ACR102 Week 1 Seminar – Admin, Expectations & Foundational Questions

Seminar Logistics & Expectations

  • First session of ACR102 “Introducing Crime & Criminal Justice” (online evening seminar)

  • Lecturer: Flynn (Associate Lecturer, expertise in historical & theoretical criminology)

  • Primary aim of week-1 seminar: housekeeping + community building

  • Core classroom principle: student safety & comfort

    • Respectful language & questioning; anticipate sensitive content (e.g., crime, punishment, victimisation)

    • Students may: skip questions, mute/turn camera off, leave seminar, or miss a week without penalty

  • Zoom etiquette

    • Cameras encouraged for richer discussion but optional

    • Chat available for quiet participation; lecturer monitors chat

  • Attendance policy

    • No compulsory attendance in this unit (Deakin-wide policy)

    • Late entry / early exit acceptable without explanation

  • Contacting staff: email addresses in unit site & guide (Flynn, Dr. Chris Lehnkn—unit chair, Dr. Jackson Wood)

Unit Staff & Consultation

  • Dr. Chris Lehnkn (Unit Chair)

    • Handles "serious" admin matters; consultations by appointment

  • Dr. Jackson Wood (lecturer for on-campus cohorts; consultations by appointment)

  • Students on multiple campuses (Burwood, Waurn Ponds) and Cloud mode access recordings from both lecturers

Seminar Pedagogy & Participation

  • Flynn’s style: low-didactic, high-discussion

    • Wants less “lecturing at” and more collective analysis

    • Around week 44 a survey will gauge learning preferences; seminar format can be tweaked

  • Students urged to share ideas, examples, critiques; disagreement welcomed when respectful

Readings & Study Materials

  • "Gold standard": complete weekly set reading

    • Realistic fallback: at least one point of contact (skim intro/conclusion, keyword search, etc.)

  • Prescribed text: single core textbook chapter per week (Flynn praises clarity & scope)

  • Unit site resources

    • Weekly Study Guide (summary + key terms)

    • Recommended readings for extension or assessment depth

  • Reading tip: maintain a brief reading log to support assessment tasks later

Assessments Overview (4-piece scaffold)

  • Assessment 1: Diagnostic Task 10%10\% (≈ 400400 words) – exploratory, due TBA

  • Assessment 2: 20%20\% – details on unit site

  • Assessment 3: 30%30\% – skill-building toward final essay

  • Assessment 4: Research Essay 40%40\% (end of trimester)

  • All prompts & marking rubrics already live; Flynn will deep-dive near each due date

Student Support Resources

  • Criminology @ Deakin blog (discipline news, staff profiles)

  • Deakin Student Support services

    • Study skill workshops (writing, referencing, time mgmt.)

    • Language & Learning Advisers; Student Union programs

  • Health & Well-being

    • Free/confidential counselling & welfare; possible wait-lists

    • SafeZone app for on-campus first aid & security

  • Emergencies / after-hours numbers supplied on slides

Ice-Breaker Insights: Class Diversity

  • Participants hail from Melbourne, Mornington Peninsula, Wangaratta, Mildura, Adelaide, Brisbane, Darwin, Orange (NSW), Croatia, California, South Africa, New Zealand, etc.

  • Age range: school-age (Deakin Accelerate Program) through mature-age returners

  • Vocational variety: retail, psychology majors, law double degrees, NT police officer, VicPol admin officer, mental-health sector professional

  • Shared interests: dogs (greyhounds & spaniels), movies ("Breaking Bad", The Dark Knight), weightlifting, drawing, literature ("ACOTAR" series)

  • Purpose of the exercise → building trust for discussing difficult criminological topics

Complexity of the Criminal Justice System (CJS)

  • Visual slide: multi-stage flow diagram (not exhaustive)

    1. Occurrence of criminal/deviant act

    2. Detection / citizen or agency reporting

    3. Police response, investigation, discretion

    4. Arrest / charge / bail or remand

    5. Arraignment & court listing

    6. Trial or plea negotiations

    7. Sentencing (custodial, community, reparative, therapeutic)

    8. Correctional supervision (prison/probation/parole) & possible appeals

  • Multiple decision nodes, overlapping jurisdictions, private vs public actors, historical change in procedures

Student-Shared CJS Encounters (Empirical Vignettes)

  • Ava: Car stolen/damaged → months-long police investigation → offenders identified → court → restitution via insurance → low-security prison ≈6\approx 6 months; felt “out of the loop”

  • Bridget: Workplace shoplifting (no CCTV) → police called → rare on-site arrest → now preparing witness statement

  • Peter (NT): Active police officer – offers “other side of the ledger”; experiences with investigative steps & paperwork

  • Con: VicPol admin – prepares briefs, ensures disclosure compliance; heavy documentation workload

  • Michelle: Mental-health professional – police interplay with emergency departments, forensic orders, absconding clients → motivation for criminology study

  • Key emergent themes

    • Process opacity: victims often uninformed of backstage work

    • Paperwork & disclosure dominate modern policing time

    • Discretion at every stage (whether to charge, what to cite, diversion options)

    • Inter-agency intersections: policing ↔ mental health; policing ↔ retail security; policing ↔ insurance

    • Historical shift from community-embedded policing to bureaucratised, "behind-the-scenes" models

Defining “Justice” – Foundational Questions Raised

  • Why are there quotation marks around “justice”? → contested concept, varies by stakeholder

  • Potential models

    1. Retributive (punishment-oriented)

    2. Restorative (repair harm, dialogue)

    3. Procedural (fair process valued over outcome)

    4. Distributive (equity in outcomes across groups)

  • Guiding questions for the trimester

    • What counts as a "crime" and who defines it?

    • How do power, culture, and history shape criminalisation and victimisation?

    • Do current institutions deliver justice? For whom and why (or why not)?

    • What alternatives exist (e.g., Aboriginal justice forums, therapeutic jurisprudence)?

Media & Public Perception

  • Most people lack firsthand CJS contact → knowledge shaped by media, film/TV (e.g., The Mentalist, Brooklyn 99, You, Breaking Bad)

  • Pop-culture portrayals influence expectations (speed of investigations, forensic infallibility, policing hero narratives, courtroom drama)

  • Students encouraged to reflect on personal media consumption vs. real-world processes

Ethical & Practical Implications Discussed

  • Necessity of safeguarding emotional well-being when tackling traumatic material

  • Importance of critical debate even when uncomfortable

  • Diversity enriches discussion; differences in age, profession, and geography produce richer criminological insights

Immediate Action Points / Next Steps

  • Acquire/read Week-1 textbook chapter before lecture replay; skim if pressed for time

  • Explore unit site: locate Study Guide, assessment rubrics, support links

  • Note down personal questions about Assessment-1 (Flynn will deep-dive next week)

  • Self-reflect: How have films, series, news outlets shaped your mental image of the justice system? Prepare to discuss

  • Optional: download SafeZone if studying on-campus

Key Numerical References

  • 1414 initial seminar participants (approx.)

  • Assessment weighting ladder: 10%→20%→30%→40%10\% \rightarrow 20\% \rightarrow 30\% \rightarrow 40\%

  • Diagnostic task length: 400400 words

  • Week 44 feedback survey planned

  • Ava’s offenders: custodial term ≈6\approx 6 months

  • Retail distance example: Wangaratta ∼45\sim 45-minute drive south of Albury

  • Student age example: Damien 2727 years

Summary Take-Home Message

The opening seminar establishes a safe, flexible, discussion-oriented learning space, introduces staff & resources, previews assessments, and invites students to interrogate their own experiences and media-formed perceptions of an intricate criminal justice system where the meaning of “justice” is anything but settled.