. By the gods, there will be no trouble now in running this government."

    • In May 1865, Johnson executed an about-face and issued a blanket pardon to all former rebels except ex-Confederate officeholders and the richest planters, whom he pardoned freely on an individual basis.

    • For readmission to the Union, Johnson required states to:

    • Nullify their acts of secession.

    • Abolish slavery.

    • Refuse to pay Confederate government debts (to penalize wealthy southerners who financed the Confederacy).

  • Southern Reaction and Johnson's Support:

    • Johnson's plan permitted former Confederate leaders to dominate new state legislatures; some even wore their Confederate uniforms while in office.

    • Supporting "a white man's government," Johnson removed black Union soldiers from the South when southern leaders complained of the "painful humiliation" caused by their presence.

    • When Mississippi refused to ratify the Thirteenth Amendment (passed by Congress in January 1865 to abolish slavery), Johnson recognized its new state government regardless.

The Black Codes and Restitution of White Control

  • Enactment and Purpose of the Black Codes:

    • Encouraged by Johnson's leniency, southern legislatures passed black codes limiting former slaves' freedom, which African Americans denounced as "a disgrace to civilization."

    • These laws reestablished white control over black labor after planters complained that without slaves, "our fields everywhere lie untilled" (April 1865).

    • Mississippi used its old slave code verbatim, replacing the word "slave" with "freedman."

  • Specific Statutory Restrictions:

    • Meetings: African Americans could not hold meetings unless white citizens were present.

    • Movement and Weapons: Blacks were prohibited from traveling without permits or owning guns.

    • Curfews: In New Orleans, blacks were banned from streets after 10:00 PM10:00\text{ PM} (one hour later than prewar slave curfews). The editor of the city's black newspaper noted: "This additional hour is the fruit of our victories in the field. Four years of a bloody war have been fought to gain that one hour."

    • Urban Residence: Local codes prohibited blacks from living in towns unless they were employed as servants.

    • Labor Contracts: South Carolina and Mississippi required freedpeople to sign 12-month12\text{-month} labor contracts. Refusal to sign allowed authorities to arrest freedpeople and auction their labor for the year. A black veteran demanded: "If you call this Freedom, what do you call Slavery?"

  • Northern Reaction:

    • Northerners angrily condemned the codes. The Chicago Tribune reprinted the Mississippi code and declared: "The men of the North will convert the State of Mississippi into a frog pond before they will allow such laws to disgrace one foot of soil in which the bones of our soldiers sleep and over which the flag of freedom waves."

    • The task of ending the rule of "white-washed rebels" fell to Congress.

Questions & Discussion

  • Section 1 Review Identifications & Key Terms:

    • Reconstruction: The post-Civil War process of rebuilding former Confederate states and restoring the Union.

    • Amnesty: An official, full pardon granted by the federal government for political offenses or treason.

    • John Wilkes Booth: The Confederate sympathizer who assassinated President Abraham Lincoln at Ford's Theatre on April 14, 1865.

    • Andrew Johnson: The 17th U.S. President (1865–18691865\text{--}1869), a Tennessee Democrat who led Presidential Reconstruction following Lincoln's death.

    • Thirteenth Amendment: The constitutional amendment passed by Congress in January 1865 that abolished slavery throughout the United States.

    • Black Codes: Southern state laws enacted after the war that restricted African Americans' freedom and forced them into agricultural labor contracts.

  • Section 1 Main Ideas and Review Questions:

    • What was southern life like after the Civil War?

    • Physical cities were devastated (e.g., Richmond and Columbia), farmlands and infrastructure were destroyed, and widespread disease and poverty caused thousands of deaths. Emancipated slaves possessed no money, homes, or land, while former planters faced economic ruin and loss of labor.

    • Under Johnson's Reconstruction plan, how could states gain readmission to the Union?

    • States were required to nullify their acts of secession, abolish slavery, and refuse to pay Confederate government debts.

    • How did Congress's plan for Reconstruction differ from Lincoln's?

    • Lincoln favored a lenient 10%10\% loyalty oath requirement to restore state governments quickly, whereas Congress passed the Wade-Davis Bill requiring a majority (>50%>50\%) of white males to swear loyalty and explicitly requiring states to abolish slavery before rejoining the Union.

    • Writing to Describe: How did the black codes affect the daily lives of newly emancipated slaves?

    • Black codes prohibited free movement without permits, barred public gatherings without white supervision, banned town residences without servant contracts, imposed strict evening curfews, and mandated 12-month12\text{-month} labor contracts under threat of forced labor auctions.

    • Evaluating: Why would "40 acres and a mule" be important to a freed slave?

    • Land ownership represented financial independence, economic self-sufficiency, protection from forced labor contracts, and tangible compensation for generations of uncompensated slave labor.